Being reported that an appeal is "likely".
http://news.ca.msn.com/top-stories/michael-rafferty-likely-to-appeal-conviction
That's not how it works.
Appeals are almost ALWAYS appealed on the basis of the interpretation of a law, not on new evidence being introduced by the other side.
The convicted murderer might appeal a specific part of the trial that was conducted outside of prior law etc.
Again, we agree.
It just sickens me to the core of my being that such depravity and evil exists on the planet.
Further to what Oagre said everyone does and should have the right to counsel even in horrific cases such as this.Well, no. We choose our cases. The trial is attractive in that it is a high profile case and defence counsel perhaps convinced himself there was a "reasonable doubt" that his client was not proven guilty. That's all there has to be to merit an acquittal.
It's a job. You do your best and try not to get emotionally involved. Does it impact you? Uh-huh. But you're trained to deal with it and concentrate on the legal issues and block the feelings out.
So you think we should be like Iran? his life and suffering would be ended then. I'd rather he spends the rest of his life looking over his shoulder wondering when the end will come, a long slow torture.
sorry...the cost of housing, feeding and entertaining these fucks is way too many hard earned tax dollars wasted on low lifes
.... and the day we get the wrong guy and execute him too soon, where will you be?
Well, Officer blackrock, make sure you don't slip up! :eyebrows:
Good thing the evidence that was kept from the jury is now public, he'll be convicted again even faster if the appeal goes though. :thumb:
I think that you deeply misunderstand everything about the criminal trial system. The evidence was obviously suppressed by the judge, either due to a Charter argument by the Defence or because the Defence successfully argued that the evidence was so prejudicial that it would have distracted the jury from concentrating on the immediately relevant facts of the case and thus rendering a reliable verdict.
The appeal to the Ont CA - and eventually to the SCC - focuses exclusively on technical errors made by the judge in - allegedly - the Crown's favour. It's not an invitation to the CA to consider non-admissible evidence contrary to accused. Were it so, why would the accused appeal?
I have a problem with on one hand having such faith in the jury system and at the same time not having enough faith in the jury that the judge feels it necessary to surpress certain facts because they may be prejudicial.
To further pevert this by allowing an appeal because the jury heard facts that someone thinks they had no right to hear.....c'mon. At some point this is just lawyers going around in circles.
Do you feel they "got the wrong guy?".... and the day we get the wrong guy and execute him too soon, where will you be?