Reasons why you don't need a tablet

Cobster

New member
Apr 29, 2002
10,420
0
0
http://www.cio.com/article/684249/Four_Reasons_Why_You_Don_t_Really_Need_a_Tablet_PC

The hype exceeds the reality.



#2 has a good reason why for me
"But if I had to pick one device to use while on the go, it would still be my smartphone, because it's so much more portable, and in addition to being able to comfortabley place phone calls it does just about everything else that a tablet can do, just with a smaller display."




I still believe they created a "want" rather than a "need" with these devices, in some instances they're great, but for the most part, overly hyped.
 
Planned Obsolesce

4) Tablets (Mostly) Aren't Built to Last

My experience with tablets tells me that they're not particularly durable, and they could break during everyday use. Apple's iPad, the epitome of the modern tablet, is practically a work of art; it's shiny, sleek and stunning, and that's just the hardware. The iPad's software is even better looking.

But the iPad is very fragile.

I can practically feel all of you iPad lovers rolling your eyes right now as you read this, but it's true. Your precious iPad's display will shatter if you drop it on its edge just right, just once. The same can be said about many of the most popular tablets right now; it's not just an iPad thing. Even the BlackBerry PlayBook, certainly one of the more durable tablets on the market right now, has a display that will shatter if dropped a couple of times.

​
 
i'm not an apple fan or anything but you could say that about pretty much 90% of the laptops out there.

If you dropped an open laptop in the right spot it would break as well. Just depends the height, angle and surface that it fell on.

I agree that it might be a little bit more fragile but i really don't think its anything to be concerned about. If you were really that clumsy you are probably better off buying something like a rugged laptop or some huge rubber otter box like skin for your tablet.
 
i'm not an apple fan or anything but you could say that about pretty much 90% of the laptops out there.

If you dropped an open laptop in the right spot it would break as well. Just depends the height, angle and surface that it fell on.

I agree that it might be a little bit more fragile but i really don't think its anything to be concerned about. If you were really that clumsy you are probably better off buying something like a rugged laptop or some huge rubber otter box like skin for your tablet.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Iw78gcU713g

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-CrpUU3cCPE

Love this one
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d7cvi00OZDM&feature=related

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eWUnsj9WVC8&feature=related
 
Interesting source.... my SO was in a meeting recently with many (over 10) of the CIOs at Wells Fargo.... all of them brought an iPad...

That said my SO would agree with this assessment.

OTB
 
Amazing your luck in spotting this bottie.
To date I've only seen 1 iPud in the 'wild'....:eyebrows:
 
Amazing your luck in spotting this bottie.
To date I've only seen 1 iPud in the 'wild'....:eyebrows:

Get out of the basement more often.....

OTB
 
I'll be 110% honest, but i have yet to see ANY tablets in the wild, other than stores.
 
You guys need to get out more... no airports or business meetings for you guys?

OTB
 
IMHO I do see the point about tablets.

The majority of the general public want a "computer" for simple stuff - check emails, surf the net, tweet / social hub, watch videos / listen to music, (maybe) simple office stuff. They don't need any heavy computing stuff, they want an entertainment device. They want portability (small size and light weight) and good battery life.

This is why laptops evolve into netbooks (smaller size, slower processors with great battery life for the size and weight, while still able to do the basic tasks including simple office suite).

The tablet seems to the natural progression - you lose the physical keyboard, you further lose weight and reduce the thickness of the device (or use the same space to pack more battery in to make it run longer). True I prefer a physical keyboard over an onscreen keyboard, but an onscreen KB is "adequate" for the most light tasks. Maybe when voice recognition matures we can completely do without the KB (sad day in human history, one more step down from degeneration of handwriting .....).

This argument about having a physical keyboard or not will always be there - some people cannot accept it, others have absolutely no problem.

Another logical progression from netbook into tablets is the mergence of portable multimedia player with portable computing.

Yes current technology can squeeze all these into a smartphone - but most people would not tolerate staring at a tiny screen (eg. < 4 inch) and fumbling with tiny onscreen leyboard buttons all day long (I got used to it, doesn't mean I like it). True there are smartphones with larger screens, but to me they become "too large" to carry around as a cellphone.

To me, the sweet spot for tablets seems to be around 7 to 8 inch screen - 10 inch tablet is too large to carry around for my preference. If I do I'd rather lug around a 10 inch netbook with a physical KB. Anything smaller (eg. 5 inch or smaller) is just too tiring for the eyes with continuous use.

And you are correct - the market is driven by manufacturers: they advertize and brainwash the customers with the idea of tablets ("something new and trendy and different") so that they can push their products. However, the bottom line is that there is also a lot of sense in the evolution of the tablet format.

I agree you may not see many of these in the wild (I only started taking my Galaxy tab out with me on biz trips), but it doesn't mean people are not buying them - I think most people like to use tablets at home, where you have the convenience of "instant access", just like streaming TV, video and music around your house. This again shows the importance of the multimedia function of this new breed of tablets.
 
What experience with tablets? AFAIK, the only experience you have is looking at them in stores and reading about them here.

I was playing with them at Apple Store and Best Buy, not just looking at them. Played around with many on them and FWIW think they are slow. However this may be due to using my Dell i7 and 3 yr old dual core Toshiba laptop for comparison. That i7 is quite fast and just flies!....:cool:
 
You guys need to get out more... no airports or business meetings for you guys?

OTB

Guess not everyone is such a big shot like you bottie!....:rolleyes:
 
Reason #10

Because I don't have one, it's easier for me to come up with reasons why no one else should have one than admit I can't afford one.
 
what a dumb article. i see the need for a smart-phone, a tablet, a netbook a notebook and for those who do heavy lifting, a desktop. so the tablet doesn't do flash! nothing new. use your netbook. it also doesn't fit in my pocket. so what? take your smart-phone. horses for courses.
 
Reason #10

Because I don't have one, it's easier for me to come up with reasons why no one else should have one than admit I can't afford one.

Nice lame rationalization.
Perhaps they are more savvy than you and want more bang for their buck. For the same money they can get a laptop or netbook that will do a heck of a lot more than your pricey, limited, underpowered iToy that doesn't even do Flash.

Some folks have higher expectations.
Others, in the cult, not so much....:eyebrows:
 
Nice lame rationalization.
Perhaps they are more savvy than you and want more bang for their buck. For the same money they can get a laptop or netbook that will do a heck of a lot more than your pricey, limited, underpowered iToy that doesn't even do Flash.

Some folks have higher expectations.
Others, in the cult, not so much....:eyebrows:

Actually, I have a laptop too, but it's not so convenient for taking to meetings, bringing on a plane, etc.

You're pretty stuck on the whole "flash" thing aren't you? I thought the topic was tablets, in general - so tell me, if a person bought a Playbook would they be making a wise choice? Would they be in the cult, or would they have to be in a different cult? Would we be allowed to even bring them into the Apple cult? Or do you think there should be a seperate cult just for tablet owners?

And yeah, that is how stupid your anti-Apple rants sound. Just out of curiosity, how much luck are you having communicating using smoke signals? Are you still lighting your smokes by rubbing 2 sticks together? It is okay to keep up with technology.
 
So, in other words I'm right, you have NO experience with them being durable or not. That's what you wrote, you said in your experience they are not durable. Unless you were tossing them around in the stores.

Pffttt....seriously, your credibility on here is virtually nil.

I was playing with them at Apple Store and Best Buy, not just looking at them. Played around with many on them and FWIW think they are slow.