I think the reason Sexual Addiction hasn't been accepted by the mainstream scientific community yet as a disorder is because the three conditions that qualify for sexual addiction can also qualify for normal healthy human sexuality.
Compulsivity: Most people given have a strong basic biological sex drive, dictated not just by behavior but by underlying biological factors (i.e hormonal influences, age, etc.); if this behavior has a strong biological component then the idea of compulsivity may not be governed just by behaviors but by biological factors as well (i.e. high testosterone production). Someone with a high sex drive or high testosterone production leading to increased libido, and what seems like uncontrollable desire would meet condition #1 Compulsivity. And also what about someone who has a strong desire for their mate and can't wait to have sex with them and is constantly on their minds interfering with concentration? Some would say they are infatuated and in love. Would they not meet the condition for Compulsivity as well? In this case it is a normal healthy part of human sexuality and encouraged, understood and even desired. I can tell you that just as I am about to have an orgasm, it's pretty hard to stop. Is that also Compulsive? What timelines are we dealing with? The few seconds just before cumming? Minutes of compulsivity? Hours? Days? By this standard, all boys and girls entering puberty with flooding hormonal changes may be classified as compulsive sex addicts (hmmm, maybe that's not a bad definition- kidding)
Continuation despite consequences: I bet most of us would, if we had the chance to get laid or visit the parents for thanksgiving, take the kids to soccer practice, go to work, would rather get laid. Look at Bill Clinton, the former President of the United States was getting blown while making policy decisions, regardless of the consequences. Is he a Sex Addict? What about, again, the teen who skips class to get a blowjob from their girlfriend? Sex Addict?
Obsession: Most guys think about sex every few seconds. It's in our biology, By this definition are we all then sex addicts?
If its the convergence of all three conditions to be met, I think it would apply to all of us at some point of our lives, if not most of the time.
I think the definition needs more work, taking into account the sexual norms of our society. Most people lie about their sexual lives, so even getting accurate information on this to even base a definition is difficult. And our sexual norms differ from those in other societies, added to which our diverse mosaic community structure may also make it harder to define norms at a national level.
Many everyday activities can have a level of addictivity, such as overeating, overdrinking, washing your hands etc. Though I don't doubt that sexual addiction exists, the definition needs more work, and those who enjoy lots of sex, even if it interferes with their daily lives, shouldn't be branded sex addicts. For example, what is the norm regarding masturbation? how often do people do it in their daily lives? Would doing this excessively be an addiction? Should it be labeled as such? I don't think so.