Shafia trial verdict.

I was not there and I am also going by the limited information given in news articles.

Certainly not arguing for the innocence of the convicted, I believe all 3 are guilty of something, but based on the limited info I've gotten from the news, it was not proven that all 3 are guilty of first degree murder.

"3) If they were killed somewhere else by drowning or pushed in while they were still alive how is it possible to be anything other than 1st Degree?
4) There was physical evidence that the Lexus pushed the car into the canal and also testimony by the accused that they were there, at the canal. Pushing someone into the canal and having them drown or pushing the dead bodies into the canal. Does it really matter which it is?"

It is entirely possible that Hamed, who followed the Nissan which was possibly trying to get away defiantly from him crashed into the back of the car in a rage and everything that happened afterwards was the parents and Hamed covering up for him.

Just like the crown's position that the victims were drowned somewhere else, transported to the car, and shoved over. There isn't evidence to prove neither of these theories.

How did the Crown explain how and where the girls were drowned before they were placed in the car?
 
It goes to his state of mind, i.e. the disdain with which he thought of them, that being whores they were worthy of death.

A lot more than a parental scolding/reprimand.

They are guilty as sin.

He can think they deserved death all he wants, but that still does not prove he planned and killed them. Saying someone deserves death, or deserved death does not necessarily mean we would cause death.
 
How did the Crown explain how and where the girls were drowned before they were placed in the car?

Crown asserted that's what happened without providing a story of how it happened, where it happened, who took part in it. Defenses' closing arguments focused on this as well, but their mistake was they didn't have a solid story that they stuck to from the start, while the crown didn't have that problem.

Again, this is based only on news articles I've read.
 
Just like the crown's position that the victims were drowned somewhere else, transported to the car, and shoved over. There isn't evidence to prove neither of these theories.

I guarantee you that if I pushed you underwater in a car and there was an open window, you would do everything in your power to get out that window. You would not lie there waiting to drown.

They did not struggle to get out of the car, the ignition was off, the headlights were off, the windows was rolled down, their seat belts weren't on, and the seats were all reclined to the point that driving would be awkward. Moreover, it's a front wheel drive car that could not easily have driven into the water without being pushed from behind, and it was hard to navigate the car off the edge at that point.

Is that circumstantial evidence? Yes. But as Aardvark likes to quote, there's trout in that milk.
 
I guarantee you that if I pushed you underwater in a car and there was an open window, you would do everything in your power to get out that window. You would not lie there waiting to drown.

They did not struggle to get out of the car, the ignition was off, the headlights were off, the windows was rolled down, their seat belts weren't on, and the seats were all reclined to the point that driving would be awkward. Moreover, it's a front wheel drive car that could not easily have driven into the water without being pushed from behind, and it was hard to navigate the car off the edge at that point.

Is that circumstantial evidence? Yes. But as Aardvark likes to quote, there's trout in that milk.

I'm sure I would have tried to get out, but that doesn't mean they would have. 3 of them had bruises on their heads, they're shaken up, water is rushing in making it harder to force yourself out. In a panic anything could have happened. The fact that they did not escape does not prove that they were already dead.

I'm not sold on the reclined seats, either. If someone who doesn't have a license, and doesn't have much experience driving gets in a car, they might not bother to get perfectly comfortable. Someone who takes the car out for a joy ride without a license not wearing a seat belt is not out of the ordinary to me.

One thing I don't understand is how the ignition was off but the car was in gear 1 or drive.
 
I guarantee you that if I pushed you underwater in a car and there was an open window, you would do everything in your power to get out that window. You would not lie there waiting to drown.

They did not struggle to get out of the car, the ignition was off, the headlights were off, the windows was rolled down, their seat belts weren't on, and the seats were all reclined to the point that driving would be awkward. Moreover, it's a front wheel drive car that could not easily have driven into the water without being pushed from behind, and it was hard to navigate the car off the edge at that point.

Is that circumstantial evidence? Yes. But as Aardvark likes to quote, there's trout in that milk.


Did the Crown explain how and where the girls were drowned before they were placed in the car? I would imagine that the Crown had to present a theory about how 3 people managed to drown 4 people.
 
Did the Crown explain how and where the girls were drowned before they were placed in the car? I would imagine that the Crown had to present a theory about how 3 people managed to drown 4 people.

Illuminati is correct to an extent. But in a high profile case like this, a lot of the information can be found online on news articles, such as the crown's theory as to how 3 people drowned 4 people. You'd assume it would be in the closing argument.

Let me know if you find anything. I haven't.

This is an interesting read:
http://media.thestar.topscms.com/acrobat/e8/5b/3ad8232a4c81b5963839860ee768.pdf
 
I'm sure I would have tried to get out, but that doesn't mean they would have. 3 of them had bruises on their heads, they're shaken up, water is rushing in making it harder to force yourself out. In a panic anything could have happened.

Nonsense. They would have tried to get out unless they were already dead or unconscious. Human instinct would take over. You would not lie there and drown. And how do you explain the ignition being off and the seats being reclined?

It was not a collission, moreover, there wasn't enough room for a high speed collision there, it was a tight, narrow, small space that took two U-turns to get into.

Again, you've got vague newspaper reports. The jury got this in detail, with diagrams, photographs, expert testimony.
 
Did the Crown explain how and where the girls were drowned before they were placed in the car? I would imagine that the Crown had to present a theory about how 3 people managed to drown 4 people.

Yes. The Crown's theory is they were drowned nearby and then put into the cars. The evidence presented for that was that they died by drowning (coroner), and they were already dead or unconscious before the car went into the water (see above).
 
Now to the living.

The three remaining children are being taken care of by family and having a rough time. Two experiencing nightmares and risk of suicide. Not once in the trial did the father call asking how the children were, instead concerned about his real estate holdings. A real prize of a father. His children are chattel and little else.
 
While it may make for idle interest without actually knowing all the evidence is it not somewhat futile to draw our own conclusions?

Jury obviously thought it was somewhat cut and dried and the judge did not exactly make noises as if he thought it was the wrong decision.

It seems reasonably clear that Hamid either killed them or he dumped them in the canal after his parents helped to kill them. I, for one, am not going to lose a minute of sleep worrying whether it should have been 1st or 2nd degree and 10 years less in custody. I will also not entertain that it was a racially or religious descrimination motivated verdict - that is just a lame cop out.
 
can they be stripped of their assets by the crown? this worried the sick bastard- so it would be good to do
I can't think of a way to do so, but perhaps a creative crown attorney can.
Further to my mind, if this were possible, creating a trust (disolving at say age 30) for his surviving (minor) children would be best.
 
The relatives of his first wife may be able to file some sort of civil claim for damages arising from her murder. Perhaps they can also try and lay claim to some of the assets, that should have belonged to her.
 
when they were alive, he beat his children, and after they were dead , he hoped the devil would shit on their graves.......does this sound like a loving father?
 
What does it matter whether he retains his assets? He won't be able to use them while in jail.
 
I think it'll piss him off knowing that he's got money "out there" but can't use any of it.
If he has any brains at all he is going to want to appoint an administrator or other agent to manage his real estate holdings and other investments for him.