Sperm Race to Egg Shows Bigger Not Better as Shape Tops Thrust
By Michelle Fay Cortez
Nov. 24 (Bloomberg) -- The length of a sperm’s tail doesn’t always determine how fast it can swim or whether it’s likely to win the race to fertilize a woman’s egg, researchers said.
The finding challenges previous medical studies that suggested natural selection favors long-tailed sperm that are faster and more competitive than smaller rivals. The theory was based in part on studies showing sperm are longer in species where females mate with more than one male, forcing sperm to compete more to fertilize the egg.
The eel-like shape of the sperm’s tail led many researchers to wrongly assume that sperm locomotion is the same as eels, according to the paper in the journal BMC Evolutionary Biology. While a longer tail generates more thrust, the sperm’s larger head counteracts any gain, a counterintuitive finding that may one day improve treatment for male infertility or guide in-vitro fertilization, said Stuart Humphries, senior author of the paper from the University of Sheffield in the U.K.
“It seems clear that some assumptions regarding the physics of sperm locomotion have hampered our progress in understanding the processes” that control sperm competition, Humphries wrote. “Accounting for the balance between drag from the head and thrust from the tail will allow us to extend our understanding of the link between sperm form and function.”
Rather than focusing on the size of the tail or head, future studies should calculate their relative sizes, which is likely the real target of selection, the researchers concluded. The physical constraints on sperm swimming ability demand a “critical reappraisal” of the belief that sperm competition favors longer, more powerful sperm, they said.
The sperm’s head contains DNA that joins with DNA from an egg to create a new individual, according to the National Institutes of Health. The midsection supplies energy to propel the tail and create movement.
The research at this point is purely scientific, said Humphries, a biologist.
“Scientists outside the medical profession have been interested in how fast sperm can swim, thinking the faster it swims, the faster it gets to the egg,” he said in a telephone interview. “If we want progress, we need to get things straight from the start.”
Humphries compared sperm to a car, with many people tempted to judge speed by engine size without considering the size and weight of the vehicle.
“There are a lot of studies in science that show the faster the sperm, the better the chance of fertilization,” he said. “If a male has a faster sperm, the more likely he’s the father of the offspring. We may be able to look in the future at men who don’t have such great sperm and see if it has something to do with its shape.”
To contact the reporter on this story: Michelle Fay Cortez in London at mcortez@bloomberg.net
Last Updated: November 24, 2008 19:00 EST
By Michelle Fay Cortez
Nov. 24 (Bloomberg) -- The length of a sperm’s tail doesn’t always determine how fast it can swim or whether it’s likely to win the race to fertilize a woman’s egg, researchers said.
The finding challenges previous medical studies that suggested natural selection favors long-tailed sperm that are faster and more competitive than smaller rivals. The theory was based in part on studies showing sperm are longer in species where females mate with more than one male, forcing sperm to compete more to fertilize the egg.
The eel-like shape of the sperm’s tail led many researchers to wrongly assume that sperm locomotion is the same as eels, according to the paper in the journal BMC Evolutionary Biology. While a longer tail generates more thrust, the sperm’s larger head counteracts any gain, a counterintuitive finding that may one day improve treatment for male infertility or guide in-vitro fertilization, said Stuart Humphries, senior author of the paper from the University of Sheffield in the U.K.
“It seems clear that some assumptions regarding the physics of sperm locomotion have hampered our progress in understanding the processes” that control sperm competition, Humphries wrote. “Accounting for the balance between drag from the head and thrust from the tail will allow us to extend our understanding of the link between sperm form and function.”
Rather than focusing on the size of the tail or head, future studies should calculate their relative sizes, which is likely the real target of selection, the researchers concluded. The physical constraints on sperm swimming ability demand a “critical reappraisal” of the belief that sperm competition favors longer, more powerful sperm, they said.
The sperm’s head contains DNA that joins with DNA from an egg to create a new individual, according to the National Institutes of Health. The midsection supplies energy to propel the tail and create movement.
The research at this point is purely scientific, said Humphries, a biologist.
“Scientists outside the medical profession have been interested in how fast sperm can swim, thinking the faster it swims, the faster it gets to the egg,” he said in a telephone interview. “If we want progress, we need to get things straight from the start.”
Humphries compared sperm to a car, with many people tempted to judge speed by engine size without considering the size and weight of the vehicle.
“There are a lot of studies in science that show the faster the sperm, the better the chance of fertilization,” he said. “If a male has a faster sperm, the more likely he’s the father of the offspring. We may be able to look in the future at men who don’t have such great sperm and see if it has something to do with its shape.”
To contact the reporter on this story: Michelle Fay Cortez in London at mcortez@bloomberg.net
Last Updated: November 24, 2008 19:00 EST

