Based on the comments from my recent posting I'm wondering if my review would have been considered less shill if I had posted graphic details and ratings. I'm just asking because my choice will always be to describe in a general way. I have no interest in giving graphic details. Nor do I have an interest in discussing rates. We are all adults here, we all make the choices we are comfortable with.
Shill review
- Thread starter S85rollover
- Start date
Especially from a new face reviewing a rarely reviewed provider.
Gotta pay your dues and build that rapport with the community.
For some reasons there seems to be dissensions when a review is about a higher rate provider. So you gotta take that into account.
It is just so on here.
It happened with Brooke Summers reviews a year or two back. There were also other instances.
Gotta pay your dues and build that rapport with the community.
For some reasons there seems to be dissensions when a review is about a higher rate provider. So you gotta take that into account.
It is just so on here.
It happened with Brooke Summers reviews a year or two back. There were also other instances.
No, post whatever you are comfortable with. There isn't a need for excessive details. The main thing I gather from reviews is whether or not a provider is real. With so many fake ads, it is very helpful to know someone actually exists and isn't a scam.
Thanks for your contribution so far.
Thanks for your contribution so far.
No, it has nothing to do with graphic details, it has to do with the fact that you are new to this community and only have 3 posts, 2 of which were giving props to an SP. The only way the review will not be considered a shill review is if you participate in the community, review other providers and share your experiences. Everybody starts on this board with zero credibility, which is what you have...you earn it by contributing and participating. Once you have that...your original review will no longer be considered a shill...until then...it likely will.
O
OnTheWayOut
Everyone has gone through being called a shill until they get better known. Nothing personal, just keep contributing and we will grow to trust your reviews, especially if you turn us on to a few gems. And buy beer. Lots of beer. 
It's because you it was your first post and you posted a review of a provider that wasn't well known. The language was a bit rosy and no details were given. Just a lot of red flags. However others have posted good reviews about Stella so I think you're safe there. Looking forward to reading more reviews and input from you
Don't worry about it man. I find some ppl on this board to be overly suspicious and quick to jump down your throat for perceived "red flags". There is a bit of a condescending attitude towards noobs, I've experienced it, it's not really a big deal.
Dont take it personally. Contributions are always appreciated. And Asuran mentioned this place gets bent out of shape over rates. Thats not the conversations I've read. Just continue to post about whatever you want, low rates, high rates who cares.
Giving little to no details about a positive encounter is your right on the board. There's no set template to follow.
Giving little to no details about a positive encounter is your right on the board. There's no set template to follow.
We've all been there , man. Look, you have hardly any posts and come out with this super good (and somewhat vague) review. Sorry if we are a little cynical. I actually appreciate you contributing and hope you don't take it to hard.
I know I've missed this convo by a couple weeks but thought I'd say it anyway since I can relate.
First off I'd say the review was well written and tasteful.
I've always worried about that happening to me. I've been a member for a while but always been hesitent to post. When I joined I would see either newbies asking for recommendations just to be told to contribute instead of leeching or to TOFTT. However once they actually wrote a review they were accussed of it being shill. I suppose some posts could be written by an SP but many aren't. By posting as a new reviewer you are risking both your own credibility and the lady you're reviewing. I still don't understand why some members are so stand offish about it but I guess it's just the way it goes.
For myself I'v found it to be shame I've had some great experinces over the years I would have (still would) enjoy contributing. Like you, I wouldn't like including graphic details. Some things are just for me to enjoy.
I'v been a member and been visiting SP's for a decade yet if I post a review now I'd still be a newbie haha
First off I'd say the review was well written and tasteful.
I've always worried about that happening to me. I've been a member for a while but always been hesitent to post. When I joined I would see either newbies asking for recommendations just to be told to contribute instead of leeching or to TOFTT. However once they actually wrote a review they were accussed of it being shill. I suppose some posts could be written by an SP but many aren't. By posting as a new reviewer you are risking both your own credibility and the lady you're reviewing. I still don't understand why some members are so stand offish about it but I guess it's just the way it goes.
For myself I'v found it to be shame I've had some great experinces over the years I would have (still would) enjoy contributing. Like you, I wouldn't like including graphic details. Some things are just for me to enjoy.
I'v been a member and been visiting SP's for a decade yet if I post a review now I'd still be a newbie haha
i didn't get the feeling when i started here last year...no one bothered me....i read, tried some tested SP's...wrote...then tried a few new ones and it built up....you worry too much...just do it...lol...
I'm a fair guy...if i love the girl, i'll go WOW on here...if it's ok...i'll lay out the cons...if it's bad, i'll be bad....i never exaggerate and tell it like it is...if some people don't like it, too bad so sad, i stand by what i say and i'm honest about it...and i almost always ask the SP if i have her blessing...
haha Yeah you're probably right about the worrying. I'm pretty invroverted so it's just in my nature. Appreciate your feed back. Well I guess next lady I visit I'll just ask her permission and just bite the bullet. If I get accussed of shill I'll just laugh lol
i wouldnt worry about what others say on here.
others have mentioned your low post count, but we all have to start at some point IF we chose to.
I think I'm at a little over 100 posts, but I don't post reviews every single time I see someone.
But then again, there is 1 person on here that freaks out when I say something negative about someone (SP), but others can do it, and he doesn't freak out on them. makes no sense!!!
others have mentioned your low post count, but we all have to start at some point IF we chose to.
I think I'm at a little over 100 posts, but I don't post reviews every single time I see someone.
But then again, there is 1 person on here that freaks out when I say something negative about someone (SP), but others can do it, and he doesn't freak out on them. makes no sense!!!
My own reviews are never really too graphic. They're mostly general. I don't like to put the lady on the spot if I say I received this and the guy asks why not him. Or if someone here didn't get something but then reads that I got it and feels shafted.
There has been a few cases where I saw reviews of fellow terbites where the provider had some restrictions but we're more open with me. I just leave myself out of it and considered myself lucky and had good chemistry with the provider.
There has been a few cases where I saw reviews of fellow terbites where the provider had some restrictions but we're more open with me. I just leave myself out of it and considered myself lucky and had good chemistry with the provider.
I try to just keep it decently generic unless there's some sort of scam or imminent danger. And +1 if we did something that wasn't on the reg.
This is annoying . "Any info?" then followed eventually by a bump by the same mark. Show some fucking agency and go get some. Once in a while sure. But when it's the same guys over and over...
Well I apologize. I didn't mean to offend anyone. I guess the opposite has happened, I always worried about someone giving me a hard time about my first review but now I'm getting a hard time about not posting lol
Like I said I'm rather a quiet fellow by nature so it wasn't my intent to "leech" Well I guess the only way to rectify the situation is to start posting.
While the board has moderators, the community on this board is somewhat self policiing...and we are usually pretty good at pointing out shills, but the real test of a shill is a user that creates an account, posts a review and maybe one or two other posts then is never seen from again...which is likely the case about the OP...time well tell but the OP has not logged on for 2 weeks.
As others have also mentioned the self policing takes other forms as well, such as pointing out white nights, and chiding those members that clearly have personal vendettas against certain providers, this last one is very clear when posters go on incessantly about providers they have never seen but both are very obvious to spot.
As others have also mentioned the self policing takes other forms as well, such as pointing out white nights, and chiding those members that clearly have personal vendettas against certain providers, this last one is very clear when posters go on incessantly about providers they have never seen but both are very obvious to spot.
Similar threads
