Rob Ford - Mistake #1

fuji

Banned
Jan 31, 2005
79,936
9
0
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
is.gd
Rob Ford took a combative stance in naming committee chairs and other positions in his first week as mayor.

Instead of offering an olive branch to those who ran against him in the election he completely excluded the opposition from any role in any council committee or other post. Ordinarily some position, however token, would be offered in an attempt to build a consensus and signal a willingness to work together.

Of course the incoming mayor has a mandate to fulfill, and would be expected to name supporters to key posts, especially those strongly related to his mandate. But usually there's something, somewhere, that can be offered up in the name of working together, especially to a member of the "opposition" who expresses respect for the fact that they mayor has his mandate.

This is Rob Ford mistake #1.

In the short term he's got the votes from his right wing supporters to push through his mandate--but just barely. He does not have any sort of overwhelming majority at council. He will, inevitably, have to try and forge a consensus, or he will, inevitably, be unable to implement his mandate.

In the immediate aftermath of the election his win is going to mean that no-body will seriously oppose what he's trying to do--moderates on council will vote for his initiatives for the good reason that he's just won a mandate.

That won't last.

Within a year, the first time he gaffes something, or does something unpopular, he will not be able to call in any favours. He won't have earned any. He will face a council stacked with people he's said "fuck you" too, and they will be licking their chops for an opportunity to bloody his nose.

Consequence:

Ford's combative style is already evident, and he has sown the seeds of his own destruction. Unless he alters his combative stance sooner or later council is going to deadlock in combative acrimony. Nothing will get done. Ford's mandate will not be implemented.

With this style he's got max one year before he's already a lame duck mayor.
 
lame.

How many committee chairs was Rob Ford named to under Miller? Where was the olive branch from the left wing during the last 7 years and were 6 of them lame duck years? Or does it only go one way? LOL

Rob Ford got a strong mandate and a decisive vote in his favour. An interesting tid bit i heard was that he got more direct votes that any other Canadian politician in history (remember you dont vote for your PM, the party picks them). And besides, combative stance? I think the voters of Toronto have spoken pretty loudly that they want change from the old ways, not appeasement.
 
Miller did name several people on the center right to various posts, though. Just not Ford. Ford, remember, never even got along with the right wing on council--he was always a loner.
 
Rob Ford got a strong mandate and a decisive vote in his favour.

Yeah, that will carry him through the next six months, maybe even a year. His term is a hell of a lot longer than that, though. The moment he does something unpopular or gaffes something up they'll pounce.
 
1Within a year, the first time he gaffes something, or does something unpopular, he will not be able to call in any favours. He won't have earned any. He will face a council stacked with people he's said "fuck you" too, and they will be licking their chops for an opportunity to bloody his nose.

Consequence:

Ford's combative style is already evident, and he has sown the seeds of his own destruction. Unless he alters his combative stance sooner or later council is going to deadlock in combative acrimony. Nothing will get done. Ford's mandate will not be implemented.

With this style he's got max one year before he's already a lame duck mayor.

Thanks Fuji... You have managed to capture the essence of the problem with our political process and our bureaucrats and the state of our society in general.
NO ONE CARES IF YOU ARE DOING THE RIGHT THING OR WRONG THING AS LONG AS YOU HAVE ENOUGH SUPPORT TO DO IT.

In the case of Toronto City Council, its about having the majority to PUSH through your ideas, or being able to CALL IN FAVORS.

I realize that I am being a bit idealistic in this, but should these councillors be voting on things based on whether it is a good thing or a bad thing for the city?

Isn't one of the reasons that councillors are not affiliated with a particular political party is so that they don't have to vote like sheep?
 
He put supporters into key positions, that was expected. He had no friends on the left, besides mamolitti who is a recent political oporrtunist. He would never recieve any support from the left wing in any event.
The right wingers Miller put in positions were always out numbered by his little lefties.

I am of the opinion that breathing is a mistake rob ford makes, at least in your opinion.
 
He won't receive any support from the left precisely because he has taken a combative approach and has demonstrated he has no interest in consensus building. This will work for him only for so long as he can claim to have a strong mandate. At some point council is going to assert that they too were elected and given mandates and he is going to face trouble there.
 
He won't receive any support from the left precisely because he has taken a combative approach and has demonstrated he has no interest in consensus building. This will work for him only for so long as he can claim to have a strong mandate. At some point council is going to assert that they too were elected and given mandates and he is going to face trouble there.

There is a significant difference between the mayors mandate on the platform he ran on city wide and a local councilors mandate . The left were never going to support much of anything he ran on, so why would he put them in a position to obstruct what he considers his job?

Being a nice guy and appearing to make nice would be facitious and the voters know that. He is better off doing things honestly rather than politically
 
It's not really a matter of Ford "…putting them[leftsh councillors] in a position to obstruct what he considers his job". He's perfectly within his rights to nominate whomever he wishes to jobs he's empowered to fill.

But he hasn't got a majority he can command. At least Harpo can command almost a majority in Ottawa, thanks to party discipline (remember when Reform stood for free votes?); Rob can command just one vote. And some of those jobs Rob nominated folks for actually need Council approval of their appointment.

Everyone of those Councillors has just as much a mandate as Rob, to vote as they and their constituents believe best. It's up to Rob, as the only Council member elected at large, citywide to persuade a majority of them that his vision is valid and merits their support. While Ottawa gives some evidence that dictatorship by a minority can prevail, most of us still believe it takes a majority to run a democracy. And in civic politics your majority has to be rebuilt daily. Good luck Rob.
 
It's not really a matter of Ford "…putting them[leftsh councillors] in a position to obstruct what he considers his job". He's perfectly within his rights to nominate whomever he wishes to jobs he's empowered to fill.

But he hasn't got a majority he can command. At least Harpo can command almost a majority in Ottawa, thanks to party discipline (remember when Reform stood for free votes?); Rob can command just one vote. And some of those jobs Rob nominated folks for actually need Council approval of their appointment.

Everyone of those Councillors has just as much a mandate as Rob, to vote as they and their constituents believe best. It's up to Rob, as the only Council member elected at large, citywide to persuade a majority of them that his vision is valid and merits their support. While Ottawa gives some evidence that dictatorship by a minority can prevail, most of us still believe it takes a majority to run a democracy. And in civic politics your majority has to be rebuilt daily. Good luck Rob.

Why should he have to convince the councilors that his policies are correct, the voters already decided that and are the councilors not the servents of their constituants?
 
so why would he put them in a position to obstruct what he considers his job?

Here's a clue why: The right don't have enough votes on council to do it any other way. If he doesn't build a consensus and run the city as the mayor for all of Toronto he is going to get blocked by council and he will be a lame duck mayor before the first year is up.

Council has pretty much the same left/right balance now as it did under Miller.

For awhile the moderates are going to support Ford because, as you say, he won city wide--but they will stop doing that the moment he does something unpopular, and at that point Ford will have no favours to call in.

Miller did always reach out and find allies on the other side to get his initiatives through, Ford's going to find out that council actually have a few teeth and can bite if not well treated.
 
Why should he have to convince the councilors that his policies are correct, the voters already decided that and are the councilors not the servents of their constituants?

The voters also elected a council that is NOT a far right council. Shouldn't that be seen as part of voter intention too? They did not elect Rob Ford mayor with a right wing council. They elected Rob Ford mayor with a center-left council. Should that not be understood as the voters saying they want to keep Rob Ford on a tight leash?
 
Not only that but he also has a sore loser named fuji who is going to relentlessly attack him on an escort review board. :eek:

Maybe you should stick to the Toronto Star online board where you will among your friends. If Ford had named socialists as you want you would be crowing about how weak he is and how the left will rise again. Lefties have to serve your four year timeout so just sit back and take your medicine. We had to put up with that flake David Miller.

D.
 
I'm going to sit back and laugh until I cry.
Increasing the police force when they don't want more officers and can't afford them?
Idiot.

It won't take long before his slogans get boring and everyone realizes his plans are stupid.
 
I'm going to sit back and laugh until I cry.
Increasing the police force when they don't want more officers and can't afford them?
Idiot.

It won't take long before his slogans get boring and everyone realizes his plans are stupid.

He might very well be a disaster but he will probably do less damage than those highbrowed "I know what is best for you" politicians who preceded him. I'm glad to take my chances with him.

Plus, some stupid people think they are liked [hint: mirror].

D.
 
Maybe you should stick to the Toronto Star online board where you will among your friends. If Ford had named socialists as you want you would be crowing about how weak he is and how the left will rise again. Lefties have to serve your four year timeout so just sit back and take your medicine. We had to put up with that flake David Miller.

D.
Maybe you should get somebody to explain my post to you.