Scientific issue that has always bugged kme

How would you see the hole get smaller if you put a heating device inside the hole. The molecules would want to expand on the surface, they would cancel out with each other the inward movement becuase of other molecules around the circle also want to do the same. They would push out on the colder molecules further inside the block spreading the temperature gradient and progressing the heat through the block. Steel is elastic up to a point so it would expand.

The only way a hole would get smaller is if you heat up block from the outside becuse the hotter molecules would be pushing on all directions and compressing inwards the room temperature molecules on the surface of the hole. This would be very small amount because the steel will have a tendancy to expand due to heat vs. push inwards so pressure would be there but can be conisdered negilable compared to the expansion of the block. i.e. Path of least resistance. However once the heat spreads through the block and it is equally distributed the hole would get bigger once it reaches to molecules on the surface of the circle. So it depends on the heat, where it is applied and the time.

See post #28.

If you heat the metal from inside the hole, whether the hole gets larger or smaller depends on the relationship between the thermal conductivity of the metal and the rate of thermal expansion of the metal.

Suppose the metal is a good insulator (heat can travel only slowly through it), but it expands a lot per degree of heat.
Now, the hot metal around the hole tries to expand, but is hemmed in by the still cold metal around it. So the metal around the hole has no choice but to expand inwards, and the hole gets smaller.

Suppose the metal is a good conductor, but has only a low expansion rate.
Now, as the hot metal around the hole heats up, the metal lying just beyond that, also quickly heats, and it too expands. So the hole gets larger.

Whether the hole gets bigger or smaller depends also on how much heat you are pumping into the heater. The more kilowatts of heat, the more possible it becomes that the heat is being fed into the metal around the hole faster than the heat can dissipate outwards into the surrounding bulk of metal. The greater the temperature difference between the bulk of the metal and the skin of metal that defines the hole, the more likely it is that the expanding skin has nowhere to go, and is forced to expand inwards.

There is no way the central hole could shrink if the block were heated from the outside. If it were possible to heat the block evenly, the hole then would get bigger.