I didn’t realize he wasn’t in the HHOF, with his history of success I thought it would have been a no brainer! 4 cups, a conn Smyth! I guess his reputation as a shit disturber was against him! I read this was a contributor to his mental health and the torch bearer thing brought it back to the forefront
He did make the Hall of Fame for 2 main reasons around his regular season play which drives much of your ultimate resume:
1. His counting stats are not Hall of Fame Caliber 379 Goals. 786 points, in 1215 Career Games
2. In terms of regular season his honours are not existent - no all star games, never close to winning any award.
His rep didn't help him, but I don't think it hurt him.
I guess they didn't see his clutch play and his playoff success as being enough to put him over the top.
His style of play also led him to play for two Canada teams in Best on Best Hockey (1987 and 1996 Canada Cup)
I think he is right on the borderline.