QuickBooks or Simply Accounting?

Linds

New member
Nov 26, 2010
206
0
0
Which one would you use and why, I can't decide which one to buy?
 
interesting ... had never heard of myob.

quickbooks is for really simple configurations ... simply accounting ... sadly is not simple ...
 
QB is pretty straightforward and with the unlimited support option (>$50 all in) in your first year, it's pretty much fool-proof.
 
I forget which one, but one of those two choices give you much better control over audit trail. Allowing you to edit income and expenses to better reflect your desired tax goals.
 
I think QB is superior to SA, and SA isn't so simple (like someone said). If you're already used to Simply Acctg then by all means, continue using it.

MYOB has always had a great reputation but it was discontinued at one time. I believe it is back on the shelves.
 
interesting ... had never heard of myob.

quickbooks is for really simple configurations ... simply accounting ... sadly is not simple ...

MYOB is its former name ...it is now called Accountedge...I should have clarified.

My preference when it comes to clients records, Worst to best:
5 a box filled with receipts
4 Simply accounting
3 QuickBooks
2 well maintained manual books
1 MYOB
 
MYOB is its former name ...it is now called Accountedge...I should have clarified.

My preference when it comes to clients records, Worst to best:
5 a box filled with receipts
4 Simply accounting
3 QuickBooks
2 well maintained manual books
1 MYOB

Right, Accountedge. Do they sell it at Staples? Can I transfer or export my data files from QB to Accountedge with ease of conversion?
 
In QB, can you set up several companies and consolidate them? Or divisions that use a common chart of accounts?
 
Are the 'several companies' all owned by the same shareholder(s) ? Quickbooks does separate divisions, but they're called classes and have to be set in the Preferences. I would definitely use account numbers for your chart of accounts. Unless the activites are related to one entity, like liquor, soft drinks and food for a restuarant, I would make each entity their own Quickbooks file and export the statements to Excel and marry them there.
Just my 2¢
CA
 
how complex is your bookkeeping? How many employees ( if any)? Simply allows you to make many journal entries easily. Changes and corrections to posting you already made.
Simply takes up a lot room in your computer - server.
look at how easy it is to update payroll ( taxes etc) , support. you can set up more then company with simply.
Also investigate bank rec..how easy.
Are you using a bookkeeper? get their input
 
Hey CA. Let's say I own five hot dog stands but that each one is located at different street corners. So I can have own common chart of accounts but book transactions to individual classes for each stand?

Are the 'several companies' all owned by the same shareholder(s) ? Quickbooks does separate divisions, but they're called classes and have to be set in the Preferences. I would definitely use account numbers for your chart of accounts. Unless the activites are related to one entity, like liquor, soft drinks and food for a restuarant, I would make each entity their own Quickbooks file and export the statements to Excel and marry them there.
Just my 2¢
CA
 
I have used QB since .... well a long time now. I have several companies so I loaded on several UN-related computers there for no mix up or connections which came in handy because of the federal audit I just had. The Feds where happy and said there job was easier.My C A's job is easier. Now I can only vouch for QB but all in all quite satisfied.
 
Hey CA. Let's say I own five hot dog stands but that each one is located at different street corners. So I can have own common chart of accounts but book transactions to individual classes for each stand?

Exactly. Each account can be common to all classes (locations). It's just a way of sorting your data and the software you chose all have the same goal basically. Without knowing all the details, Quickbooks will work for what you've described so far.
CA (acronym for Capital Amatuer, not Chartered Accountant!)
 
I've been using QB since they first came out. By far the best accounting package for small and medium sized business. MYOB from what I remember was a nightmare.
 
I have used QB since .... well a long time now. I have several companies so I loaded on several UN-related computers there for no mix up or connections which came in handy because of the federal audit I just had. The Feds where happy and said there job was easier.My C A's job is easier. Now I can only vouch for QB but all in all quite satisfied.

Your accountant must think you're a saint too :)
 
I agree. I've tried Simply and MYOB and I went directly back to Quickbooks.

You have wisdom beyond your years Kayla ;)