Scientists explain ancient Rome's long-lasting concrete

danmand

Well-known member
Nov 28, 2003
46,971
5,606
113
Scientists explain ancient Rome's long-lasting concrete
By Matt McGrath

Scientists examined samples from this ancient Roman pier with very high-powered X-rays
Researchers have unlocked the chemistry of Roman concrete which has resisted the elements for thousands of years.
Ancient sea walls built by the Romans used a concrete made from lime and volcanic ash to bind with rocks.
Now scientists have discovered that elements within the volcanic material reacted with sea water to strengthen the construction.
They believe the discovery could lead to more environmentally friendly building materials.
Unlike the modern concrete mixture which erodes over time, the Roman substance has long puzzled researchers.
Rather than eroding, particularly in the presence of sea water, the material seems to gain strength from the exposure.
In previous tests with samples from ancient Roman sea walls and harbours, researchers learned that the concrete contained a rare mineral called aluminium tobermorite.
They believe that this strengthening substance crystallised in the lime as the Roman mixture generated heat when exposed to sea water.
Researchers have now carried out a more detailed examination of the harbour samples using an electron microscope to map the distribution of elements. They also used two other techniques, X-ray micro-diffraction and Raman spectroscopy, to gain a deeper understanding of the chemistry at play.
This new study says the scientists found significant amounts of tobermorite growing through the fabric of the concrete, with a related, porous mineral called phillipsite.
The researchers say that the long-term exposure to sea water helped these crystals to keep on growing over time, reinforcing the concrete and preventing cracks from developing.
"Contrary to the principles of modern cement-based concrete," said lead author Marie Jackson from the University of Utah, US, "the Romans created a rock-like concrete that thrives in open chemical exchange with seawater."


A close up view of the concrete from a scanning electron microscope showing the presence of the tobermorite which adds strength
"It's a very rare occurrence in the Earth."
The ancient mixture differs greatly from the current approach. Modern buildings are constructed with concrete based on Portland cement.
This involves heating and crushing a mixture of several ingredients including limestone, sandstone, ash, chalk, iron and clay. The fine material is then mixed with "aggregates", such as rocks or sand, to build concrete structures.
The process of making cement has a heavy environmental penalty, being responsible for around 5% of global emissions of CO2.
So could the greater understanding of the ancient Roman mixture lead to greener building materials?
Prof Jackson is testing new materials using sea water and volcanic rock from the western United States. Speaking to the BBC earlier this year, she argued that the planned Swansea tidal lagoon should be built using the ancient Roman knowledge of concrete.
"Their technique was based on building very massive structures that are really quite environmentally sustainable and very long-lasting," she said.
"I think Roman concrete or a type of it would be a very good choice [for Swansea]. That project is going to require 120 years of service life to amortise [pay back] the investment.
"We know that Portland cement concretes contain steel reinforcements. Those will surely corrode in at least half of that service lifetime."
There are a number of limiting factors that make the revival of the Roman approach very challenging. One is the lack of suitable volcanic rocks. The Romans, the scientists say, were fortunate that the right materials were on their doorstep.
Another drawback is the lack of the precise mixture that the Romans followed. It might take years of experimenting to discover the full formula.
The research has been published in the journal American Mineralogist.
 
The Romans invented concrete in the late First Century BC, they used pumice as a building material. When pumice is mixed with water it turns into a glue, the bind it creates is stronger than the stone it adheres to. I'm not sure about the sea water part. How would you explain this?

 
The Romans invented concrete in the late First Century BC, they used pumice as a building material. When pumice is mixed with water it turns into a glue, the bind it creates is stronger than the stone it adheres to. I'm not sure about the sea water part. How would you explain this?

They're claiming a chemical reaction. But pollution is doing what time couldn't and eroding many monuments. At one point they stopped traffic around the coliseum and are allowing only tourist buses in.
 
Traffic in the Old City has been restricted for awhile now. Which is great for tourists since it frees the the Corso Victor Emmanuele, connecting The Roman Forum to The Vatican, is only used for pedestrian traffic. Part of The Colosseum was used for building material in the MIddle Ages, an earthquake over a millennium ago leveled most of the north side.
 
Traffic in the Old City has been restricted for awhile now. Which is great for tourists since it frees the the Corso Victor Emmanuele, connecting The Roman Forum to The Vatican, is only used for pedestrian traffic. Part of The Colosseum was used for building material in the MIddle Ages, an earthquake over a millennium ago leveled most of the north side.

I believe you are mistaken on the issue of Corso Victor Emmanuele, which was not a pedestrian zone when I was there recently. Maybe you are thinking of the street of the same name in Milano.
 
It would be interesting to see how this concrete would survive a Canadian winter.

What kills concrete is the freeze thaw cycles. Moisture gets into the concrete matrix during the warm seasons increasing the moisture content of the concrete. Then when it gets cold, the moisture freezes, expands and blows apart the concrete matrix. Every time. The Romans didn't have to contend with that. The second thing that kills concrete is the road salts that we use in the winter. It permeates the concrete and corrodes the reinforcing steel. Corrosion is an electrical reaction. The rebar expands when it corrodes and blows the concrete apart. (A la Gardiner Expressway.) Again, a killer. The third thing is the type of stone that we used to use, especially in Quebec, was the type that caused efflorescence. Or more accurately alkali silica reactivity. Which is that white powder you see on concrete. When it gets bad, it will blow apart concrete.

I've been to Rome several times and would hop on a plane today to go there if I could. When I'm in Rome, the thing that they have that blows away North America is not concrete. It's style. It's everywhere in Rome and practically nowhere in Toronto. The Romans built a city for the ages. Toronto built a city based on the cheap.
 
I believe you are mistaken on the issue of Corso Victor Emmanuele, which was not a pedestrian zone when I was there recently. Maybe you are thinking of the street of the same name in Milano.

It's a Google mistake, I know that road as Via della Republica. It used to be the victory parade route of Roman generals. You're probably right, I haven't been back since 2007. I've lost part of my memory from the car accident, there is an awesome restaurant on that road near the Torre Argentina. The name escapes me, they serve great local wines including Frascati (Italian Beaujolais) and specialize in mushrooms.

Danmand, if you've been there, refresh my memory per favore.
 
It's a Google mistake, I know that road as Via della Republica. It used to be the victory parade route of Roman generals. You're probably right, I haven't been back since 2007. I've lost part of my memory from the car accident, there is an awesome restaurant on that road near the Torre Argentina. The name escapes me, they serve great local wines including Frascati (Italian Beaujolais) and specialize in mushrooms.

Danmand, if you've been there, refresh my memory per favore.

I will be going on my yearly trip in march, and I may also decide to tour Italy in October. I will look up the restaurant for you (and for myself!). I have yet to find a poor restaurant in Rome, even as I sometimes eat at inexpensive places.