road tolls revisited

simon482

internets icon
Feb 8, 2009
9,945
181
63
i started a new thread cuz i don't want to look for the old one.

so i was driving through georgia and i noticed something, the roads are in great condition the lawns and fences by the roads are flawless and they have a service driving around that is basically a mobile mechanic to help any car that is broken down.

they don't have any road tolls and their sales tax is far lower than ours. so why can they do more with less money then we can with more ?
 
They also don't have this thing we call winter. No snow, ice and freezing temps makes for much better roads. We have that mobile mechanic too, its called CAA.

Cheers
 
I was told that Georgia girls are much more feminine and approachable than the Toronto ones. Is that because of this thing called winter too?
 
They also don't have this thing we call winter. No snow, ice and freezing temps makes for much better roads. We have that mobile mechanic too, its called CAA.

Cheers

caa is not a free service and while their winters are not as fierce as ours they still do get ice and shitty conditions. our gov't takes in a far greater amount than their's, so why is their gov't doing more with less ? is it that our gov't just doesn't give a fuck about the people and theirs does or are they just smarter with money.

indiana has toll roads and their roads are shit, worse than ours. they have winters as bad as ours as well. so why can't they get their shit together with toll money and you think our gov't will.

i guess what i am saying is the problem is with the spending not with what is collected.
 
Because they're spending their money on the roads, NOT health care, education, social services, etc.
 
roads are used less too. state of georgia has 9 million people...the GTA has 5.5 million.

are you trying to say that major interstates are not used as highways in toronto ?
 
also why is it so hard for you people to admit that the gov't has a spending issue. you are all way to quick to make excuses why other places are better.

indiana has the same winters, tornado's and road tolls and their highways are worse than ours. while other states with winters like ours and no road tolls have better quality highways.

stop making excuses for your gov'ts lack of ability to be accountable for their spending. other places with the same conditions do more with less.

collect less and spend responibly seems to work in other places, why are we collect more spend more and still can't pull it off.
 
I really think that the biggest reason we seem to have higher taxes, spend more and seem to see less in terms of roads and infrastructure is because of or excellent but universal and expensive health care system. I think it takes a third or more of our taxes to fund. US states don't have this overhead.

and they don't have the sales tax that we do. also a person can survive on 8$ an hour down there. not happening up here. i am not saying i want to live down there, i am just saying in my travels down there that they collect less and do more with it. take the percentage off the top for health care and we probably collect the same that they do. why is it that they are so far advanced with how and where to spend then we are.
 
Michigan freeways are in good shape--outside of Detroit. I got cement smooth wide roads here, 45 to 70 mph limits. The lanes are wider, pave wide shoulders on both sides of the freeways. No toll roads, gas for $3.70 US a gallon. No smog, safety checks.

The only road that comes close is parts of the 401 but with less traffic and high set speed limits and no stunt driving bs laws....plus my kid, if i had one, can buy and play a video game of car jacking and killing pretend people..

now if the hotties could be a little more corporative and we could get lap dancing back in Detroit it be nice
 
Intellect and Integrity of those in charge of the monies.

I do remember using a toll highway in Atlanta between downtown and the burbs. Think it was 50cents each way.
 
they don't have any road tolls and their sales tax is far lower than ours. so why can they do more with less money then we can with more ?

They don't have winter. Seriously. A cold climate dramatically increases the cost of road maintenance, the freezing and unfreezing is murder on the road surface, the bridges, and other structures.

You will also notice a lot more old model cars on the road in the south for a similar reason: They don't have salt on their roads, so their cars don't rust.
 
also a person can survive on 8$ an hour down there.

A person can pretty much survive sleeping outside year round down there. At most you need to throw up four tent posts and a tarp, and put a pallet on the ground, to keep you away from the rain. Your heating bill sure is a lot lower, and your home is cheaper to build because you don't have to buy fancy double pane glass, install a furnace, or spring for costly insulation.
 
They don't have winter. Seriously. A cold climate dramatically increases the cost of road maintenance, the freezing and unfreezing is murder on the road surface, the bridges, and other structures.

You will also notice a lot more old model cars on the road in the south for a similar reason: They don't have salt on their roads, so their cars don't rust.

and what about the examples i used in states that have the same winter as us ? there is more to it than just some cold.
 
and what about the examples i used in states that have the same winter as us ? there is more to it than just some cold.

Sure, there's more to it than just some cold, but cold is a big factor in cities that have it.

There are a variety of ways to fund road construction. Toronto's plainly under-funded, ever since the Province downloaded so many services to the city, but did not provide the revenue to pay for them. If we got the funding model right in Toronto there's no reason why we couldn't improve our roads too, whether that's by adding road tolls, giving the city a share of the gas tax or sales tax, or whatever. I am guessing those places you are thinking about have funded their municipal government properly, or else the roads are maintained by the State.
 
and what about the examples i used in states that have the same winter as us ? there is more to it than just some cold.
And the Scaninavian countries have even worse winters. The point is not to make comparisons elsewhere—especially not with flawed or failing regimes—but to decide what we want for our nation and its communities.

Road tolls are just a user fee, like so many others our governments are considering or have already imposed on us. If we don't want user-pay for roads (never mind the energy and environmental costs that no government on this sde of the Atlantic has shown the guts to face up to) then what do we want? And if we can afford free roads for all, why not good EI, adequate daycare or respectable pensions? Or even decent schools and children's denticare?

But as to Georgia, a state with bad education, abysmal poverty, inadequate sovcial services, and far fewer police dealing with a much higher crime rate than we have, they decided that good free roads to take you from your gated community to the mall and back were where they wanted to spend their local state and federal tax dollars.
 
Sure, there's more to it than just some cold, but cold is a big factor in cities that have it.

There are a variety of ways to fund road construction. Toronto's plainly under-funded, ever since the Province downloaded so many services to the city, but did not provide the revenue to pay for them. If we got the funding model right in Toronto there's no reason why we couldn't improve our roads too, whether that's by adding road tolls, giving the city a share of the gas tax or sales tax, or whatever. I am guessing those places you are thinking about have funded their municipal government properly, or else the roads are maintained by the State.

how can you say toronto is under funded when places with less funding are doing just fine. take canadian expamples then like the entire northern part of ontario from barrie up. far better road conditions, better plowing in the winter and frankly more to do than in toronto. this is more to do with the lack of ability to spend properly than it is to do with the city needing more money.
 
And the Scaninavian countries have even worse winters. The point is not to make comparisons elsewhere—especially not with flawed or failing regimes—but to decide what we want for our nation and its communities.

Road tolls are just a user fee, like so many others our governments are considering or have already imposed on us. If we don't want user-pay for roads (never mind the energy and environmental costs that no government on this sde of the Atlantic has shown the guts to face up to) then what do we want? And if we can afford free roads for all, why not good EI, adequate daycare or respectable pensions? Or even decent schools and children's denticare?

But as to Georgia, a state with bad education, abysmal poverty, inadequate sovcial services, and far fewer police dealing with a much higher crime rate than we have, they decided that good free roads to take you from your gated community to the mall and back were where they wanted to spend their local state and federal tax dollars.

utah, wyoming, nebraska, texas and missouri all have better roads than toronto and once you take the health care cut off the top were are getting the same roughly in taxes they do. hell we are getting more just based on cigarette sales. carton of smokes in any of those states is about 40-45 a pop here i am guessing it is about 60-65.
 
how can you say toronto is under funded when places with less funding are doing just fine. take canadian expamples then like the entire northern part of ontario from barrie up. far better road conditions, better plowing in the winter and frankly more to do than in toronto. this is more to do with the lack of ability to spend properly than it is to do with the city needing more money.

Where do you get the ideas that those other places receive less funding? Note that on things like sales tax Toronto currently collects ZERO sales tax, ZERO gas tax, ZERO income tax.

The basic Canadian problem is that the Federal level collects the majority of the tax, and pays for a minority of the services, leaving the Provinces and the Municipalities chronically under-funded. We need to transfer a lot of the Federal tax to the provinces and the cities, so basically a federal tax cut combined with a rise in provincial/municipal tax. Perhaps Ottawa's share of the GST should be given to Toronto and Ontario.
 
Where do you get the ideas that those other places receive less funding? Note that on things like sales tax Toronto currently collects ZERO sales tax, ZERO gas tax, ZERO income tax.

The basic Canadian problem is that the Federal level collects the majority of the tax, and pays for a minority of the services, leaving the Provinces and the Municipalities chronically under-funded. We need to transfer a lot of the Federal tax to the provinces and the cities, so basically a federal tax cut combined with a rise in provincial/municipal tax. Perhaps Ottawa's share of the GST should be given to Toronto and Ontario.

so i guess you missed the part where i said we need to do better with the money we have. like redirecting it to places that need it instead of wasting on shit we don't.