Senators approve anti-spanking bill

baci2004

Bad girl Luv'r
Mar 21, 2004
2,572
2
38
55
At the range!!!
http://www.cbc.ca/canada/story/2008/06/19/spanking-bill.html?ref=rss

Senators approve anti-spanking bill

Last Updated: Thursday, June 19, 2008 | 10:15 AM ET Comments431Recommend147

CBC News


A proposed law that could see parents charged for spanking their children is heading to the House of Commons after clearing a major hurdle in the Senate.


'I received the occasional spanking as a child and didn't turn out to be an abusive monster. I sure made me listen when I was told to do something or not do something.'
--Mississauga Mom
Add your comment


The bill, supported by the Liberal majority, quietly passed third reading in the Senate on Tuesday night despite Conservative objections to the legislation. The vote count was not recorded.
Bill S-209, which needs House approval to be made into law, proposes to eliminate Section 43 of Canada's Criminal Code, which allows parents, teachers and caregivers to use reasonable force to discipline a child and correct their behaviour.
Liberal Senator Céline Hervieux-Payette first introduced the bill in December 2004, shortly after the Supreme Court denied a challenge to Section 43 and upheld the right of adults to physically discipline children between the ages of two and 12.
Dion's support expected

Hervieux-Payette said she believes she will get the support of Liberal Leader Stéphane Dion in the House, although the ruling Conservatives have voiced concern over the bill. Hervieux-Payette said if the House does not pass her legislation, she will simply keep reintroducing it.
"It is to send a signal, so that people who use violence in a repeated way will no longer feel protected," she said, according to Canwest News Service. "It is not to arrest everyone who gives their child a tap on the arm."
The Senate mulled over the bill for more than three years, as the Canadian Bar Association and the Canadian Council of Criminal Defence Lawyers spoke out against it. In response to concerns, the bill was amended to allow parents and caregivers to use force in very specific situations — such as when a caregiver wants to immediately stop a child who is about to do something dangerous that could cause serious harm.
Routine discipline and using spanking as premeditated punishment wouldn't be allowed.
"No corporal punishment would be allowed, either by an educator, the mother, the father or someone acting for them," Hervieux-Payette said.
 
asn said:
you cant ground kids and now you cant spank them either.....i am never having kids

You can just don't vote Liberal.
 
Aardvark154 said:
Yet another reason why reform of the (Canadian) Senate is desperately, desperately overdue!

An overhaul of most appointed government positions such as the senate, superior court judges, government ministries etc is required as most appointments to me are partisan politics. A fair system would be to have these positions selected by the people in some sort of election process. Just my two cents...
 
Send your kids to South America and see how far their tantrums and meltdowns will be tolerated.

Some teenagers nowadays are very disrespectful and vulgar. It all starts from home.
 
Sure raise a kid without discipline...see how they turn out. They'll step all over their parents.

Parents can't discipline, teachers can't discipline. :confused:
 
jerbear said:
Might as well hand the kids handguns too .


It's the kids that have the hand guns and it is the registered guns they want to get rid of. Just look at all the young gang members. It is the adults that are powerless.
 
asn said:
you cant ground kids and now you cant spank them either.....i am never having kids

If your only purpose in having children is to have someone a quarter your size that you can beat the shit out of with impunity, you're better off not having them. Take up boxing instead and pick on someone your own size - unless you're too scared to hit someone who might actually hit back.
 
johnhenrygalt said:
If your only purpose in having children is to have someone a quarter your size that you can beat the shit out of with impunity, you're better off not having them. Take up boxing instead and pick on someone your own size - unless you're too scared to hit someone who might actually hit back.

I doubt if any parent wants to beat thier children or really harm them in anyway. But what if you hear your child is doing something extemely wrong let's say and you go and question them about it and your responce you get from said child is go to hell and the good ole F word. You then tell your child not to talk in that way and it is not respectful and tell them they are grounded and they tell you I will do what I want anyways. You then tell them to speak respectfully to you and to go to the corner and they turn around and let's say kick you or continue to be defiant towards you. In other words refuse to obey your orders. I am sure every child is different but I also agree that lots of things kids learn and attitudes of children are changing and they learn things from school and not necessarily everything is from the home. Kids of any age can kick back. Look even at the wee ones you see throwing tantrums on the streets and refusing to leave with thier parents and the embarrasment they bring to thier parents. Yes, this age you can pick up and carry to your car if you are not afraid of being kicked a few times. This too needs to be kicked in the bud one way and somehow. Seven year olds and ten year olds can be defiant too. It is not about beating a child just being allowed to control your children when all else fails.
 
johnhenrygalt said:
If your only purpose in having children is to have someone a quarter your size that you can beat the shit out of with impunity, you're better off not having them. Take up boxing instead and pick on someone your own size - unless you're too scared to hit someone who might actually hit back.


I agree completely.

Of course, since virtually NO-ONE has children FOR THAT PURPOSE your comment is asinine.

That's just as stupid as saying "if your only purpose in having children is to lock them away in their room for hours on end (i.e. timeout) then you are better off not having them. Instead go to Mexico an djoin a kidnapping gang so you can kidnap someone your own size.

Try to have an intelligent discussion where you don't exagerrate the other sides position.
 
forcebwu said:
Send your kids to South America and see how far their tantrums and meltdowns will be tolerated.

Word.

I feel bad for those parenting in North America. Ain't easy. Criminalizing spanking is just going too far .
 
Last edited:
Jade4u said:
It is not about beating a child just being allowed to control your children when all else fails.

Well, there's nothing in the bill that says you can't use force to control your child when necessary, it just limits the circumstances.
 
What will they deem necessary? Will every little spanking have to go before the court of law? Now I do agree that if a child is obviously beaten then there should be interactions. But laws should be made to improve child behaviour and not give them more freedom to take parent to court for grounding, spanking, punishing and more or less just because they are not happy at the time and seek revenge. Children are taught what thier rights are and will be the ones to abuse them before anyone else that is fearful of the law like adults. Look in the schools it is always please this or please that. I saw awhile back a teacher ask a student to deliver a message to his teacher and the student said I don't want to. The teacher just responded that's fine. Respect is going out the door.
 
Jade4u said:
What will they deem necessary? Will every little spanking have to go before the court of law? Now I do agree that if a child is obviously beaten then there should be interactions. But laws should be made to improve child behaviour and not give them more freedom to take parent to court for grounding, spanking, punishing and more or less just because they are not happy at the time and seek revenge. Children are taught what thier rights are and will be the ones to abuse them before anyone else that is fearful of the law like adults. Look in the schools it is always please this or please that. I saw awhile back a teacher ask a student to deliver a message to his teacher and the student said I don't want to. The teacher just responded that's fine. Respect is going out the door.

100% agreed!