Rosetta Stone vs. Pimsleur Approach?

Pimsleur all the way.

Rosetta Stone is a ripoff from what I hear
 
I have been studying French.

I have tried Pimsler - ugh, puts you to sleep

I tried U of T night classes - too expensive and no better

I tried the Alliance Francais on Spadina north of Bloor - mixed emotions on this place. It's a little loosie goosie for me. The "text books" (so called, more like $45.00 magazines are TERRIBLE)

And I have gone to Humber.

By far, Humber is the best. Right price, right concepts on how to teach, right text book.

In all cases, so much depends on your teacher. I went to the Alliance Francais and had one excellent teacher there - Henry. Was a very adept guy at teaching and speaking and good sense of humour. 2 other teachers after that - not so good. Last one (some woman) was down right abusive.

Humber, had one EXCELLENT teacher. If she was teaching, I would take everything she taught. One other woman that was good and one downright IDIOT - some guy from the middle east who would just stand up there and talk. He would stand up there and tell us about his job and about health issues and about virginity in the Middle East being important. I quit going about one third of the way through the semester I disliked him that much.

For me to learn, I need the rules of the language explained to me in English. Some teachers refuse to speak English at all and it makes it very very difficult. (They figure that by speaking French all the time about everything, it forces you to learn, however, when it comes to structure (and French is structured very differently than English), I like to have it explained in English. Everything else can be in French.)

But without a doubt, for me, the best option is Humber College.
 
Wow, I was just going to buy this to learn Spanish. Is it a rip off in terms of cost or does it not work? There is a special right now on for $299.
 
I tried U of T night classes - too expensive and no better

I attempted to take a French class when I was at U of T. I felt that half the class was more fluent in French than they let on in order to get a really easy high grade and increase their GPA. I'd heard stories like that and found it to be true in that case. I was struggling to keep up and ended up dropping the course. :(



For me to learn, I need the rules of the language explained to me in English. Some teachers refuse to speak English at all and it makes it very very difficult. (They figure that by speaking French all the time about everything, it forces you to learn

Yep, the teacher of that class almost refused to speak English at all which made it more difficult for me. I understand the concept of immersion but felt I was unable to keep up with others in the class.
 
Learning a language in my opinion is an "all of the above" affair. It's got to get pretty deep into your brain, there is no magic answer. You need to do anything and everything you can, every day.

Ultimately you need to immerse yourself in the language, use it daily in real life situations with native speakers interactively as much as possible. Pimsleur is great preparation for immersion as it will give you a remarkably large number of useful templates up front that you can put into service in many common conversational situations, and it will also help you more with your pronunciation than any other self study method.

It's not enough by itself though. You need to have a good foundation, which means some sort of classroom or book study, until you've got a good handle on the grammar. Pimsleur also won't give you a huge vocabulary, to get that you will need some sort of flash cards or similar. I understand Rosetta is good at vocabulary building, though I've never used it myself. Flash cards are great because you can put a couple dozen in your pocket and pull them out during the day whenever you have to wait a few minutes for something.

I do think Pimsleur is pretty good and I've used it a lot myself, but you have to understand that it's only a small part of your overall language learning. You have to do a lot if you want to learn a language, and you have to do it every day.

For me what has been successful is course + pimsleur + flashcards + seeking out native speakers and using it as much as possible (e.g., travel, finding friends who speak that language, etc.) and setting aside at least 30 minutes a day, every day, to do at least one of those things every day.
 
It's not enough by itself though. You need to have a good foundation, which means some sort of classroom or book study, until you've got a good handle on the grammar. Pimsleur also won't give you a huge vocabulary, to get that you will need some sort of flash cards or similar. I understand Rosetta is good at vocabulary building, though I've never used it myself.

I think I have a relatively decent vocabulary in French. I really need to work on the grammar and conversational stuff.
 
I think I have a relatively decent vocabulary in French. I really need to work on the grammar and conversational stuff.

In that case I'd say take a course, ideally a couple of nights a week, and do pimsleur on the days you don't have the course.
 
Here in Ottawa the easiest way to learn French is to get a job in construction! Quebec building trades are a closed shop so all the non-union workers end up on this side of the river.

In Toronto, that probably only works for Portuguese or something like that?
 
I can order drinks in several languages, but after I've had a few I find is best to just blend them altogether and speak Sprench. It's English, French and Spanish together. When I am in a foreign country, I just speak it really loudly and with great enthusiasm, with an increasing degree of exasperation. It works beautifully!

Is the Rosetta Stone you buy at Best Buy etc the same as the online version do you know? I thought I might try it to bone up...
 
Souhaitez-vous coucher avec moi?........ Oui, oui, deux cents dollars par heure. Learn this first and you will get a good start on the language
 
I have both Rosetta and Pimsleur and imo I find Rosetta to be quite a bit more effective and interactive. Rosetta teaches you the way a child learns, via images ie a child points to something and asks "dat"(baby talk for whats that).
Pimsleur is strictly a listen and learn program which I find very boring and sleep inducing.

Both Rosetta Stone and Pimsleur offer free trials, try them out and decide for yourself
 
I can order drinks in several languages, but after I've had a few I find is best to just blend them altogether and speak Sprench. It's English, French and Spanish together. When I am in a foreign country, I just speak it really loudly and with great enthusiasm, with an increasing degree of exasperation.

Sprench! LOL I can order red wine in 5 different languages. :p
 
Just speak English slowly like you would to a dog. They all understand.