RIP Gord Downie

Inevitability of Death

Terry's gift is forever green, it got me up and back on the scene

We don't go to hell, just our memories do

Fantastic gap, common space

Open concept in your smiling face

We don't go to hell, memories of us do

And if you go to hell, I'll still remember you

-Day for Night (1994)

Whether falling off the stage or not, he never disappointed me. Coke Machine Glow tour included.

I hope we all played some loud ones for him this week.

Remember Gord Downie, and remember that he wanted us to remember Chanie Wenjack.
 
Definitely an Canadian icon and arguably/likely the most beloved Canadian musician(by Canadians only, though) ever. I'm devastated, and have been over the last year. The New York Times captured his impact perfectly: "The place of honor that Mr. Downie occupies in Canada’s national imagination has no parallel in the United States. Imagine Bruce Springsteen, Bob Dylan and Michael Stipe combined into one sensitive, oblique poet-philosopher, and you’re getting close."
 
Did anyone catch Long Time Running last night? I saw a bit of it. Gord showed a lot of courage after going through his surgery, chemo and radiation treatments. We lost a great human being and true Canadian icon. RIP.

 
Some mentioned the PM and I have to say, I saw Justin speak about Gord’s death and I can’t say I ever recall seeing a person in power like him, give a statement in tears.

To me, that speaks volumes to both men.
 
Looking at his history, posted elsewhere, I still cannot see where he would be considered an "Icon". To his fans, he probably is. To others, I expect he is just someone, who got mentioned in the news, since that tour was announced. I also think, our selfie PM, who was a fan, had something to do with his elevated status.

Weather you cannot see it, is irrelevant. He is a Canadian cultural icon, there is no debate about this. 12 millions Canadians watched the final concert (about 1/3 of our population) and that's not including the millions more that may have wanted to watch but had other plans or just busy. It's not just his popularity that made him a Canadian icon, it was how exemplified Canada and what it is to be Canadian. That's the point your totally missing.
 
Weather you cannot see it, is irrelevant. He is a Canadian cultural icon, there is no debate about this. 12 millions Canadians watched the final concert (about 1/3 of our population) and that's not including the millions more that may have wanted to watch but had other plans or just busy. It's not just his popularity that made him a Canadian icon, it was how exemplified Canada and what it is to be Canadian. That's the point your totally missing.

Lets see 24 million did not tune in, for such a great cultural icon. Of that 12 million you said did, how many just to find out what the fuss was all about. I did, and I expect others did, since Canadians also like to know what is happening, and why. Does not even mean those 12 million watched the whole show, or signed on for your reason. His fans can believe what they like, about him. Others just do not have to go along with their fanatic belief. This is Canada, and we are allowed to choose, what we think. I have asked that question of others I meet. Did you ever hear of this guy, before the tour ? I have only met one that had so far. Did all that money, from the ticket sales for his tour, get given to the indigenous population ? Or did he keep it ? We have a lot of Canadian people who could be considered cultural icons. The only point missing, is that others, do not have to believe, what you do, about him.
 
I have asked that question of others I meet. Did you ever hear of this guy, before the tour ? I have only met one that had so far.

I guess it depends on who you're hanging out with. I doubt that in my 100 closest acquaintances I could find even 1 who didn't know of Gord prior to his cancer announcement and farewell tour. But sure, feel free to pick and choose your own cultural icons...nobody's stopping you.
 
I guess it depends on who you're hanging out with. I doubt that in my 100 closest acquaintances I could find even 1 who didn't know of Gord prior to his cancer announcement and farewell tour. But sure, feel free to pick and choose your own cultural icons...nobody's stopping you.


Haha! I'm not going to try and convince this dude that one of our nations most popular musicians of all time isn't a Canadian icon..lol.
 
I guess it depends on who you're hanging out with. I doubt that in my 100 closest acquaintances I could find even 1 who didn't know of Gord prior to his cancer announcement and farewell tour. But sure, feel free to pick and choose your own cultural icons...nobody's stopping you.

Then I hope you and your "100" closest acquaintances, attended the Richmond Hill fund raiser, Sunday night, and made deep pocket donations, in the name of your icon. And stayed for the indigenous ceremony, on the 51th year, of the death of Chanie Wenjack. If not, then you are not honouring, your own particular icon.
 
Haha! I'm not going to try and convince this dude that one of our nations most popular musicians of all time isn't a Canadian icon..lol.

He played to a particular niche in music. But not the most popular ones, that are around. He had his own fan base, as other musicians have. He did not even get a mention in the top list of Canadian musicians.
 
Then I hope you and your "100" closest acquaintances, attended the Richmond Hill fund raiser, Sunday night, and made deep pocket donations, in the name of your icon. And stayed for the indigenous ceremony, on the 51th year, of the death of Chanie Wenjack. If not, then you are not honouring, your own particular icon.

Dude, what are you smoking?

He played to a particular niche in music. But not the most popular ones, that are around. He had his own fan base, as other musicians have. He did not even get a mention in the top list of Canadian musicians.

Well, if you're simply talking about popularity, then you have a point. Drake and Bieber are more popular, but that's not saying much.

This list has The Hip at #7 of 200. That's certainly up there with some of the greats.

https://rateyourmusic.com/list/noname219/top_200_canadian_artists/
 
Does it exhibit your
Supercapacity to love

Gord wrote and sang beautiful songs.
And no he doesnt need our Selfie PM to elevate his status. The man's talent is more than adequate to achieve that feat. May he find eternal peace.
 
I never even heard of this person, till the final tour was being promoted, and the reason for it. Looking at his history, posted elsewhere, I still cannot see where he would be considered an "Icon". To his fans, he probably is. To others, I expect he is just someone, who got mentioned in the news, since that tour was announced. I went to you tube, to hear what he played, after his death. Not my type of music. I also think, our selfie PM, who was a fan, had something to do with his elevated status. He did do a few good things, but then so do many others, without the same recognition. Canadians care about others. He was just one, of many who do something to make it better.

To those who liked him, my condolences. No one should die early.

Out of curiosity, are you very young, Québécois or new to Canada?

I find it a bit surprising that any music-loving Anglo-Canadian adult under 65ish had never heard of Gord Downie before he went public with his diagnosis and the media outlets started to punch this up. What music do you listen to now, or what radio stations did you listen to growing up?

From Billboard: “The Hip has scored seven No. 1s on Billboard's Canadian Albums chart, the third-most among all acts and a record among groups in the chart's 21-year history. In total, the band sports 17 entries, the most by a group.”

For comparative sakes, is there a Canadian musical icon you can point to as someone who actually meets your standard for “icon” status? How about music icons in general?

A subculture, like Hip fans, aren't ordinarily who ‘gets’ to bestow icon-status on someone/something. It seems to me that his ubiquity, disctinction and longevity would have made him a living icon, and in his death that status seems indisputable.
 
Lets see 24 million did not tune in, for such a great cultural icon. Of that 12 million you said did, how many just to find out what the fuss was all about. I did, and I expect others did, since Canadians also like to know what is happening, and why. Does not even mean those 12 million watched the whole show, or signed on for your reason. His fans can believe what they like, about him. Others just do not have to go along with their fanatic belief. This is Canada, and we are allowed to choose, what we think. I have asked that question of others I meet. Did you ever hear of this guy, before the tour ? I have only met one that had so far. Did all that money, from the ticket sales for his tour, get given to the indigenous population ? Or did he keep it ? We have a lot of Canadian people who could be considered cultural icons. The only point missing, is that others, do not have to believe, what you do, about him.

I don’t think you understand what a (pop/cultural) icon is.

Celine Dion and Shania Twain are Canadian musical icons. It would seem that Justin Bieber and Michael Buble have had the longevity to earn this status as-well. My personal tastes with regard to any of their music doesn’t make them any less iconic.

Biggie Smalls, Tupac, Janis Joplin, Kurt Cobain, Amy Winehouse, Jimi Hendrix and Sid Vicious (et al) weren't exactly Bono in-terms of philanthropy, yet they achieved status as cultural icons. We didn’t somehow ‘strip’ status from James Brown or Michael Jackson when it became pretty evident that they were not-so great people.

As for why he didn’t donate proceeds from the last tour, I’m not sure if that’s correct or incorrect. Gord was 20% of the Hip. His bandmates aren’t exactly hurting, but knowing it was the last real Hip tour ever would make me want to be careful with those $$$. Gord had a(n almost ex-)wife and 4 kids in private school. He was NOT expecting to stop touring or making music any time soon, at-least that’s what he said to a friend of mine when they were on vacation together over the years. Financially, I’m told he wasn’t prepared for this. His kids won’t be going to public school any time soon, but they’ll probably use that schooling for the jobs they’ll inevitably need.

Gord had business class/rental vacation home money, not private jet/private island money.

Regardless, I believe proceeds from The Secret Path went to his Wenjack fund. I’m a big fan of the cause, and can’t recall a musician, including Tribe Called Red, who did more for indigenous reconciliation in Canada, even though he seemed to only get involved in 2011 or 2012. I met Gord for the first time when I was involved with Waterkeeper Lake Ontario in the early 2000s so I can say for sure that he’s not exactly a stranger to doing the right thing.

Could he have done more? Probably. Who, including myself, can honestly say it’s impossible to have done more?
 
Then I hope you and your "100" closest acquaintances, attended the Richmond Hill fund raiser, Sunday night, and made deep pocket donations, in the name of your icon. And stayed for the indigenous ceremony, on the 51th year, of the death of Chanie Wenjack. If not, then you are not honouring, your own particular icon.

Didn’t you say you only heard of Gord Downie when his cancer was announced?

What makes you think you can possibly understand how this man would want, let alone expect to be honoured? I’ve been going to shows, buying albums and reading his poetry since the late-80s, and I’m still not exactly sure.

If you think that donating to a cause in memory of a particular person is the only way to honour someone in the wake of death, I feel you’re a bit naive.

It’s A way to honour Gord’s legacy, not THE way.
 
He played to a particular niche in music. But not the most popular ones, that are around. He had his own fan base, as other musicians have. He did not even get a mention in the top list of Canadian musicians.

I should have started reading here. Clearly, you’re just trolling.

From Billboard.com: “The Hip has scored seven No. 1s on Billboard's Canadian Albums chart, the third-most among all acts and a record among groups in the chart's 21-year history. In total, the band sports 17 entries, the most by a group.”

Do you mean English Canada / Anglo-Canadians as a niche market? As-in a niche market by US-industry standards?

Which “list” would you be referring to? I imagine you’re right for at-least one list.

Maybe your cave doesn’t get a strong enough FM signal.

Also, https://www.grammarly.com/blog/comma/
 
Don't even waste your time. Canman1 from the "Toronto Escort Review Board" says he's not a Canadian icon, there for, he's not...lol. Despite every News media outlet in the county, every radio station paying tribute to him, NHL teams and so on, Canman1 doesn't know who he is so he's not a Canadian icon...lol.
 
Last edited:
Dude, what are you smoking?



Well, if you're simply talking about popularity, then you have a point. Drake and Bieber are more popular, but that's not saying much.

This list has The Hip at #7 of 200. That's certainly up there with some of the greats.

https://rateyourmusic.com/list/noname219/top_200_canadian_artists/

I will take that answer as you did not even know about the fund raiser. The Secret path which this fund raiser was about, was Gord's only real acknowledgement. Chanie Wenjack was the child in the story.
 
Out of curiosity, are you very young, Québécois or new to Canada?

I find it a bit surprising that any music-loving Anglo-Canadian adult under 65ish had never heard of Gord Downie before he went public with his diagnosis and the media outlets started to punch this up. What music do you listen to now, or what radio stations did you listen to growing up?

From Billboard: “The Hip has scored seven No. 1s on Billboard's Canadian Albums chart, the third-most among all acts and a record among groups in the chart's 21-year history. In total, the band sports 17 entries, the most by a group.”

For comparative sakes, is there a Canadian musical icon you can point to as someone who actually meets your standard for “icon” status? How about music icons in general?

A subculture, like Hip fans, aren't ordinarily who ‘gets’ to bestow icon-status on someone/something. It seems to me that his ubiquity, disctinction and longevity would have made him a living icon, and in his death that status seems indisputable.

8th generation Anglo Saxon Canadian, and under 65.
Could you name all musicians in every field of music. I doubt it, even more so if you, listen to another type as your preference.
Billboard is an American company. Who gets to the top of it, depends on your timing of the release of the music. But if you want to use that, who are the Canadians listed on the yearly 100. The Hip is not one of them.
You should have read a little closer. My objection was Cultural Icon, or the most popular musician.