rant about crappy tire

newbler

Member
Mar 21, 2006
848
4
18
that time of year rolled around that i needed an emissions test done, and i was overdue for an oilchange anyways, so i take my car into crappy tire. ( i know i know, mistake number 1 ) anyways, i get a call today that my car needs front brakes, i tell the man politely that i can do that myself and for him to just do what i asked to the car and i'll be on my way. the thing is, i just DID my brakes myself after the last time i had it in for an oil change because i was told the same thing, and when i pulled my wheels off, yes my pads were past their prime.

granted this time it has been like 10-12k since the last oil change, but somewhere between then and now, brakes were done, new pads, new rotors. i know brakes obviously last much longer than 10k.... my pet peeve, do they even look at the brakes or just tell this to everyone? cuz i hear this everytime i take my car in there.

i think they are just trying to rake in some suckers, because they quoted 400 something just for the front brakes, when i bought a pair of pads for 50 and change, and rotors for 20 something each, less than $100 in parts, 300 for labour? please.... even at a shop rate of say $60? it doesn't take 5 hrs. i did the front brakes myself in a little over an hour.

incase anyone is wondering why i can do brakes but not change my oil, im too big to get under my car... lol, i can do everything to my truck, but unfortunately i just cant manouver myself under my car if my life depended on it.
 
At least CT is consistent. :rolleyes: I don't think I've ever heard a good story from someone using them for car repairs.
 
The mechanists in the crappy tire are all high school drop out.

I dont even know why you take your car to them. CT are for soccer mom.
 
Never, never go to Crappy Tire for any service work. Sorry, I would not go there for an oil change. They are the worst gougers, and most expensive for anything. The worst part is they hit women the worst, and without a doubt they are most expensive in town, especially for brake jobs. I think Dealers would get a better rap than CT.
 
Same old story, crappy tire ripping people off and getting away with it. Somebody should do a consumers report, W5 or some other expose.

They did the same thing to me many years ago. I was a bit naive about my jeep back than and brough it in to canadian tire for something small. The truck was barely 4 years old and they told me my shocks were gone. I didn't believe them since the truck was riding just fine. But these guys were trying to convince me and scare me, that my shocks could brake off, and I could cause an accident. I went to another mechanic and he told me my shocks were fine.
 
I only go to CT for an oil change. They always try to upsell you. I've left my car, come back in an hour, only to find all the wheels off my car and them telling me how badly I'm in need of a complete brake overhaul. :rolleyes: They wanted me to spend over a grand on all sorts of "problems."

It was funny b/c they said my coolant needed changing. I laughed and told them I'd just had a complete coolant flush a couple weeks earlier. They said their records didn't show that. Uh, yeah, no shit. Because I'm not dumb enough to have CT do it!

CT looks at their records and if those indicate you're overdue, that's what they use to determine what service you need. Doesn't matter if your car actually needs it or not.

You have to be really careful with CT and only have them do work that you already know needs to be done.
 
Not that I'm defending CT, but if you had a seized slider pin, or your caliper was seizing up.....you're lucky to get 10K!!! Brake Jobs are not just about rotors and pads...the hardware has to be serviced as well....that's what seperates the men from the boys when it comes to brake jobs! Just my input, I don't want to get anyone upset...LOL!
 
bethy said:
I dont even know why you take your car to them. CT are for soccer mom.

Exactly. That's what they bank on (although many other chains and dealers are not much better). They must be trained and instructed to try the pitch on everyone so as not miss out on scoring more money form the people who are absentminded about their car's service and will go with whatever the shop suggests.

It's a philosophy that favours a "get the most money NOW" approach without worrying about the customers you might lose forever. Unfortunately so many people have a love affair with this franchise that they feel secure enough to piss some customers off.
 
skyfire said:
Not that I'm defending CT, but if you had a seized slider pin, or your caliper was seizing up.....you're lucky to get 10K!!! Brake Jobs are not just about rotors and pads...the hardware has to be serviced as well....that's what seperates the men from the boys when it comes to brake jobs! Just my input, I don't want to get anyone upset...LOL!

i agree with you 100%, if my caliper was seized, i wouldn't have been able to squeeze it back in to accomidate a new pad, and i always lubricate my slider pins with heat resistant grease, i just didn't bother mentioning it because i honestly didn't expect anyone to understand brakes to that detail =p but to make a long story short there is nothing wrong with them at all, i can let go of my steering wheel at 100km/h or when im braking, no pull whatsoever
 
For the record: What puddle jumper do you own that you only paid $20.00 a piece for rotors?

Since you did the brake job yourself, where did you turn your rotors? At 20.00 each I'm SO sure they were 100% true outta the box...NOT

Calipers: ummm just because the piston moves fine, doesn't mean they're fine.

There's a multitude of reasons brakes might not last more than 10K....constant stop and go, improper installation, poor quality pads, overheated rotors will cause pads to wear in about 1/10th the time. Plus if there are lateral scuffs in the surface of the rotor that too will cause rapid pad wear.

Letting go of the steering wheel at any speed is just ONE of the tests you can do to check your brakes. Just because the brakes pull smoothly doesn't mean they can't be worn....

Shocks: there's fine and then there's fine. Maybe they won't fall off the truck but I bet most mechanics will try to sell you a new pair if there's less than 20% life left in them.....

Sure EVERY auto shop will try to upsell you. That's how they stay in business. Hasn't anyone ever gone in for a new dress shirt and the guy tries to sell you a new tie too? Or how about shoes and the salesman tries to sell you polish?

Anyone who goes to any shop, and doesn't know the basics of how their vehicle works, or has never read the manual, and DOESN'T look at what the mechanic is trying to sell them and DOESN"T ask for their old parts deserves to be taken. SOrry, but if you don't bother to know a little bit about what owning a vehicle entails and think owning one is just turning the key and going, then you open yourself up to all sorts of things.

Now, if during your oil change you signed on for the deluxe 40 point inspection, that's why your wheels were off. They WEREN'T purposely doing things you didn't ask for.

Again, if they were putting sugar in your gas tank, loosening bolts to cause leaks, cutting fan belts, etc THEN you have a right to bitch and moan. But a salesman trying to sell you something? Ummm yeah ok.....

BTW: CTC is far from the worse place you can go for service....believe me....
 
listen tboy, long story short, there's nothing wrong with the brakes. but the original point of the thread was, they tell you that you need service that you dont, every time the car is in there, its a constant upsell. keebler hit the nail on the thread, because THEIR records indicate that my brakes haven't been done since the last time i had my car in there, 10-12k ago, they tell me it needs to be done, not because they actually noticed my brakes were in poor condition.
 
Listen Newb: did you actually check the brakes when they had the wheels off? Hell, I'd at least say to them: I need front brakes? Show me......

BTW: you never did tell me where you can get brake rotors for 20 bucks apiece......
 
tboy,

It's not that they are trying to upsell you that people resent, it's the fact that they are telling you you are in dire need of services that you don't actually need done and are relying on the fact that everyone can't be an auto mechanic to close the sale.

To use your shirt analogy, it would be like the salesman telling you "You need to get a new tie, that one you have on is about ready to explode and kill someone"

Sure you can ask for your used parts back, but unless you marked them in advance how do you know that they're actually YOUR parts they are showing you?
 
Tboy

It is possible to get $20 rotors at canadian tire for some North America made cars. Usually late 80s early to mid 90s but they are few and far between. Same at same at aftermarket if you recieve the shop discount for a few others if you get the shop discount
 
goodtime said:
Years ago, a relative had their brake work done at local CT. The trainee somehow incorrectly mount the brakepads. Needless to say, there were any brake at the traffic light. Lucky it was late at night & no traffic else accident for sure.

Only problem with your story goodtime is that how did they get the car out of the shop without using the brakes? So they must have replaced all pads on all wheels for the brakes to fail because the system is designed to stop the vehicle if 1 2 or 3 wheels fail.

Sorry, I don't believe you. Send me the details of the settlement because it would have been in the tens of thousands and highly publicized. For eg: in 1988 GM produced replacement brake pads for the Grand Prix (new model that year). It seems that some were made way too hard and didn't have the same grip on the disc/rotor that the OEM ones did. Seems a few accidents resulted. The settlements for those claims were in the hundreds of thousands....

Re: used parts. 1) you can watch them remove them from your vehicle. Most places have windows where you can see into the shop. 2) You don't have to be a mechanic but you should know what a rotor, brake pad, caliper, brake lines, fan belt, when you should replace all fluids, etc etc Basically take a look at your engine closely the day it comes off the dealership. Look at all the parts you can see so you know what they look like new.

This is no different than learning how to change a tire on your new vehicle. This way when you get a flat at 3 am and it's pouring rain out you're not struggling getting the jack out from under the spare tire (and you know the proper jack point).

Sorry, I don't buy it. This story is NO different than the people that fall for the old "you have to replace the air in all 4 tires because it's stale..."
 
I find the best way to handle CT is to go to them and say 'do this, do this and do that... no I don't want to to diagnose anything'. When you let them "check" things, that where things start to get out of control.

Also, some CT locations are much worse than others. The one on Dundas west of Kipling is much worse than the one by 403 & Dundas.

Understand that CT stores are franchises just like any dealer. Some franchise owners know how to run a business better than others.

Some dealers gouge really bad too.

On a Honda I used to own, I needed a full brake job... rotors, pads, repair seized caliper and new rear shoes.

The dealer (near Dundas and Winston Churchill) quoted me around $2000 for this.

CT (Dundas & 403) quoted and charged around $900.

Other places might have done the job for less than CT, but not by much. And the CT I went to has a shuttle service where they'll drop you off at work and pick you up later at no cost.

The worst repair experience I had was with Active Green & Ross to replace a heater core... they tried to charge me 8 hours of labour for a job that had the job listed at 4.5 hours max in the Chilton labour rate guide. And they wanted to charge me for a new heater core AND a heater core 'recore' (you don't need to 'recore' a new heater core. This is only necessary on an old leaky one). And when the job was done, they did the same 'upsell' thing where the car was still on the hoist when it should have been ready in the parking lot.

I've never had CT do the 'car-on-the-hoist-when-it-should-be-ready' upsell. But as I said, you have to be selective with which CT you go to.


Keebler Elf said:
I only go to CT for an oil change. They always try to upsell you. I've left my car, come back in an hour, only to find all the wheels off my car and them telling me how badly I'm in need of a complete brake overhaul. :rolleyes: They wanted me to spend over a grand on all sorts of "problems."

It was funny b/c they said my coolant needed changing. I laughed and told them I'd just had a complete coolant flush a couple weeks earlier. They said their records didn't show that. Uh, yeah, no shit. Because I'm not dumb enough to have CT do it!

CT looks at their records and if those indicate you're overdue, that's what they use to determine what service you need. Doesn't matter if your car actually needs it or not.

You have to be really careful with CT and only have them do work that you already know needs to be done.
 
I agree. I know of a couple of CT stores that try to rebuild your car for you when you take it in for an oil change. I also knew someone who worked at CT as a service advisor and he said never to go to a CT.

On the other hand, I've been to the CT in Gravenhurst for minor stuff and the service was good. My thinking is the franchise owner is a member of a small community and he doesn't want to get the reputation of being a rip-off artist.

zekestone said:
Understand that CT stores are franchises just like any dealer. Some franchise owners know how to run a business better than others.
 
skyfire said:
Not that I'm defending CT, but if you had a seized slider pin, or your caliper was seizing up.....you're lucky to get 10K!!! Brake Jobs are not just about rotors and pads...the hardware has to be serviced as well....that's what seperates the men from the boys when it comes to brake jobs! Just my input, I don't want to get anyone upset...LOL!

If that was the case, the second you put the brakes on, the car would pull quite noticeably to the other side.
 
Most garages are the same. I take my car to the dealer where I bought the car (because it's still under warrantee) and they constantly try to upsell you shit you don't need. They are fucking terrible for service.

They have this "Maintenance A, B, and C" that the Warrantee manual does not call for that they constantly try to get you to subscribe to.

"Oh, your car is due for it's Maintenance C"

Me: "And what does that entail?"

Them, "We will change the oil, inspect this and inspect that, rotate the tires, and service the brakes"

Me, "What do you mean service the brakes?"

Them, "Well clean and inspect the brakes"

Me," What do you mean you clean and inspect the brakes"

Them "We take them apart, clean off the dust, clean the pins, adjust them blah blah blah"

Me, "How much is that?"

Them "$389.00"

Me: "No fucking way, it doesn't need it"

Them, "well, we also inspect this and that (he even said that they inspect the Air Conditioning)"

Me: "I want an oil change"

Them, getting all pissed off, "you really need to maintain your car properly"

Me: "I've been laying under cars since I was 8 years old, I know what needs to be done and what is bullshit upsell"

Disk brakes do not need cleaning, you can clean the pins every time you do a brake job and replace any bushings in the calipers and you are good to go. If the piston(s) go back into the bore, you are FINE.

The fucking dealer where I take my car charges 80 bucks for an oil change, because he "inspects this and that"

It's all a huge scam.

If you aren't educated, they see you coming.



They constantly try to sell me this shit.

I seriously doubt that they even do any of it.