Rebreather?

JackBurton

Well-known member
Jan 5, 2012
2,035
897
113
Hey, any scuba divers here have any experience with the new gen of rebreathers? I've been thinking one could really round out my diving in the future, especially if there is something very cool to see that's very deep and I don't want to do any deco stops.

Thoughts? Advice? Warnings?

I only want to hear from real divers, no reposting stuff I can find thru google (cause I've done that, I want some real world input now)
 
Price ~ $3,000-10,000, more technical to use, tricky, and expensive maintenance. Who are you trying to sneak up on? More difficult to use. Which of the four types do you want to get?
 
I know the price range and I'm looking at the Posiden. I like the idea of diving for 3 hrs as deep as I want with no deco times. However I want to split it up - 2 dives for an hour and a half each etc. it would be good for more bottom time on wrecks
 
I know the price range and I'm looking at the Posiden. I like the idea of diving for 3 hrs as deep as I want with no deco times. However I want to split it up - 2 dives for an hour and a half each etc. it would be good for more bottom time on wrecks

If money is not a problem, go for it, but as far as no decompression, that's news to me, but hey, I learned something.
 
It is my understanding that a closed-circuit rebreather allows you to stay longer at depth without decompression and when decompression is required reduces the time necessary. Perhaps that was what you were already saying. Also this doesn't apply at all to semi-closed rebreathers or to oxygen rebreathers.
 
I was hoping with the wealth of knowledge we have on terb, there might be someone who has a unit and they could tell me what they like, don't like, how it fits, what they think of the computer and its algorithm that is COMPLETLY different than regular scuba diving etc.
 
I was hoping with the wealth of knowledge we have on terb, there might be someone who has a unit and they could tell me what they like, don't like, how it fits, what they think of the computer and its algorithm that is COMPLETLY different than regular scuba diving etc.

I guess it's not as popular as you first thought, even among the 'don't care what it cost' big spenders on TERB. That might tell you something.
 
I guess it's not as popular as you first thought, even among the 'don't care what it cost' big spenders on TERB. That might tell you something.


Pretty specialized equipment and profile. Long odds that anyone outside of technical diving circles would be able to offer any substantial insight.

But didn't stop Captain Oblivious to chime in with the results of your 30 seconds of googling.
 
I think the fact that the spokesman for rebreathers with PADI actually just died using one is enough of an answer in itself. My question is what do you want to see that you can't on a single 80?
Do you really want to be constantly below deco levels. If so you might want want to look into something else like getting your tech qualifications.
 
Pretty specialized equipment and profile. Long odds that anyone outside of technical diving circles would be able to offer any substantial insight.

But didn't stop Captain Oblivious to chime in with the results of your 30 seconds of googling.

... and just as expected, SC chimes in, go figure. No googling necessary. Nothing I said was wrong. A cousin has used them professionally and my brother has also dove for years. Sometimes people just know things from actually talking to others and doing stuff. Apparently you don't are to believe that.
 
I think the fact that the spokesman for rebreathers with PADI actually just died using one is enough of an answer in itself. My question is what do you want to see that you can't on a single 80?
Do you really want to be constantly below deco levels. If so you might want want to look into something else like getting your tech qualifications.

Careful, SC might accuse you of googling stuff.
 
... and just as expected, SC chimes in, go figure. No googling necessary. Nothing I said was wrong. A cousin has used them professionally and my brother has also dove for years. Sometimes people just know things from actually talking to others and doing stuff. Apparently you don't are to believe that.

The OP clearly said: "I only want to hear from real divers, no reposting stuff I can find thru google (cause I've done that, I want some real world input now)"


Yet you chime in with exactly what he likely already knows, the price and that it is "more technical" to use! DUH! And you aren't a diver! Knowing one is the same, eh?

I actually AM a veteran technical diver. NAUI certifed Trimix and semi and closed circuit rebreather etc. Yet I have nothing to add to his question as I am not familiar with any "new generation" units
 
The OP clearly said: "I only want to hear from real divers, no reposting stuff I can find thru google (cause I've done that, I want some real world input now)"


Yet you chime in with exactly what he likely already knows, the price and that it is "more technical" to use! DUH! And you aren't a diver! Knowing one is the same, eh?

I actually AM a veteran technical diver. NAUI certifed Trimix and semi and closed circuit rebreather etc. Yet I have nothing to add to his question as I am not familiar with any "new generation" units

Since he did not say what what he already knew, it was not that clear. You really are trying too hard.

Since he didn't specify 'new generation' in his OP, it would be hard to know that was what he was looking for. You only know that because of subsequent post, talk about Captain Hindsight.
 
Since he did not say what what he already knew, it was not that clear. You really are trying too hard.

Since he didn't specify 'new generation' in his OP, it would be hard to know that was what he was looking for. You only know that because of subsequent post, talk about Captain Hindsight.


Uhhhhhmmmm here is the first line from his original post:

"Hey, any scuba divers here have any experience with the new gen of rebreathers? "


You seems to read enough of a post to simply find a way to pipe up and yap off with what you think you know.
 
I dive a Revo... http://www.revo-rebreathers.com/#/en/home/

Most of what is above is wrong, or partially wrong. A rebreather minimizes deco obligations by providing the ideal mix of gas at any given depth.

There are only two real reasons to buy and use a rebreather... You are currently sucking a lot of tri-mix on deep dives and are looking to save money, or you want to eliminate bubbles for photography (my particular application). My unit, with the training was about $10K. With the price of HE going through the roof, payback is shorter than it used to be.

There are a few rec units coming out (like the Poseidon unit mentioned) but these are designed to be relatively idiot-proof so there are MANY limitations and they're more expensive to use. These are not designed for especially deep dives, but more for longer rec dives. Some folks think that these things are way lighter etc and they are, but since they're pretty sketchy, you still need to haul a tank or tanks as bailout. This is typical of all rebreathers.

I can tell by your question that you haven't done much if any tec diving. There are a number of good forums that you can join to get some real information. I will add that nothing will kill you faster than misusing a 'breather. I have personally known four people who have died using them. All were very experienced divers, but not necessarily on the rebreather they were using at the time they died. One of the worlds leading authorities on these units is a very good friend, and a former Mississauga girl, living in Florida.

I can recommend several excellent Instructors if you're interested, but it depends a bit on the unit you are buying.

Checkout:

www.thedecostop.com
http://www.rebreatherworld.com/forums.php