It really depends on where you intend to dive on a regular basis. If your intent is to be one of those wussy divers that only ever dive in warm salty water, then there is no reason to do your open waters here. (I'm kidding about the wussy part... but it is a lot easier to dive in the south). If, on the other hand, you are open to diving here, then you will benefit from the open water instruction here. The very different conditions make for two almost entirely different sports... Different gear, different type of diving. Up north requires more (and therefore heavier) gear. The diving is often more demanding... colder, often deeper once you get into it.
My "average" dive here is in about 140' and I regularly dive in excess of 200' on mixed gas, in water which rarely gets above 41 F below 70'. My "average" dive down south is about 100', in 82 F water. Here, my gear weighs about 150# - 200#, there, it's about 60#. But I like diving here every bit as much as there... it's just different.
IMHO, it's much, much easier to take a northern diver and "convert" them to a southern diver. But if you intend to be the "once a year vacation" diver, then why fuss with this stuff.
As an aside, the Great Lakes make up the best fresh water diving area in the world. People come from all over the world to dive our wrecks. Visibility in the spring is routinely over 100' and I have seen it as high as 180' in Lake Ontario. You need to be offshore in deep, cool water for that, but it's awesome for photography.
And finally, regarding diving being "dangerous", statistically it's very safe (some specialties, like cave diving being the exception). If you Google up the most dangerous sports, diving doesn't even make the top 25 in most. (If I recall, I got into this with my family last Christmas... top of the list was lawn bowling! WTF... then I realized that the average lawn bowler is probably about 106 years old!). Diving requires discipline and common sense, but it is not inherently dangerous, unless you have an underlying health problem. Most "diving accidents" are actually old fuckers have heart attacks swimming against currents.
And, no, sharks "never" attack divers. You are far more likely to be nipped by a shark wading at a beach, and even that is extremely rare.
My "average" dive here is in about 140' and I regularly dive in excess of 200' on mixed gas, in water which rarely gets above 41 F below 70'. My "average" dive down south is about 100', in 82 F water. Here, my gear weighs about 150# - 200#, there, it's about 60#. But I like diving here every bit as much as there... it's just different.
IMHO, it's much, much easier to take a northern diver and "convert" them to a southern diver. But if you intend to be the "once a year vacation" diver, then why fuss with this stuff.
As an aside, the Great Lakes make up the best fresh water diving area in the world. People come from all over the world to dive our wrecks. Visibility in the spring is routinely over 100' and I have seen it as high as 180' in Lake Ontario. You need to be offshore in deep, cool water for that, but it's awesome for photography.
And finally, regarding diving being "dangerous", statistically it's very safe (some specialties, like cave diving being the exception). If you Google up the most dangerous sports, diving doesn't even make the top 25 in most. (If I recall, I got into this with my family last Christmas... top of the list was lawn bowling! WTF... then I realized that the average lawn bowler is probably about 106 years old!). Diving requires discipline and common sense, but it is not inherently dangerous, unless you have an underlying health problem. Most "diving accidents" are actually old fuckers have heart attacks swimming against currents.
And, no, sharks "never" attack divers. You are far more likely to be nipped by a shark wading at a beach, and even that is extremely rare.

