Sex Work is Work

Again I see the word MOST. Not all. But please quote me where I said ALL men.

And please prove me wrong. Show me all the threads where guys are supporting screening by using real numbers only And of course compare that to the amount of men who say no to real numbers and tell me which is more. Because I did limit it to MOST of the men here on TERB. Disprove that and I will apologize.
 
Last edited:
Again I see the word MOST. Not all. But please quote me where I said ALL men.

And please prove me wrong. Show me all the threads where guys are supporting screening by using real numbers only And of course compare that to the amount of men who say no to real numbers and tell me which is more. Because I did limit it to MOST of the men here on TERB. Disprove that and I will apologize.
OK...you said 'most'...doesn't change my view...what kind of culture is this where we can't have a safer industry because the cheating husbands have to jump thru a hoop...if protecting cheating husbands is the only defence you have than I still like my idea.
 
OK...you said 'most'...doesn't change my view...what kind of culture is this where we can't have a safer industry because the cheating husbands have to jump thru a hoop...if protecting cheating husbands is the only defence you have than I still like my idea.

Not the only defence but one that leads heavily to an underground which is more unsafe for everyone then what we have now. Another thing that will push the underground is the hoops women will have to jump through and not ones related to providing STDs

And yes I said most because it fair to say it is true based on the over all opinion of men and their privacy here on TERB. I didn’t say in the whole industry, that could be a completely different number if we include everyone but I said most here because it is true. Again, prove me wrong.

Lastly, and apparently repeatedly, it is already legal for us to work. You want regulation. You want more government influence on the sex lives of its citizens. That is what you are looking for. On top of what discrimination would do which would allow you to purchase sex.
 
I and many others, especially actual sex workers who understand the system, would prefer decriminalization.

As stated, it is already legal to escort. It is illegal for you to be a client. Decriminalization would end that for you. Legalize would bring your private hobbling to light and many, especially married men, would not be able to hobby as much out of legit fears of getting caught.

This doesn’t even bring into account the huge underground market that it would cause and the added dangers that would come with it.

Please actually look at the differences between legalization and decriminalization. I don’t think you truly know the difference and are just making assumptions about your “legalizing” would look like.

As a client the difference between legalization and decriminalization is quite different.
If it's just decriminalized there are absolutely no standards, no oversight and a lot of aspects of the industry will be just as they are currently.
If it's legalized yes you as an SP might loose and probably will loose some clients who are married, but the numbers of clients gained from it due to it being legal will be substantially higher.
There are a few countries that prostitution is legal and they haven't or didn't see a huge underground market that caused added dangers.

But the aspect of strippers and shutdowns which this thread is about, I really do hope SW's overall do not dig their heels in this nonsense of strippers are being unjustly targeted. Again issue with the strip clubs is 2/50 in Ontario 4% had outbreaks and the issue of non compliance was at an industry level.
If they (All SW's) do they are going to alienate and lose the support of many people who were empathetic towards the SW industry in general and would have been allies in the fight to destigmitize SW and the industry and possibly decriminalize or legalize it.
 
Last edited:
Not the only defence but one that leads heavily to an underground which is more unsafe for everyone then what we have now. Another thing that will push the underground is the hoops women will have to jump through and not ones related to providing STDs

And yes I said most because it fair to say it is true based on the over all opinion of men and their privacy here on TERB. I didn’t say in the whole industry, that could be a completely different number if we include everyone but I said most here because it is true. Again, prove me wrong.

Lastly, and apparently repeatedly, it is already legal for us to work. You want regulation. You want more government influence on the sex lives of its citizens. That is what you are looking for. On top of what discrimination would do which would allow you to purchase sex.
My plan may have flaws but the current industry/culture could be improved...the good escorts will be ok.
 
Very long thread. Good points of either side.
As some mentioned, sex work is already legal in many countries. If it can work in US and most of European countries, why reinvent a wheel?? There's demand for sex, plain and simple. This profession is as old as human kind itself.
The unfortunate thing is we have hypocrites in government and our society stinks of hypocrisy. Everyone knows this industry exists! So government should either choose to regulate it or leave it the F alone and let it's players figure things out.
Married, no married, looking to experiment or to spice things up - my personal life is non of your effin business. If I'm not harming anyone - let me be.
Unfortunately, most of clients will not be heard in support of sex workers. Most of us operate from the shadows for various reasons. The only way this industry will be legalized is if all sex workers unite and take a chapter from LGBT or BLM and start shaming our goverment for mistreatment.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Josephine Grey
As a client the difference between legalization and decriminalization is quite different.
If it's just decriminalized there are absolutely no standards, no oversight and a lot of aspects of the industry will be just as they are currently.
If it's legalized yes you as an SP might loose and probably will loose some clients who are married, but the numbers of clients gained from it due to it being legal will be substantially higher.
There are a few countries that prostitution is legal and they haven't or didn't see a huge underground market that caused added dangers.

But the aspect of strippers and shutdowns which this thread is about, I really do hope SW's overall do not dig their heels in this nonsense of strippers are being unjustly targeted. Again issue with the strip clubs is 2/50 in Ontario 4% had outbreaks and the issue of non compliance was at an industry level.
If they (All SW's) do they are going to alienate and lose the support of many people who were empathetic towards the SW industry in general and would have been allies in the fight to destigmitize SW and the industry and possibly decriminalize or legalize it.

These ladies felt there was a ground for action. I would suggest to sit down and watch what arguments they will put on the table before you make your opinion.

Also, the fact that a group of sws are fighting for something many might argue about should not affect how worthy we are of basic rights (legalization/decriminalisation). If the support of these pretended potential allies is based on that. I personally don't think the cause need them. The issue was there before covid 19.

I am very curious of what will happen and how the autority will respond to that. Tbc
 
Those ladies should stand in front of a judge and ask:
How come is abortion legal in Canada at all stages of pregnancy but our profession isn't.
Why is it not illegal to get high or drunk and have one night stands?
Why is it not illegal to openly admitting to having a sugar daddy?
 
These ladies felt there was a ground for action. I would suggest to sit down and watch what arguments they will put on the table before you make your opinion.

Also, the fact that a group of sws are fighting for something many might argue about should not affect how worthy we are of basic rights (legalization/decriminalisation). If the support of these pretended potential allies is based on that. I personally don't think the cause need them. The issue was there before covid 19.

I am very curious of what will happen and how the autority will respond to that. Tbc

The argument they are making is clear in the article and is based on a lot of false assumptions or misleading information, the government will show proof of non compliance and the fact that they weren't targeted but it was caused due to the strip clubs not following guidelines and nothing will come of it. They will also show lack of concern from the strip club owners for the general public by not issuing public notices right away (which other businesses do) and only having these outbreaks come to light after the information was released by the public health authority.

As well as I've stated many times which you keep avoiding, there are many instances of establishments who serve liquor from around the world being super spreader cases, and the government allowed strip clubs to re-open prior to allowing night clubs to re-open, that is evidence that they didn't target them and were more than fair with them.

Like I said it will alienate people from supporting this cause because it shows during a pandemic where many industries are affected, where many haven't been able to re-open yet, where many who earn a lot less income than dancers or the strip club owners, where the success in the fight against the Coronavirus needs to be a joint effort by all, strippers are only concerned about their own greed even after they were given an opportunity to re-open but only failed because of their own lack of adherence to the set guidelines.

Also like I said in my first post in this thread in regards to the original article you linked the author has legitimate concerns about the overall stigmatization as well as the issues regarding race in the industry, but she is fully wrong on the re shutdowns of the strip clubs, and it dilutes her overall message when she is so wrong about another argument she is making.

At no point has the government treated strip clubs in an unjust manner during the pandemic, the government did allow them to reopen early prior to allowing nightclubs to reopen. They were very strict with them regarding the need to follow the protocols of social distancing, face masks and contact tracing guidelines, they put the onus on the strip club owners/staff/dancers/customers to act in a responsible manner and they all failed doing such and following the set guidelines, it simply was not followed at an industry level. This is the exact opposite of unjust treatment, it's called cause and effect.
Dancers shouldn't be upset at the government they really should be upset at themselves for not adhering to the set guidelines that allowed them to re-open.

BTW Dancers claim their charter rights to freedom of expression and association in a safe and secure environment to work freely is being violated.
The charter of rights at no point allows any individual or institution to put their own selfish gains/greed over the protection of health and safety of customers or the general population at risk.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cityside15
So, decided to actually read bill C-36. What a fun read.
Long story short:
Any sex trafficking - illegal
Advertising sex services other than your own - illegal
Forcing anyone into sex - illegal
Agencies and massage parlors - borderline illegal (all staff must vouch that service is provided at free will to have a pass)
Independents - not classified as legal, but basically expemt from prosecution
 
So, decided to actually read bill C-36. What a fun read.
Long story short:
Any sex trafficking - illegal
Advertising sex services other than your own - illegal
Forcing anyone into sex - illegal
Agencies and massage parlors - borderline illegal (all staff must vouch that service is provided at free will to have a pass)
Independents - not classified as legal, but basically expemt from prosecution

You forgot a very important one

Client's purchasing services for consideration----illegal
 
Maybe I misunderstand something, but for me decriminalisation means no real regulation, while legalisation is legal brothels or licences, health check for employees, etc. However, no business has any requirements (other than age check) for customers, so, I do not know where the idea of STD checks fro clients came from. I see it like LCBO with the privacy condition that customers' information is not recorded and not disclosed. No photo/video inside.
 
You forgot a very important one

Client's purchasing services for consideration----illegal
Yes, that was also there but... if it's consented between 2 adults - good luck proving otherwise.

I never paid for sex. Not once! I did pay for companionship. And what a time it was!
 
In some countries, (or administrative subdivisions within a country), prostitution is legal and regulated. In these jurisdictions, there is a specific law, which explicitly allows the practice of prostitution if certain conditions are met (as opposed to places where prostitution is legal only because there is no law to prohibit it).

In countries where prostitution is regulated, the prostitutes may be registered, they may be hired by a brothel, they may organize trade unions, they may be covered by workers' protection laws, their proceeds may be taxable, they may be required to undergo regular health checks, etc. The degree of regulation, however, varies very much by jurisdiction.

Such approaches are taken with the stance that prostitution is impossible to eliminate, and thus these societies have chosen to regulate it in an attempt to increase transparency and therefore reduce the more undesirable consequences. Goals of such regulations include controlling sexually transmitted disease, reducing sexual slavery, controlling where brothels may operate and dissociating prostitution from crime syndicates.

In countries where prostitution is legal and regulated, it is usual for the practice to be restricted to particular areas.

In countries where prostitution itself is legal, but associated activities are outlawed, prostitution is generally not regulated.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Valcazar
I try to do so well that it won't seem like work, at least not with me. It is more blessed to give than to receive...
 
In some countries, (or administrative subdivisions within a country), prostitution is legal and regulated. In these jurisdictions, there is a specific law, which explicitly allows the practice of prostitution if certain conditions are met (as opposed to places where prostitution is legal only because there is no law to prohibit it).

In countries where prostitution is regulated, the prostitutes may be registered, they may be hired by a brothel, they may organize trade unions, they may be covered by workers' protection laws, their proceeds may be taxable, they may be required to undergo regular health checks, etc. The degree of regulation, however, varies very much by jurisdiction.

Such approaches are taken with the stance that prostitution is impossible to eliminate, and thus these societies have chosen to regulate it in an attempt to increase transparency and therefore reduce the more undesirable consequences. Goals of such regulations include controlling sexually transmitted disease, reducing sexual slavery, controlling where brothels may operate and dissociating prostitution from crime syndicates.

In countries where prostitution is legal and regulated, it is usual for the practice to be restricted to particular areas.

In countries where prostitution itself is legal, but associated activities are outlawed, prostitution is generally not regulated.

Maybe a way to think of it is like abortion.
Abortion in Canada was decriminalized, not legalized. There aren't specific abortion laws. It is just part of medical treatment and dealt with that way.
Decriminalizing prostitution would be the same thing - all normal laws about self employment and work and so on would still apply, but there would be no specific laws, licenses, and legal demands about prostitution itself.
 
Abortion in Canada is legal at all stages of pregnancy and funded in part by the Canada Health Act.
Can't wait to see a day when sex workers are able to accept OHIP.
 
Doesn’t mean it is not real work. I pay taxes on this work. I do the admin, I do the job, I advertise, I market, I get shitty or great ROI, I have profits and losses, income statements, materials and supplies, etc etc

Don’t say it is not “real” work. You are just perpetrating the stereotype.

BTW - you are getting your terms wrong. It is 1000% sold legally. You’re just pissy you can’t legally buy it. Doesn’t mean it is not legally sold.

Hi Jenesis,

For sex work to be viewed as a legal transaction, the government has to allow the buying and selling of the service. The elements of a contract require:

an offer;​
an acceptance of that offer;​
consideration (something of value exchanged between the parties);​
capacity;​
consent;​
legal purpose (contract cannot violate the law)​

Since the customers are not legally able to buy the service, it can be argued that the entire transaction is illegal.

Cheers,

Matt
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fun For All
Hi Jenesis,

For sex work to be viewed as a legal transaction, the government has to allow the buying and selling of the service. The elements of a contract require:

an offer;​
an acceptance of that offer;​
consideration (something of value exchanged between the parties);​
capacity;​
consent;​
legal purpose (contract cannot violate the law)​

Since the customers are not legally able to buy the service, it can be argued that the entire transaction is illegal.

Cheers,

Matt

Sex work is defined by “work”, not by transaction. Work does not to deemed legal transactional for it to be classified as work. The taxes I pay this working income certainly lets me know it is work.

I get what you are trying to say but the government has said and the CCC have been made so that I am allowed to “legally” work. They have made selling sex legal. Actually, selling sex was legal before C-36. Selling sex itself has never been illegal. There have just been provisions that were illegal. C-36 gave us less provisions to deal with. I don’t deny that one part of the “transaction” is not legal but my part is legal and my part is the working part.

You can try to make it Illegitimate all you want but it doesn’t mean it is true. My job is legal and it is work. Therefore sex work is work.

Please don’t be one of those people who negate or take away the validity of my job.
 
Last edited:
Now if we look at the definition of work according to physics which is a force applied through a distance then certainly the sex act is work. For every action there is a reaction, namely the reaction to sex work is some form of financial compensation.

7_work1.jpg