rental car details

whitewaterguy

Well-known member
Aug 30, 2005
3,258
180
83
so i dont have a need to rent a car often but am wondering what the deal is with the added insurance they try to upsell to you at the counter. it seems that it adds about 15-25 bux per day to the price of the vehicle. is this necessary/worthwhile/or a waste of cash. would my own insurance policy not cover me or say if i rented the car with my Amex platinum, or mastercard suffice? thanks for the help

i am basically going to be renting at edmonton airport then tooling off to jasper to ski marmot basin for a week.
 
Look into gold card coverage. Even no-fee gold cards offer coverage that probably will eliminate the insurance upsell.
 
We have a Gov. insurance deal in MB but check with your regular insurer, I can usually get a weeks coverage for about the same cost as the rental company charges for a day.
 
Option A is to use your credit card IF it provides auto insurance coverage. CHECK YOUR POLICY first. If you're covered, you need to check "decline" on the insurance form. If you damage the vehicle, your CC is charged (so the rental company has its money immediately) and then your CC company removes the charges from your CC account, once all the paperwork has been processed. MAKE SURE you read the fine print so that you do all the paperwork required by your CC company - this might include a police report, special forms from the rental company, and a special form from the CC company, maybe more. Also note that, while the investigations and paperwork are being processed, the charges sit on your CC account - could be for the full price of the car. If all goes well, you're covered, but you need to jump through the right hoops to ensure you don't wind up buying the rental agency a new car.

Option B is to pay the extra insurance. This is a good option if you are super risk averse and don't want to risk your CC company screwing you over. Do the math on buying the rental company's insurance. For a week you're probably looking at around $100 extra (if you book online and take all the right options) to $300 if you get burned for full rate, for insurance coverage that basically allows you to drive the car off a cliff and walk away with no hassle.
 
remember that car insurance consists of collision coverage but also liability. i'm fairly sure most credit card car insurance coverage only includes collision.
 
There are several options already mentioned:

Book through a credit card with insurance coverage (damages only usually). AMEX is the best, especially if a corporate card

Add the insurance to the rental agreement

Add insurance to your contract (ie like travel insurance)

It may be covered under your existing auto insurance (it is for me)

Don't buy any extra and take the risk - how often do you actually have an accident anyway?

NOTE: The real problem is if there is an accident and there is a combination of the above already present - say booked under a CC card and your existing auto coverage alreadsy covers it - which takes precedence and pays and for what!