schiff vs "patriotic millionaire"

I find it interesting that people who make such statements almost never take action so as to voluntarily pay more tax.
 
I find it interesting that people who make such statements almost never take action so as to voluntarily pay more tax.

US Treasury has an account set up just for this, oddly rich liberals who favor the rich paying more rarely use it....
 
US Treasury has an account set up just for this, oddly rich liberals who favor the rich paying more rarely use it....

I imagine it's because they would be making all the effort themselves, but for everyone's benefit; you do all the work, but experience only a fraction of the benefit.

Think of it this way. Say the four people in your household (including you) contribute 25% to paying the hydro bill, and you think it would be better for everyone if the bill was lower...so you make an effort to conserve energy. No one else decides to help. You do 100% of the work, but receive only 25% of the benefit.

Now apply it to the tax code. The rich paying more would supposedly help with the debt problem, but having only a few paying a lot extra in tax would have a much smaller impact than everyone paying a little and would spread the load around more.
 
I imagine it's because they would be making all the effort themselves, but for everyone's benefit; you do all the work, but experience only a fraction of the benefit.

Think of it this way. Say the four people in your household (including you) contribute 25% to paying the hydro bill, and you think it would be better for everyone if the bill was lower...so you make an effort to conserve energy. No one else decides to help. You do 100% of the work, but receive only 25% of the benefit.

Now apply it to the tax code. The rich paying more would supposedly help with the debt problem, but having only a few paying a lot extra in tax would have a much smaller impact than everyone paying a little and would spread the load around more.

That's not a particularly apt analogy.

Here's a better one:

http://www.fortunewatch.com/the-obama-tax-system-explained-in-beer/

Now, stop after the 10th line ("The tenth man (the richest) would pay $59."). The equivalent action for liberal rich people donating more taxes via the IRS's voluntary donation route would be for that 10th man to pay more than $59 (call it $69), allowing the first 6 men to pay nothing and the 7-9th men to pay $2 less than they had previously ($5, $10, and $16, respectively). That's a nice thing, if he chooses to do so. But he doesn't. The rich liberals in this case actually DEMAND that the government FORCE everyone in his tax bracket to pay the extra $10, but refuses to do so himself until he is forced to.

Patriotism is not forced. You can't force someone to be patriotic. Taxes, by their very nature, are forced. If you don't pay them, men with guns will eventually come and force you to stay in substandard public housing for a substantial period of time. Serving in the military when you're drafted isn't patriotic. It's not a BAD thing, and I give those who responded credit for doing so, but you didn't volunteer. Don't pretend that you did. Same thing with taxes.

The real-world equivalent of your above heating scenario would be the rich person starting business that helped lower the deficit, which is a real world impossibility. The government, unfortunately, is the only body that can lower the deficit and get rid of the national debt through a combination of promoting economic growth (and therefore raising their revenues, since their revenues are tied to the GDP) and cutting costs. In particular, "dead money" costs that don't accomplish anything except suck in billions of dollars.