RIP Gord Downie

I don’t think you understand what a (pop/cultural) icon is.

Celine Dion and Shania Twain are Canadian musical icons. It would seem that Justin Bieber and Michael Buble have had the longevity to earn this status as-well. My personal tastes with regard to any of their music doesn’t make them any less iconic.

Biggie Smalls, Tupac, Janis Joplin, Kurt Cobain, Amy Winehouse, Jimi Hendrix and Sid Vicious (et al) weren't exactly Bono in-terms of philanthropy, yet they achieved status as cultural icons. We didn’t somehow ‘strip’ status from James Brown or Michael Jackson when it became pretty evident that they were not-so great people.

As for why he didn’t donate proceeds from the last tour, I’m not sure if that’s correct or incorrect. Gord was 20% of the Hip. His bandmates aren’t exactly hurting, but knowing it was the last real Hip tour ever would make me want to be careful with those $$$. Gord had a(n almost ex-)wife and 4 kids in private school. He was NOT expecting to stop touring or making music any time soon, at-least that’s what he said to a friend of mine when they were on vacation together over the years. Financially, I’m told he wasn’t prepared for this. His kids won’t be going to public school any time soon, but they’ll probably use that schooling for the jobs they’ll inevitably need.

Gord had business class/rental vacation home money, not private jet/private island money.

Regardless, I believe proceeds from The Secret Path went to his Wenjack fund. I’m a big fan of the cause, and can’t recall a musician, including Tribe Called Red, who did more for indigenous reconciliation in Canada, even though he seemed to only get involved in 2011 or 2012. I met Gord for the first time when I was involved with Waterkeeper Lake Ontario in the early 2000s so I can say for sure that he’s not exactly a stranger to doing the right thing.

Could he have done more? Probably. Who, including myself, can honestly say it’s impossible to have done more?

Good reply - you should have stoped here. Anything after this is just a repeat of what you have already said.
 
I will take that answer as you did not even know about the fund raiser. The Secret path which this fund raiser was about, was Gord's only real acknowledgement. Chanie Wenjack was the child in the story.

Sorry to bust your bubble but I've been following this band since their first album in the late 80s.

I'm also fully aware of the Secret Path project and fundraiser. But to suggest, if fans didn't make "deep pocket donations" then they are not honouring Gordie is ridiculous.

Billboard is an American company. Who gets to the top of it, depends on your timing of the release of the music. But if you want to use that, who are the Canadians listed on the yearly 100. The Hip is not one of them.
You should have read a little closer. My objection was Cultural Icon, or the most popular musician.

The Hip never broke through to the US market. But that doesn't change the fact that Gordie is a Canadian icon.

But don't take it from me. https://www.thestar.com/entertainment/music/2017/10/18/gord-downies-death-spurs-tribute-from-canadian-musicians-queens-park-politicians-and-more.html
 
8th generation Anglo Saxon Canadian, and under 65.
Could you name all musicians in every field of music. I doubt it, even more so if you, listen to another type as your preference.
Billboard is an American company. Who gets to the top of it, depends on your timing of the release of the music. But if you want to use that, who are the Canadians listed on the yearly 100. The Hip is not one of them.
You should have read a little closer. My objection was Cultural Icon, or the most popular musician.

I’m still absolutely perplexed, assuming you don’t live and work exclusively in a cave network without radio for the past 20+ years how you could have missed Gord Downie or the Tragically Hip. No, I can’t name all musicians in all genres of music. But I know why Gord Downie was an important guy. Just like I knew why Glen Gould, Leonard Cohen Oscar Peterson or even Stompin’ Tom was an important guy. What do they have in common, other than being musicians and Canadian? They’re cultural icons.

Again, I’ll ask, who are the true Canadian icons if Gord isn’t one?

Remember, iconic status isn’t bestowed by a subculture (or niche). I’m not sure how you’d defend your premise of Gord Downie being disqualified as a cultural icon for some lack of ubiquity, distinction and/or longevity.

As for his popularity, read the Billboard article for yourself: http://www.billboard.com/articles/columns/chart-beat/8005871/the-tragically-hip-by-the-numbers-remembering-frontman-gord

Is he “the most popular musician”? I don’t know (because that’s a bizarre statement), but I imagine if someone told you that, they were wrong.
 
I’m still absolutely perplexed, assuming you don’t live and work exclusively in a cave network without radio for the past 20+ years how you could have missed Gord Downie or the Tragically Hip. No, I can’t name all musicians in all genres of music. But I know why Gord Downie was an important guy. Just like I knew why Glen Gould, Leonard Cohen Oscar Peterson or even Stompin’ Tom was an important guy. What do they have in common, other than being musicians and Canadian? They’re cultural icons.

Again, I’ll ask, who are the true Canadian icons if Gord isn’t one?

Remember, iconic status isn’t bestowed by a subculture (or niche). I’m not sure how you’d defend your premise against Gord Downie being disqualified as a cultural icon for some lack of ubiquity, distinction and/or longevity.

As for his popularity, read the Billboard article for yourself: http://www.billboard.com/articles/columns/chart-beat/8005871/the-tragically-hip-by-the-numbers-remembering-frontman-gord

Is he the most popular musician? I don’t know (because that’s a bizarre statement), but I imagine if someone told you that, they were wrong.


I wouldn't even waste your time....lol. Let him think he's not a cultural icon.
 
I’m still absolutely perplexed, assuming you don’t live and work exclusively in a cave network without radio for the past 20+ years how you could have missed Gord Downie or the Tragically Hip. No, I can’t name all musicians in all genres of music. But I know why Gord Downie was an important guy. Just like I knew why Glen Gould, Leonard Cohen Oscar Peterson or even Stompin’ Tom was an important guy. What do they have in common, other than being musicians and Canadian? They’re cultural icons.

Again, I’ll ask, who are the true Canadian icons if Gord isn’t one?

Remember, iconic status isn’t bestowed by a subculture (or niche). I’m not sure how you’d defend your premise of Gord Downie being disqualified as a cultural icon for some lack of ubiquity, distinction and/or longevity.

As for his popularity, read the Billboard article for yourself: http://www.billboard.com/articles/columns/chart-beat/8005871/the-tragically-hip-by-the-numbers-remembering-frontman-gord

Is he “the most popular musician”? I don’t know (because that’s a bizarre statement), but I imagine if someone told you that, they were wrong.

have four radios, plus an extensive music collection. But I listen to those, that I prefer to hear. Downie never made that list, or will. So when did Downie, ever win a music award, or even make the news, prior to the last year and half. Others you have mentioned in this thread have, and would be recognized, by more people, then Downie. Even if you do not listen to their music. They also sell more music then Downie ever did. Thee most popular musician was stated in this thread.

Considering that Toronto has 46.1 % of people living here, that were not born in this country. Do you really think the Downie's music would be recognized, as their Cultural Icon. We are a diverse city, and country. One genre of music does not fit all peoples idea of an Icon. If you take all of Canada, the it becomes one fifth of the total population, not born in this country. A good number of these would have their own music, that you will never find on a chart.
Add in those that prefer opera, classical, country, Latin, and so forth. Then Downie, becomes even more diminished as anyone's cultural or music Icon.

If you want a cultural icon, find someone who has been doing good for the majority of their life. Not just in the last 18 months, and most recognizable item is a story, called the Secret Path. An issue, that it was also in the courts, and news, when released. If this had been released even a few years ago, it would not have had, the same impact. Just like in music, timing is everything.

If you look at the history of those you mentioned above. They have far more accomplishments, and recognitions then Downie,. Yet the same fuss was not made over them. Why not ? His fans can mourn his passing, and should.

Musicians if they make the grade, have the fan base, and survive as a performer over the years, would end up as musical legends. Rather then Cultural Icons. Will the Hip make it there, only time will tell. The truth is very few ever do. They just fade away, and are replaced by another.
 
have four radios, plus an extensive music collection. But I listen to those, that I prefer to hear. Downie never made that list, or will. So when did Downie, ever win a music award, or even make the news, prior to the last year and half. Others you have mentioned in this thread have, and would be recognized, by more people, then Downie. Even if you do not listen to their music. They also sell more music then Downie ever did. Thee most popular musician was stated in this thread.

Considering that Toronto has 46.1 % of people living here, that were not born in this country. Do you really think the Downie's music would be recognized, as their Cultural Icon. We are a diverse city, and country. One genre of music does not fit all peoples idea of an Icon. If you take all of Canada, the it becomes one fifth of the total population, not born in this country. A good number of these would have their own music, that you will never find on a chart.
Add in those that prefer opera, classical, country, Latin, and so forth. Then Downie, becomes even more diminished as anyone's cultural or music Icon.

If you want a cultural icon, find someone who has been doing good for the majority of their life. Not just in the last 18 months, and most recognizable item is a story, called the Secret Path. An issue, that it was also in the courts, and news, when released. If this had been released even a few years ago, it would not have had, the same impact. Just like in music, timing is everything.

If you look at the history of those you mentioned above. They have far more accomplishments, and recognitions then Downie,. Yet the same fuss was not made over them. Why not ? His fans can mourn his passing, and should.

Musicians if they make the grade, have the fan base, and survive as a performer over the years, would end up as musical legends. Rather then Cultural Icons. Will the Hip make it there, only time will tell. The truth is very few ever do. They just fade away, and are replaced by another.

I'm now convinced you're trolling and I won't feed the troll.
 
Weather you cannot see it, is irrelevant. He is a Canadian cultural icon, there is no debate about this. 12 millions Canadians watched the final concert (about 1/3 of our population) and that's not including the millions more that may have wanted to watch but had other plans or just busy. It's not just his popularity that made him a Canadian icon, it was how exemplified Canada and what it is to be Canadian. That's the point your totally missing.

If the House of Commons pays tribute to Gord Downie, then he truly is a Canadian icon.

RIP

 
So when did Downie, ever win a music award, or even make the news, prior to the last year and half.

Seriously? Either you haven't bothered to do the slightest bit of research or you're simply trolling. I'm betting on the latter.

SOCAN Awards: 1997: National Achievement Award

Canada's Walk of Fame: 2002: Inducted in Toronto, Ontario

Canadian Music Hall of Fame: 2005: Inducted at the Juno Awards in Winnipeg, Manitoba

Royal Conservatory of Music: 2006: Presented with an honorary fellowship May 24 at the Windsor Arms Hotel in Toronto, Ontario

Governor General's Performing Arts Awards: 2008: Presented the National Arts Centre Award in Ottawa, Ontario

Juno Awards

1990: Most Promising Group of the Year
1991: Canadian Entertainer of the Year
1993: Canadian Entertainer of the Year
1995: Entertainer of the Year
1995: Group of the Year
1997: Group of the Year
1997: Album of the Year (Trouble at the Henhouse),
1997: North Star Rock Album of the Year (Trouble at the Henhouse)
1999: Best Rock Album (Phantom Power)
1999: Best Album Design (Phantom Power)
2000: Best Single ("Bobcaygeon")
2001: Best Rock Album (Music at Work)
2006: CD/DVD Artwork Design of the Year (Hipeponymous)
2006: Music DVD of the Year (Hipeponymous)
2017: Rock Album of the Year (Man Machine Poem)
2017: Group of the Year

Order of Canada: 2017: Appointed to the Order of Canada
 
Seriously? Either you haven't bothered to do the slightest bit of research or you're simply trolling. I'm betting on the latter.

SOCAN Awards: 1997: National Achievement Award

Canada's Walk of Fame: 2002: Inducted in Toronto, Ontario

Canadian Music Hall of Fame: 2005: Inducted at the Juno Awards in Winnipeg, Manitoba

Royal Conservatory of Music: 2006: Presented with an honorary fellowship May 24 at the Windsor Arms Hotel in Toronto, Ontario

Governor General's Performing Arts Awards: 2008: Presented the National Arts Centre Award in Ottawa, Ontario

Juno Awards

1990: Most Promising Group of the Year
1991: Canadian Entertainer of the Year
1993: Canadian Entertainer of the Year
1995: Entertainer of the Year
1995: Group of the Year
1997: Group of the Year
1997: Album of the Year (Trouble at the Henhouse),
1997: North Star Rock Album of the Year (Trouble at the Henhouse)
1999: Best Rock Album (Phantom Power)
1999: Best Album Design (Phantom Power)
2000: Best Single ("Bobcaygeon")
2001: Best Rock Album (Music at Work)
2006: CD/DVD Artwork Design of the Year (Hipeponymous)
2006: Music DVD of the Year (Hipeponymous)
2017: Rock Album of the Year (Man Machine Poem)
2017: Group of the Year

Order of Canada: 2017: Appointed to the Order of Canada

Dude, he's clueless...lol. It's a winless battle...lol.
 
What some of you are clueless about is, a lot of Canadians do not know who Downie was, or for that matter actually care about the whole issue. Not every one will have the same opinion, that he is such an Icon. So grow up and face the simple fact, not everyone will agree with you.

Continue on with your delusion, that all of Canada is with you.
 
What some of you are clueless about is, a lot of Canadians do not know who Downie was, or for that matter actually care about the whole issue. Not every one will have the same opinion, that he is such an Icon. So grow up and face the simple fact, not everyone will agree with you.

Continue on with your delusion, that all of Canada is with you.

Same could be said for any Canadian artist. You're going to have to try harder than that.

You asked "So when did Downie, ever win a music award, or even make the news, prior to the last year and half." I provided a complete list and that's that's your response? That's the best you can come up with? Not every single person in Canada is a Gord Downie fan?

We already know you're a troll. You don't have to keep proving it.
 
Same could be said for any Canadian artist. You're going to have to try harder than that.

You asked "So when did Downie, ever win a music award, or even make the news, prior to the last year and half." I provided a complete list and that's that's your response? That's the best you can come up with? Not every single person in Canada is a Gord Downie fan?

We already know you're a troll. You don't have to keep proving it.

I just stopped answering the delusional Trolls.
 
What some of you are clueless about is, a lot of Canadians do not know who Downie was, or for that matter actually care about the whole issue. Not every one will have the same opinion, that he is such an Icon. So grow up and face the simple fact, not everyone will agree with you.

Continue on with your delusion, that all of Canada is with you.

Nobody, as far as I can tell, has said that everyone in the country loves Gord Downie. It’s been said multiple times in this thread that The Hip didn't really break into the francophone-market for one. I would have thought most of us know someone who hates The Hip for whatever reasons. I’d have to think that there are large groups of Canadians, mostly related by age demographics, who haven’t heard of them. If you were listening to contemporary rock or pop in English Canada between 1988 and 2000ish, you would have been exposed to The Hip.

Everybody in the country didn’t love P.E. Trudeau and that didn’t stop history from remembering him as an iconic person. If I say I’ve never heard of Neil Young, or that lots of people haven’t heard of Neil Young, that doesn’t mean he’s not a Canadian icon. There are many Canadian music icons that I’m not a fan of, but that doesn’t mean they aren’t icons.

Please, just do some casual searches for “cultural icon” to find out what it actually is. I feel you’ll likely find it’s considerably different than how you seem to have internalized its meaning.

They (sic.) either are or are not a cultural icon. There’s no “he’s not a cultural icon to me” option. It seems like this thread has proven he is, can you prove your argument at all without relying on vagaries like “a lot of Canadians” and “not everyone.” Iconic status isn’t a matter of opinion. Simple fact.

I’ll ask again and again... who are the (deceased) Canadian musical icons that so clearly in your mind eclipse Gord?
 
What some of you are clueless about is, a lot of Canadians do not know who Downie was, or for that matter actually care about the whole issue. Not every one will have the same opinion, that he is such an Icon. So grow up and face the simple fact, not everyone will agree with you.

Continue on with your delusion, that all of Canada is with you.



Do you buy chance know who Terry Fox is?