I was not there and I am also going by the limited information given in news articles.
Certainly not arguing for the innocence of the convicted, I believe all 3 are guilty of something, but based on the limited info I've gotten from the news, it was not proven that all 3 are guilty of first degree murder.
"3) If they were killed somewhere else by drowning or pushed in while they were still alive how is it possible to be anything other than 1st Degree?
4) There was physical evidence that the Lexus pushed the car into the canal and also testimony by the accused that they were there, at the canal. Pushing someone into the canal and having them drown or pushing the dead bodies into the canal. Does it really matter which it is?"
It is entirely possible that Hamed, who followed the Nissan which was possibly trying to get away defiantly from him crashed into the back of the car in a rage and everything that happened afterwards was the parents and Hamed covering up for him.
Just like the crown's position that the victims were drowned somewhere else, transported to the car, and shoved over. There isn't evidence to prove neither of these theories.
How did the Crown explain how and where the girls were drowned before they were placed in the car?

