Is there a line between them?
I know a fair bit about mental health, and they are actually quite different. Schizophrenics are largely psychotic and use primitive defence mechanisms such as splitting and projection and they lack object constancy. They do this because they are exceptionally confused and terrified of their environment. They have equal ignorance and terror of themselves and their actions. Under times of stress, they truly believe that their computer can swallow them whole, or worse, they feel they can swallow their computer whole and they cannot own that aggression within them. That is to say, things for them are strongly either black or white - hence the name schizophrenia, meaning "a split mind".
Religious fanatics, however, are keenly in touch with their environment, and to a lesser extent they are in touch with themselves. However, it is important to qualify "in touch with themselves". There are really two parts to a religious fanatic - a very empty and scared "self" and a second part that consists of all of these learned beliefs about religion and about others. These learned beliefs are "undigested" in that they are not properly thought-through before they become part of one's personality. Instead, one recognizes that their personality is "lacking" in one area and takes in the religious belief to easily compensate for that lack - if one lacks a belief, it is easier to ingest one than it is to form it on one's own. They swallow the idea whole without recognizing the full implication of what they have done. By the time they do, it is too late - the shame and disgust they would feel about making such a horrible mistake is too much to bear for them, so they continue on a fanatical path in order to justify their original belief and to avoid awful shame, including exile from other fanatics around them.
Where schizophrenics and religious fanatics may share something in common is their black-and-white view of the outside world, but I hope that you can see the psychopathology is completely different. In schizophrenics, they do not know any better than to view the world as black and white. The guilt and shame is so inaccessible that we can say it doesn't exist, at least when one is acting in a schizophrenic way (note I do not imply that they have NO guilt or shame in their daily lives, they do, but they have exceptional difficulty understanding or owning it and why they act that way). In religious fanatics, they do know that they can view the world in shades of grey, they are just too ashamed to do so.
I know a fair bit about mental health, and they are actually quite different. Schizophrenics are largely psychotic and use primitive defence mechanisms such as splitting and projection and they lack object constancy. They do this because they are exceptionally confused and terrified of their environment. They have equal ignorance and terror of themselves and their actions. Under times of stress, they truly believe that their computer can swallow them whole, or worse, they feel they can swallow their computer whole and they cannot own that aggression within them. That is to say, things for them are strongly either black or white - hence the name schizophrenia, meaning "a split mind".
Religious fanatics, however, are keenly in touch with their environment, and to a lesser extent they are in touch with themselves. However, it is important to qualify "in touch with themselves". There are really two parts to a religious fanatic - a very empty and scared "self" and a second part that consists of all of these learned beliefs about religion and about others. These learned beliefs are "undigested" in that they are not properly thought-through before they become part of one's personality. Instead, one recognizes that their personality is "lacking" in one area and takes in the religious belief to easily compensate for that lack - if one lacks a belief, it is easier to ingest one than it is to form it on one's own. They swallow the idea whole without recognizing the full implication of what they have done. By the time they do, it is too late - the shame and disgust they would feel about making such a horrible mistake is too much to bear for them, so they continue on a fanatical path in order to justify their original belief and to avoid awful shame, including exile from other fanatics around them.
Where schizophrenics and religious fanatics may share something in common is their black-and-white view of the outside world, but I hope that you can see the psychopathology is completely different. In schizophrenics, they do not know any better than to view the world as black and white. The guilt and shame is so inaccessible that we can say it doesn't exist, at least when one is acting in a schizophrenic way (note I do not imply that they have NO guilt or shame in their daily lives, they do, but they have exceptional difficulty understanding or owning it and why they act that way). In religious fanatics, they do know that they can view the world in shades of grey, they are just too ashamed to do so.
Is there a line between them?
I know a fair bit about mental health, and they are actually quite different. Schizophrenics are largely psychotic and use primitive defence mechanisms such as splitting and projection and they lack object constancy. They do this because they are exceptionally confused and terrified of their environment. They have equal ignorance and terror of themselves and their actions. Under times of stress, they truly believe that their computer can swallow them whole, or worse, they feel they can swallow their computer whole and they cannot own that aggression within them. That is to say, things for them are strongly either black or white - hence the name schizophrenia, meaning "a split mind".
Religious fanatics, however, are keenly in touch with their environment, and to a lesser extent they are in touch with themselves. However, it is important to qualify "in touch with themselves". There are really two parts to a religious fanatic - a very empty and scared "self" and a second part that consists of all of these learned beliefs about religion and about others. These learned beliefs are "undigested" in that they are not properly thought-through before they become part of one's personality. Instead, one recognizes that their personality is "lacking" in one area and takes in the religious belief to easily compensate for that lack - if one lacks a belief, it is easier to ingest one than it is to form it on one's own. They swallow the idea whole without recognizing the full implication of what they have done. By the time they do, it is too late - the shame and disgust they would feel about making such a horrible mistake is too much to bear for them, so they continue on a fanatical path in order to justify their original belief and to avoid awful shame, including exile from other fanatics around them.
Where schizophrenics and religious fanatics may share something in common is their black-and-white view of the outside world, but I hope that you can see the psychopathology is completely different. In schizophrenics, they do not know any better than to view the world as black and white. The guilt and shame is so inaccessible that we can say it doesn't exist, at least when one is acting in a schizophrenic way (note I do not imply that they have NO guilt or shame in their daily lives, they do, but they have exceptional difficulty understanding or owning it and why they act that way). In religious fanatics, they do know that they can view the world in shades of grey, they are just too ashamed to do so.
if you talk to god you are a religious fanatic; if he answers you, you are.....a complete schizo.
Actually, the wikipedia article is different, or at least it is from my point of view. The article links schizophrenia with Religious DELUSIONS. You were asking about schizophrenia and Religious FANATICS
In my view fanaticism is a somewhat controlled and conscious decision - or at least there is a decision process that goes along with one becoming a fanatic. Delusions are the prevue of schizophrenics and those who are psychotically organized, and there is little control over them. However, fanatics can certainly have delusions, as can normal people, so they are not mutually exclusive.
But what do you mean by that? Is prayer talking to God, if so there are certainly one Hell of a lot of religious fanatics not just around the world or in North America, but right in Toronto.If you talk to God you are a religious fanatic; if he answers you, you are.....a complete schizo.