Should credit cards be cancelled...?

Maya25

New member
Aug 20, 2004
29
0
0
North York
www.hotelmassage.ca
Just wondering if credit cards like bay and sears should be cancelled after i've paid them off. Some ppl tell me that i should cancel them and others say that i shouldn't as it would make me look weak. Please advise if anyone knows for sure. I have paid them off and cancellig them is just a phone call away....but I dont wanna make a mistake by doing so. I do plan on buying a house/condo real soon.
thanks so much
Maya
 
If you have no plans to use them, then cancel them. It's one less teptation to over extend yourself....
 
If you have enough self discipline to kep the cards, and you feel that they will be of use in thee future you should keep them.
 
You shouldn't cancel them. part of your credit score is based on how much credit you have and how much of that credit you're currently using. I am not sure if a Bay or Sears card has the same effect as a Visa or a MC.
 
Sargeant StiffCock said:
You shouldn't cancel them. part of your credit score is based on how much credit you have and how much of that credit you're currently using. I am not sure if a Bay or Sears card has the same effect as a Visa or a MC.

As Sargeant has noted, those credit cards help you debt ratio that the bank uses to determine loans and mortgages. So if you are looking at buying a house don't cancel the credit cards, just don't use them.
 
Sargeant StiffCock said:
You shouldn't cancel them. part of your credit score is based on how much credit you have and how much of that credit you're currently using. I am not sure if a Bay or Sears card has the same effect as a Visa or a MC.


If you have a VISA card and you apply for a loan the bank will treat the entire limit of your card as a liability in calculating your debt ratio. The last department store card I had did not have a limit but that was long ago. If your department store card has a limit I am certain the bank will treat it as a liability when you apply for a mortgage.
 
cards

Agree with hambone.

You should not cancel all of your credit cards, but neither should you keep a bunch of unneeded ones. Also, the length of time credit cards have been held in good status can be a factor. In that case demonstrating good credit over a several year period is a plus.
 
Personally I just use one credit card - Visa. I do also have an AMEX card but that one is company issued for corporate expenses. I just find it more convenient to have one bill every month as opposed to multiples. When I initially got my Visa card it only had a few thousand as the spending limit, but I called and they gladly raised it.
 
I find if you spend a lot, they will increase the limit automatically. I use mine for business and personal spending, so having a points card is a great advantage. :)
 
Just something on the same topic.

FYI
there's a difference if you cancel them, and if the lender cancels them. it shows up on your credit report as "closed by consumer" or something like that.
 
Wrong

Some of the advice on here could not be more wrong.....

If you have "excess availability" of credit that is very bad when applying for mortgages or other bank loans.

When a lender looks at your debt ratio it is based on the assumption that all available credit is maxed out (since what's stopping you from doing that the day after your new loan/mortgage).

Therefore access to credit is just as bad as having to much debt or maxed out credit cards.

Only keep credit cards you plan to actively use and do not keep them maxed out and make your payments on time. Having unused credit cards with zero balances will hurt your credit rating and ratios.

Having high interest credit cards (store cards, etc) are seen as a double negative since any debts incurred on those cards is much harder to service givven that a larger portion of the minimum monthly payment only goes to interest without reducing the principle.

Prelations is correct....if you cancel a credit card it shows on your report that you cancelled it, which is a good thing as it shows credit responsibility.

Also, if you cancel a credit card check your credit report a few months later, often credit card companies just close your account but do not cancel it and therefore it is still affecting your debt ratios and credit scores.

Also, remember that if you apply for credit more than 1 time every three months this will also diminish your credit score. Therefore be weary of stores and company's which offer you gifts just for applying. Each application results in a credit check which hurts your score. Too many credit searches and you get branded a "credit seeker" on your credit report which harms your ability to borrow even further.
 
Maya:

You should cancel the cards, especially the Bay and Sears cards. Cancelling the cards yourself is viewed as a positive thing when evaluating your credit score. Make sure that your other cards have reasonable limits, are current (all the time) and you will have no problem getting the credit when you need it, provided it's an amount you can reasonably service. Don't get caught believing that a lot of credit makes you a good candidate from the bank's perspective.
 
Look at the interest rates and that alone should tell you to cancel them. get a line of credit from the bank instead.