Should I Take This Job Offer?

Brookstone

Active member
Sep 11, 2004
1,600
2
38
So I havent worked FT in about 9 months now. Previous work, great place/employer, but job itselft wasnt the best. Not challenging enough and no room to grow. You know when you get that feeling of you just dont want to be there anymore. So I left, travelled a bit, just took it easy, rethink my options etc.

But when i started looking for a new job again, i totally did not think it would be that hard. Maybe its just me but idk. Very surprised. So i ended up going with an agency (which i tried to avoid at first) a while back, they actually contacted me for something else that didnt go thru.

Now, i'm looking for work that could lead to permanent FT. Like how you get hired but have a 3 month probation period type of thing.
They set me up for an interview with a big name/brand, very popular, that you see in your supermarket/stores. Interview went great, but I was kinda disappointed when i was told this was an on going temp situation. The company at the moment, have no room to hire anyone new perm FT. So this could be a 3month, 6month, 1year etc. type of thing.

My rep think i should take it as he believes i will get hired on at some point as long as you prove yourself. Assured me they are very good to their employees and recognize talent.
But what worries me is the fact that the company has no openings to hire anyone at the moment. Thats my main concern.
So who knows when the next person is going to retire or leave right?

I dont mind being a temp for 3-6 months with possibility of getting hired, but something ongoing, for say a year +, not my definition of temp. Not really beneficial to me in long run, you know what i mean

Other than the fact that i need a steady job/income at the moment. Long term wise, is this a chance worth taking?
 
If I were you I would take it and keep looking. You are always in a stronger position having a job then looking for another one. One thing you have to be careful with is the what sort of guarantee your "agent" has with the company.

I took a job one time and I worked for a few weeks, it was a great job but the people and commute didn't do it for me. When I resigned to take another position my "agent" freaked, apparently he had a guarantee with my employer he didn't tell me about. I think he had to give back his commission. He threatened to black list me with all the other agencies in T.O. Just something to be aware of.
 
I find that the best jobs in the world go to people in this order:

1) Internal Employees get first crack at them
2) External Candidates, who are working at other companies
3) External Candidates, who are unemployed

Milhouse, you mentioned you need some income coming in at the moment, I would take the job and keep looking. You'll be much more marketable when you're working.

As for your what your "rep" says, (I'm thinking this is a placement agency). Keep in mind that their clients are the companies. The job seekers are merely candidates. They usually have the interest of the company in mind when giving "advice" to job seekers, and the usually net a nice fee if one of their candidates are hired on by the company.

With that said, I think you should take the job. Long term wise, this may not work out, but you're putting yourself in a better situation to land something permanent.
 
I guess you might consider your other offers................What is that???????? There are none??????????

It is a temp position. Take it and keep looking
 
Actually it's the perfect job. Take it.

It's horrible looking for a permanent career type job when you are out of work. Too tempting to take the first offer you get just because you have no money coming in.

In my opinion you should always contract out something short term and then go look for the full time work. That way you have some bucks rolling in and you can evaluate permanent job offers carefully and only take the one that really is best for you.

My attitude when I'm looking for work is I'll take any sort of contract that comes along. Anything, so long as it is temporary/contract.

Then I start a careful job search and keep on looking until I find the fulltime/perm position that I think will really build up my career the next step.

Takes some confidence to say "no" to all the things that come along while I'm doing that search.. the kind of confidence you get from having a cheque to cash.
 
milhouse said:
So I havent worked FT in about 9 months now. Previous work, great place/employer, but job itselft wasnt the best. Not challenging enough and no room to grow. You know when you get that feeling of you just dont want to be there anymore. So I left, travelled a bit, just took it easy, rethink my options etc.

But when i started looking for a new job again, i totally did not think it would be that hard. Maybe its just me but idk. Very surprised. So i ended up going with an agency (which i tried to avoid at first) a while back, they actually contacted me for something else that didnt go thru.

Now, i'm looking for work that could lead to permanent FT. Like how you get hired but have a 3 month probation period type of thing.
They set me up for an interview with a big name/brand, very popular, that you see in your supermarket/stores. Interview went great, but I was kinda disappointed when i was told this was an on going temp situation. The company at the moment, have no room to hire anyone new perm FT. So this could be a 3month, 6month, 1year etc. type of thing.

My rep think i should take it as he believes i will get hired on at some point as long as you prove yourself. Assured me they are very good to their employees and recognize talent.
But what worries me is the fact that the company has no openings to hire anyone at the moment. Thats my main concern.
So who knows when the next person is going to retire or leave right?

I dont mind being a temp for 3-6 months with possibility of getting hired, but something ongoing, for say a year +, not my definition of temp. Not really beneficial to me in long run, you know what i mean

Other than the fact that i need a steady job/income at the moment. Long term wise, is this a chance worth taking?

The benefit should be in the rate. You should get a premium for the lack of benefits, uncertainty, etc.

Take the contract and work your ass off to impress them. You'll likely either continue to make contract dollars, or get a fulltime offer. If the company really values you and has any kind of work, you'll get it.

If it doesn't work, you have more experience under your belt.
 
I concur. Take the job. Then if it's not what you want, keep looking.

The company might not be hiring full-time people right now because of budget / headcount issues. Happens all the time. As soon as the new fiscal year hits, I'll bet that real hiring will start up again.

I work for a big, bad-ass, global, financial corporation. For the first 6 months or so of our fiscal year, we did no hiring. None. Nada. Then all of a sudden we (upper management actually) figured out that revenue wasn't so sucky after all so we've posted for 30 of the 60+ vacancies there are to fill. What did we do in the meantime? We told people we weren't hiring full-time but that we'd bring them on as temp.

Take the job. Things will change at the company before you know it. In the meantime, you can still look for the job of your dreams.
 
Take it and keep looking. At least you will have an income and there is no telling how long you might wait for another opportunity to present itself.
 
hunter001 said:
If I were you I would take it and keep looking. You are always in a stronger position having a job then looking for another one. One thing you have to be careful with is the what sort of guarantee your "agent" has with the company.

I took a job one time and I worked for a few weeks, it was a great job but the people and commute didn't do it for me. When I resigned to take another position my "agent" freaked, apparently he had a guarantee with my employer he didn't tell me about. I think he had to give back his commission. He threatened to black list me with all the other agencies in T.O. Just something to be aware of.


While I am sure there are a few good agents, many of them are self glorified employment pimps.
There # 1 concern is not if there is a good fit for you or the employer, rather the commission. The commisson is huge (25-50% of a years salary)
They insist on meeting with you (taking up your time) & if there is no immediate placement thats the last you hear from them.
 
Ya thats what i figured everyone would say.
I know all about the agencies all too well. Was sent to another big name company few years back when i first started a 'career'. Was told this had perm FT potential, but when i got there, the company did not hire anyone FT. Other than the ones they already have rest were all temp/contract. Thats exactly why i tried to avoid the agencies in the first place.

Although i will say this agency seems a lot better. Not a big name agency but they seem more about working as Team than I. Instead of everyone in their own cubicles working for themselves, they are all in same room always discussions jobs and candidates together, to see who has the best candidate for which jobs.

My agent knows i want a perm FT, and i even talked to him after the interview to let him know where i stand, if i take it, i would certainly still keep an eye out.

I'm just sick of changing jobs every so often not being able to find the right fit. But i will take it and hopefully it turns out well.
Thanks all
 
I feel your pain brother. I went through the same type of thing myself for several years 10-15 years ago. Best advice is to consider self-employment if at all possible. Build up a loyal client base, it's like having a bunch of different "jobs" - if you lose one you've still got plenty left.

I don't know how old you are, but imagine yourself at 45-50 still going through this kind of crap - not a fun prospect.
 
Plan B said:
...

1) Internal Employees get first crack at them
2) External Candidates, who are working at other companies
3) External Candidates, who are unemployed

That's a good list but I changed one thing:
1) Boss's unqualified son or daughter
2) Internal Employees get first crack at them
3) External Candidates, who are working at other companies
4) External Candidates, who are unemployed

Good advice all around and for the most part, taking a job doesn't mean you're stuck there for life. As stated, the headhunter may have a minimum time guarantee before they get their commission but I've used HH's before and if I leave, I've never heard boo from them except for trying to place me somewhere else.

I tell you, they put me one place and it literally felt like I was a square peg being driven into a round hole. I didn't get along with anyone (but one person) and when I left, a couple of people said to me: you know, this is a tough group to get along with but you did better than most! For whatever reason the staff around here really make it hard on a new person unneccessarily....(so yeah, it happens).

As for being concerned that the company doesn't have room to hire on any more permanant staff, this isn't anything new really. Many many companies have limits to what they can do, and that includes hiring staff. Plus the cost benefits alone are worth not having an added new employee (for eg: a rough estimate is that it costs a company about 50% more on top of the employee's salary in benefits, taxes, health care contributions etc).
 
tboy said:
That's a good list but I changed one thing:
1) Boss's unqualified son or daughter
2) Internal Employees get first crack at them
3) External Candidates, who are working at other companies
4) External Candidates, who are unemployed

Lmao, Good amend to the list Tboy, I completely forget about relatives and friends, who even when not qualified, "somehow" happen to be the best "fit" for the position. Even more so of a reason for Milhouse to take the job.