Review - Nikon D200

xarir

Retired TERB Ass Slapper
Aug 20, 2001
3,763
1
36
Trolling the Deleted Threads Repository
At the risk of being called a Shill, here's a short review of a different kind.

Last December I purchased a new Nikon D200 camera. I toook a risk and bought it sight unseen - I placed my deposit before the camera was released and waited a few weeks for it to be delivered. Short story - I'm glad I did.

I've been shooting film for quite a while. I grew up using a Nikormat mostly with a 50mm f2.0 lens but I also loved using a 135mm on occasion. Eventually I got an N401 which was a decent camera but one that had a lot of limitations. The F100 was next. What a joy it was to use that camera! But it was still film and I wanted to move to digital, thus the D200.

Nikon claims that the standard battery that comes with the D200 yields up to 1800 shots. I suppose this is possible, but my real world shooting got me only 700 shots with limited use of both flash and LCD. I would strongly recommend spending the extra $80 for another battery which you can carry around with you. The external battery pack might be a nice to have, but IMHO it would make the body too heavy.

Sans lens a D200 isn't too bad in the weight category. But this is not a point & shoot camera so you can't expect it to be a lightweight. If weight is a consideration, stick with a D50 or D70. The D200 is a real camera made for heavy duty use. Accordingly it's built to take some abuse. I wouldn't drop my camera or anything, but I'm sure it could take a few bangs without being adversely affected.

I got the new 18 - 200mm lens. In 35mm equivalent that's approximately 27 - 300mm! It's very much a one lens for all situations kind of thing here. Though it's only f3.5, one of the beauties of digital is that it lets you take shots at much lower light levels than with film, even if you load high ISO. Shots that I would hesitate taking with an f1.4 lens on ISO 800 film come out quite nicely on the D200.

The controls of the D200 are logically laid out and it's easy to reset settings between shots without missing a beat. It's pretty easy to shoot this camera using only one hand, which is handy in certain situations.

But I guess the one thing I really love about this camera is being free of film. I can shoot to my heart's content and not have to worry about the cost of processing afterwards. With the F100 I never used it to it's full capacity because I was always concerned about burning through too much film. On a D200 I can just go on a shooting spree then delete unwanted shots afterward. I can bracket my shots, I can shoot continuous high mode (5.3 frames per second!), I can take those experimental shots all without any concern. It's fantastic!

In terms of memory, I use the cheapest 2GB compact flash card that I could find. It works very well - there's no reason IMHO to use the much more expensive Ultra III cards. The buffer in the camera holds enough for normal shooting that delays in writing the card go by unnoticed. I was able to shoot continuous high (5.3 fps) for 2 - 3 seconds and I had no troubles with writing to my el cheapo card. For the most part I was shooting at a resolution of 2896 x 1944 pixels with normal (1:8) compression. This gave me roughly 750 shots per 2 GB card. Max resolution BTW is 3872 x 2592.

Peeves - the standard settings on the D200 are for softer shots. In my early test shots I was disappointed with the output because they lacked that Nikon crispness I was accustomed to with the other bodies. A quick change on one of the menu settings fixed that though. The other thing is that the standard program mode seems to have trouble getting the colour of the sky right. I've found that switching from centre-weighted exposure to matrix, while also pushing to colour saturation deals with this pretty well. The trouble here though is that resetting colour saturation requires delving into the menu structure which could mean missed shots. I'll have to see if I can program this into a function button - maybe that will fix things up.

The peeves are relatively small though. This is a great camera and with some practice relative to the settings, it can and will give you fantastic shots. I actually find no visible difference between a fine jpeg and RAW format - this camera is that good.

This is not the camera to end all cameras - Nikon and Canon both have bodies out that are technically superior to the D200. But I know that this is the last camera I'll be buying for a while.
 
Interesting review. Not sure how many TERBites will appreciate it. I now use a Nikon D70s with a Sigma 18-125. If the D200 had been out, I would have bought it but the D70 works just fine.

Many of the older shots on my web page were taken with a Canon G2. Unlike the SLRs it had a shutter delay that one had to live with and learn to use.

My web page addy can be seen in my profile. The mods might get upset if I posted it here.

Anyway, Xarir, nice to see a man in love with a camera. :))
 
Last edited:
I had the opportunity to rent the D200 for this weekend. It is a fantastic camera.

I hear that the D2Hs and the D2xs are now available. Are these comera bodies worth the money?
 
Thanks for the interesting and informative review xarir. I'm glad you found the camera that you feel comfortable with.

I'm a D70 shooter and going to digital was the best thing I've ever done for my photography.

Cheers
QB7
 
lots of Nikon shooters here. I myself use two Canon 30D as my secondary (and tertiary) body and 5D as my primary. I personally like the high ISO performance (in terms of less digital grain) on the Canon better than Nikon.

OTOH, I wish Canon will release a 18-200 IS soon.
 
Another Nikon fan here.

Using the D70 with both the 18-70mm and 70-300mm lenses. .5gig and 2gig memory cards. Spare battery pack.

Easy to use. Great results. Even the firmware upgrade that was available was easily done.

Moving to digital took some doing. For the first while, I found myself waiting for the 'right' shot (to save film!) After a few outings though it's 'Mr. Happy Shutter.' Weed out the bad shots later. Amazing how many shots were salvageable, though, with a little crop here/lighting enhancement there. Photoshop is our friend.

Only downside is - I'm a hoarder. I'm going to need a bigger HD soon.

Note: Nikon has a battery recall on some of their EN-EL3 batteries. See http://nikon.ca for details.
 
clules said:
I had the opportunity to rent the D200 for this weekend. It is a fantastic camera.

I hear that the D2Hs and the D2xs are now available. Are these comera bodies worth the money?

I have to say that as much as I like Nikon, at the upper end I think Canon has an edge. The new 5D with its full-frame sensor is particularly intriguing. I also think that Canon is starting to make some better lenses than Nikon, though Nikon arguably makes more versatile zoom lenses for everyday use.

Having said that, if you want the best that money can buy I doubt you'd go wrong with a D2 series body. It does depend though on what you shoot. For me, the difference in price for a D2 series vs D200 is not justified, but I'm not a pro photographer either.
 
Digital SLRs.......

Actually, I was most interested in seeing a camera revue here in the lounge. It would appear there are some serious shooters out there in Terbland.

I use a Canon 1Ds (SLR) and the Canon 10d (SLR) as a backup. Given the relative freedom from distortion and compatibility with a wider range of lenses, I agree with a previous writer that the full-frame sensor is the way to go. I suspect all Canon SLRs will be full-frame in the not to distant future because the cost of these light-sensitive chips is coming down.

The original poster might consider posting his review on a very informative site I found which is dedicated to camera revues which is read by a wider audience interested specifically in photography. It is:

http://www.photographyreview.com/reviewscrx.aspx
 
I love the 200d and moved from Olympus E-1s last year....... I bought a d50 while in NYC last summer because my bag got stolen and it was the first camera i came across that had accessories and such in stock. After using the cheaper version of the d70s...... a few things auto set up, i was quite happy.
When the d200 was announced a buddy of mine got me a pre-production model to use over a weekend.....i was hooked. It is almost a pro camera but not quite like the D2 series. But for the price.... i just recently bought the 12-24 Nikon lens and Lens and Lens Baby..... WOW .... very fun stuff.
Great review.