ROBOCALLS investigation dumped.

fmahovalich

Active member
Aug 21, 2009
7,256
25
38
It would seem that Prime Minister Stephen HArper HAS BEEN CLEARED IN THE ROBOCALL 'scandal' after all.

After much shouting by the left after the last election, and after a huge waste of taxpayers dollars, the ROBOCALL investigation has been found without merit and has been boxed.

Nothing to see here folks.


Of course we don't see the media party saying much about this!!!
 
There is plenty to see- they can't prove anything but that doesn't mean it didn't happen- robocalls should be banned
 
I'll just C&P my post from the thread on the same subject in in the P&IA forum;

So let me see, an investigative body that can't compel witness to give evidence, can't arrest them if they don't, has evidence destroyed or can't do much beyond a slap on the wrist as a sanction, failed to find evidence of wrong doing? DUH!!!
 
There were roughly 40,000 complaints filed about robocalls to Elections Canada. Yves Cote, the Commissioner of Canada Elections has reported that 39,350 of those complaints were traced back to "Leadnow" a left wing activist group. That says it all.
 
There were roughly 40,000 complaints filed about robocalls to Elections Canada. Yves Cote, the Commissioner of Canada Elections has reported that 39,350 of those complaints were traced back to "Leadnow" a left wing activist group. That says it all.

MF2 supplied a copy of the report in the other thread. Perhaps you can offer up the paragraph the reported that .MF2 quote on another point was found wanting when you actually looked at it in black and white.

If it is this part, not quite as you suggest;

The Commissioner received over 40,000 general communications and complaints about
“robocalls.”5 Most were from people who said they had not actually received an inappropriate
call, but wished to express their concern that these kinds of calls had taken place. In all, 39,350
were received via an online form sponsored by an organization called Leadnow. Electors
were encouraged by Leadnow to complete the form (which had a prefilled message that could
be revised) and send it to a number of intended recipients, including the Commissioner. The
vast majority of those 39,350 communications seemed to simply reproduce the form’s original
wording.
 
Commissioner has made it clear 96% of the complaints are not being taken seriously as they shouldn't. Investigative body had no legal right to force anyone to testify or answer questions, no different if you get hauled into the police station they can't force you to answer questions or co operate in an investigation as it should be.
 
Commissioner has made it clear 96% of the complaints are not being taken seriously as they shouldn't. Investigative body had no legal right to force anyone to testify or answer questions, no different if you get hauled into the police station they can't force you to answer questions or co operate in an investigation as it should be.

Police can't force you to answer, but they sure can legally make you life miserable of you take that tact. I'll let the lawyers on TERB fill you in on how. The commission can do diddly.
 
See also the thread in the more appropriate Politics Forum. In fact, Harper was never accused nor implicated, so its the grossest sort of mis-statement to say he was cleared. The Commissioner did find that there was wrongdoing, but was unable to get to the bottom of the matter with the powers and resources he has, so in fact no one has been cleared of anything.

All he said was that he didn't have the evidence to proceed with any charges.
 
groggy will be so pleased :biggrin1:

We all know the Liberals will provincially will spend a billlion of our money to win a seat, so its a good thing to know that their federal counterparts can't spend any more on a seat they already won ( Guelph).
 
The Commissioner did find that there was wrongdoing, but was unable to get to the bottom of the matter with the powers and resources he has, so in fact no one has been cleared of anything.

That's not what the commissioner said. He explicitly said there was no evidence of wrongdoing (an error is not necessarily "wrongdoing").

http://www.elections.ca/content.aspx?section=com&document=apr2414&dir=pre-com&lang=e

You managed to get it completely wrong in two different forums.
 
Another coverup by this corrupt scandalous secretive ultra right conservative government. Three years of this was enough and destroyed democracy in Canada something that nations give their lives all over the world to achieve it and we had it already.

well said...Harpo tries to make his own rules just glad to see he isn't getting away with the bully boy tactics...
 
I'll just C&P my post from the thread on the same subject in in the P&IA forum;

So let me see, an investigative body that can't compel witness to give evidence, can't arrest them if they don't, has evidence destroyed or can't do much beyond a slap on the wrist as a sanction, failed to find evidence of wrong doing? DUH!!!

That's not what the commissioner said. He explicitly said there was no evidence of wrongdoing (an error is not necessarily "wrongdoing").

http://www.elections.ca/content.aspx?section=com&document=apr2414&dir=pre-com&lang=e

You managed to get it completely wrong in two different forums.

.... and the explanation for that failure is quite clear but apparently needs repeating.

Then we have this from your link;


  • The Commissioner has concluded that, following a thorough investigation by his Office, the evidence is not sufficient to provide reasonable grounds to believe that an offence was committed. Therefore, the Commissioner will not refer the matter to the Director of Public Prosecutions.
... not that there was no evidence found. The hardest thing to prove was intent.
 
  • The Commissioner has concluded that, following a thorough investigation by his Office, the evidence is not sufficient to provide reasonable grounds to believe that an offence was committed. Therefore, the Commissioner will not refer the matter to the Director of Public Prosecutions.

... not that there was no evidence found.

Too bad you forgot to add the quote from the next bullet point, about the Honourable Louise Charron offering "strong support" for "the finding that there are no grounds to believe that an offence was committed."

The statement is unequivocally clear. There is evidence that erroneous calls occurred but there are "no grounds" to believe that the errors were intentional.
 
Too bad you forgot to add the quote from the next bullet point, about the Honourable Louise Charron offering "strong support" for "the finding that there are no grounds to believe that an offence was committed."

The statement is unequivocally clear. There is evidence that erroneous calls occurred but there are "no grounds" to believe that the errors were intentional.

Do you understand the principal of mens rea?
 
There were roughly 40,000 complaints filed about robocalls to Elections Canada. Yves Cote, the Commissioner of Canada Elections has reported that 39,350 of those complaints were traced back to "Leadnow" a left wing activist group. That says it all.
It says that there were at least 650 legitimate breaches of the elections act by the Tories.
 
Says who,...???

It says that there were at least 650 legitimate breaches of the elections act by the Tories.

A complaint does NOT constitute,... legitimate breaches of the elections act by the Tories

FAST
 
A complaint does NOT constitute,... legitimate breaches of the elections act by the Tories

FAST
Quite so. If it did, there'd be 39,350 'legitimate' breaches of the Elections Act by the Tories, instead of the mere 650 under discussion.
 
Another coverup by this corrupt scandalous secretive ultra right conservative government. Three years of this was enough and destroyed democracy in Canada something that nations give their lives all over the world to achieve it and we had it already.

Harper doesn't nearly as well as Dalton and Wynn. Next you will be accusing the Harp of erasing computer files.
 
Harper doesn't nearly as well as Dalton and Wynn. Next you will be accusing the Harp of erasing computer files.

Electoral fraud is pretty serious.
Harper has been accused of deleting files with the Duffy scandal, but with the robocall scandal its all party computers and people he wouldn't let talk with Elections Canada.