She was the better choice.

TQM

Guest
Feb 1, 2006
2,651
0
0
- the better choice amongst two good, interesting choices.

She began the campaign as the heir apparent - good candidates, like Edwards, became her door mats.

But she underestimated Obama - most everybody did. And when you're the heir apparent, that's dangerous.

Her team (both of them) had a straightforward strategy - one that makes the math of primaries much simpler. That strategy was to win the big states - and the rest will follow.

That strategy almost always works - until now. Big state after big state went to Clinton, but Obama, to his credit outperformed her in most of these states. He was expected to lose. He didn't lose by as much as people thought.

Really, the primaries are an abomination. They unfairly promote some very small states and they discriminate against some big ones. There's no doubt that the Florida and Michigan primaries turned out to be a big blow to Clinton. Both states were right to be upset with the primaries process. The end result for both states was the best possible in an impossible situation - a situtation the DNC should never have allowed to happen in the first place. Maine remains unpunished.

Super Tuesday is another abomination - designed to address (read: undermine) the primaries process. But Obama made his mark here. Clinton was never able to recover from the combined impact of the Super Tuesday results and the Florida/Michigan fiasco.

She proved herself an amazing fighter. She lasted the whole 15 rounds and lost on points. Very few fighters can get up off the mat and last til the end.

She succeeded in putting Obama on the defensive. Given how invulnerable he was earlier in the campaign, that's an amazing achievement. To be fair, many of the scoring punches she landed were given to her by Obama himself.

Obama's "message of hope", while a nice sentiment - is puffery and nothing more. He's a good, strong politician - and frankly he really needed to be challenged here.

The idea that Clinton should have dropped out earlier and should have pulled her punches is, pretty much, a fascist sentiment. She was in to win - I applaud her and her campaign.

Obama will now be a better candidate. He didn't know how to handle adversity. Now he does.

Please notice that when the Rev. Wright's comments first went public, Obama tried every possible spin to brush it aside. He said he never heard such comments (a lie). He said you can't disown your grandmother (stupid analogy - you don't choose your grandmother; you choose your church). He let the issue percolate. That was stupid.

When the guest preacher more recently said something stupid at his church - he acted much more decisively - and put the issue to rest. He's a better candidate now than he was 12 months ago.

The Democrats will be battle ready. Bush is very unpopular, the economy isn't particularly strong - and the Republicans are going to take the heat for this.

Though I disagree wholeheartedly with Obama's position on the Iraq war, the fact is I agree with him far more often than I disagree. The social issues I support finds him on my side. He has weaknesses - lack of experience; lack of a real understanding of the issues (e.g. NAFTA). But frankly, George Bush jr. had greater weaknesses. Ronald Reagan had greater weaknesses.

The United States is actually quite lucky - Clinton, Obama, and McCain are better candidates than Bush or Kerry or Gore. It's good to see relatively strong candidates come forward, for a change.

Summarizing, Clinton fought a fine, but losing, campaign. My hat's off to her. The Democrats are better for it.
 
"a black from Detroit"

nice.

Jesus.

Her strategy failed - in that sense, you can claim it was mismanaged. But good strategies can fail. Good strategies don't guarantee success. Clinton's strategy was a good strategy.
 
DQ - this is simple.

I realize I have to make it really, really, simple for you - but here goes.

Think about poker. You can be an amazing poker player with the best strategies and still lose.

The same is true in politics.

Winning doesn't mean you had a great strategy. Losing doesn't mean you had a bad strategy. Please don't respond. Just think about it.

In all previous primaries, winning the big states meant you won the election.
 
Obama came from "nothing"--a white mom and a black dad who left him when a baby.

Hillary rode her husband's name as far as she could. Shes a phony. She became a N.Y. senator not because that was her home state but because she thought that was the ticket to the White House.

Look how many times Hillary has "put her foot in her mouth". She isn't the better person to answer the phone @ 3 AM...she be too sleepily and misspeak once again.

Bill Clinton became a real let down. I loved Bill but ever since he drop his pants in the Oval office hes been a disappointment.

Obama has earn this spot all by himself. He is a "maybe" but I see him as a "good maybe".
 
corrections

1. She's hardly the first senator to have not been born in her state.

2. She has credentials and expertise.

3. She's certainly not a phony.

4. Foot in her mouth? The only thing I can think of was the stupid "under fire" stuff.

5. Many presidents have dropped their pants in the White House.
 
DonQuixote said:
If it was so good then why the results? :confused:

Her campaign was mismanaged.
Disagree as you will, the caucus
states were disregarded and
that is her downfall.

Let me get this straight. Obama and Clinton aside, in your opinion, it is not possible for two candidates to both run good campaigns, and one of them just happens to win, because, by definition, they both can't win. The only possible way to explain it, according to your logic, is that one of them must have run a bad campaign?

Wow!
 
TQM said:
nice.

Jesus.

Her strategy failed - in that sense, you can claim it was mismanaged. But good strategies can fail. Good strategies don't guarantee success. Clinton's strategy was a good strategy.

No. it wasn't. She completely dismissed that there would be any chance of any real competitor, she had no clue of the kind of money that could be raised from small contributors and relied on one time donations from the rich, she absolutely neglected any effort in States holding caucuces and paid dearly for it. And she made two final fatal mistakes. She completely underestimated Barack Obama, and many times described her coronation as inevitable. The mistake of all mistakes. Oh, and there's also letting Bill put his foot in his mouth continuously. Good plan? Nope.
 
wrong asterix,

As her initial strategy developed there were no other competitors - she had access to all the polling needed. She knew she could count on NY, California, Florida, Michigan, and a host of other support in a bunch of states, like Pennsylvania. Normally (read: every other election) that's enough to win.

As for fundraising - her problem wasn't that she couldn't fundraise. Her problem was that she blew her wad too early and when, after Super Tuesday, she found herself in 2nd place - she found her cupboards bare.

Her strategy was an obvious one; a good one. She had an enormous lead. She went for a knockout punch early (spending her money). It certainly knocked out nice guys like Edwards. That's smart (even though it didn't work out).

When you have a big lead and you want to discourage the few remaining - you go for the kill. Obama - good candidate that he is - survived that and lucked into a Super Tuesday. A different mix of states would have had a greatly different result. If the Florida and Michigan primaries had been allowed to occur- she would have won those easily and would have survived Super Tuesday with a lead. Instead, she showed up in second place.

Like a good fighter, she changed her strategy - went on the attack. It would have been stupid for her to attack Obama before Super Tuesday. But when the reality changed and she was no longer the front runner, she again chose the best possible strategy and focused on Obama.

It didn't work. But it almost did. The number of delegates she has isn't too shabby.
 
S.C. Joe said:
Bill Clinton became a real let down. I loved Bill but ever since he drop his pants in the Oval office hes been a disappointment.

Really? Did your quality of life decline as a result? Could you not look foreigners in the eye anymore because the Commander in Chief got busy with a mere government intern?

I fail to see how anyone who had high expectations could be all that let down. Of course, I also fail to see how anyone could have had high expectations.
 
True, she pulled a strong second place but take away the name Clinton-which her husband built-not her-where would she have been ? Not in second place...many voted not for Hillary but for Clinton. They just figure she be as good as Bill was for the country.

I look at all the mistakes she made and get scare what mistakes she would make as president.
 
Bill had no reason to bring up the race card when Obama started his pull. Bill lost all his "class" since he drop his pants...let me just say that.
 
cypherpunk said:
Really? Did your quality of life decline as a result?


Well yes it did, the whole state of Michigan, Ohio and others have been hurt by this guy Bushie. Al Gore would have gotten in the White House for sure if Bill would have not messed around until he was done as president...but then making out with Hillary :eek: maybe I can forgive him.
 
TQM said:
As her initial strategy developed there were no other competitors - she had access to all the polling needed. She knew she could count on NY, California, Florida, Michigan, and a host of other support in a bunch of states, like Pennsylvania. Normally (read: every other election) that's enough to win.

As for fundraising - her problem wasn't that she couldn't fundraise. Her problem was that she blew her wad too early and when, after Super Tuesday, she found herself in 2nd place - she found her cupboards bare.

Her strategy was an obvious one; a good one. She had an enormous lead. She went for a knockout punch early (spending her money). It certainly knocked out nice guys like Edwards. That's smart (even though it didn't work out).

When you have a big lead and you want to discourage the few remaining - you go for the kill. Obama - good candidate that he is - survived that and lucked into a Super Tuesday. A different mix of states would have had a greatly different result. If the Florida and Michigan primaries had been allowed to occur- she would have won those easily and would have survived Super Tuesday with a lead. Instead, she showed up in second place.

Like a good fighter, she changed her strategy - went on the attack. It would have been stupid for her to attack Obama before Super Tuesday. But when the reality changed and she was no longer the front runner, she again chose the best possible strategy and focused on Obama.

It didn't work. But it almost did. The number of delegates she has isn't too shabby.
Bullshit. You make the fighter analogy. A good fighter respects opponents and saves enough for the later rounds if something goes wrong. Hillary did neither.
 
Not so long ago, Hillary Clinton was running ads claiming she was the candidate best able to make decisions if an emergency call came at 3 a.m.

So, here we are, in primetime, and the decision she had to make was obvious, and she .... says she can't make a decision yet.

Good riddance to her.
 
ummmm.....

First - to moviefan. Clinton isn't saying anything yet because she's jockeying for a role. Nothing required her to say anything today. She wants a role. She wants input. She's not going to throw cards on the table until then.

Asterix - you really don't know anything about boxing, do you? A good fighter doesn't save anything if the case doesn't require it and doesn't respect opponents ever. Ali was incredibly disrespectful to his opponents.

She was up by 30 points over everyone. She went in for the kill. Good strategy, but didn't work. Still - and you really are too dense to see the point - she did adjust and ran a superb campaign after Super Tuesday. She has ended up with over 1900 delegates (keeping in mind Florida and Michigan). Even at this late date in the campaign she's still wining states.

If anything, Clinton was too respectful to Obama. Just wait until you see what the Republicans throw at him.

Her campaign didn't realize how much the Florida/Michigan nonsense would hurt her - until too late. There is a fault.

But since Super Tuesday, Clinton has matched Obama delegate for delegate (give or take). She made a fine adjustment. It just wasn't enough.
 
neversayno,

If you're considering being a wit, first, try to learn how to spell. Then, stop doing things in half-measures....
 
okey dokey

Clearly this is turning into a mainly nutbar thread. neversayno doing a version of the incredible Hulk; DQ with his grade 2 politics, and Asterix with his grade 3.....
 
TQM said:
Asterix - you really don't know anything about boxing, do you? A good fighter doesn't save anything if the case doesn't require it and doesn't respect opponents ever. Ali was incredibly disrespectful to his opponents.

He acted disrespectful as part of his act. Liston scared him to death, and he knew Frazier and Forman could beat him at any given moment. He had talent, in my opinion he was the best, but always prepared himself for his opponents. To suggest he didn't respect opponents ever shows you have no idea what you are talking about. The main reason he lasted so long in what amounted to the second half of his career is that he learned he could take a punch, and so outlast another fighter, which he readily admitted. Hillary blew it by not understanding who she was up against and what her limitations were, a mistake Ali rarely made until near the end. Hillary counted on an early knockout, and when that didn't work, had no back-up plan and nothing left.
 
it is sad that today might bring the video that may sink obama...........Michelle obama's whitey video is being released 5 months early.

Obama is the republicans best hope