Questions for TERB evolutionary biologists

Humans certainly are evolving (although mixed race breeding is setting that clock back a few thousand years)
As evidenced by the neanderthal throwback attitude your post embodies?

Jesus. The fucking Grand Dragon of the Orangeville chapter is a TERB poster. Just fucking great.
 
How did single cell organisms (apparently how all life forms started on earth) evolve into multi-cell organisms? Are there any observable instances of this?

If species are constantly evolving and this is the process by which new species come into existence, why don't we observe thousands of different species evolving into brand new species every day (since there are billions of species on earth)?
Two good questions: 1) We don't often see the very earliest steps because more evolved critters eat the just-evolved. 2) As for new species evolving from old, we're seeing that every day, but until the process is complete there isn't a new species to be observed, only the ongoing process. See also Answer 1), and ask again when we we're no longer constantly discovering species we didn't know of before.

BTW what do you mean by the word 'species'.
 
In the lab they have already observed single celled bacteria turning into multicelled organisms, in the lab they have already observed fruit flies changing into a new species that can not reproduce with the original fruit flies. The only missing piece of the puzzle is the transition from non living to what we would consider as living.
 
BTW what do you mean by the word 'species'.

By species I'm referring to something that can only reproduce with other members of the same species.

As I understand it, you and I could still mate with humans that lived 50k years ago (if we could travel back in time) since they are the same species. However, since we're constantly evolving, does this mean that there may come a time in the future when our species' reproductive genes have undergone so many new mutations that humans would no longer be considered human (i.e. they would not be able to theoretically mate with you, I, or humans that lived in the past to produce offspring)? The same way we cannot mate with some proto-human types although I recall reading that modern Europeans were able to breed with Neanderthals, according to new DNA research.
 
Oh good.. I didn't have to ask it.

I don't know if it makes his statement irrelevant since he has not yet elaborated on it.

As MissCroft points out, evolution doesn't strive for perfection, it just strives for adapting best to the environment that a species finds itself in.

As far as I know genetic variation strengthens a species' ability to survive under many more conditions - sturdier genetic stock. I don't know if this means that intermixing on the whole makes us "better", more "perfect", or "smarter". Or does it?
 
How did single cell organisms (apparently how all life forms started on earth) evolve into multi-cell organisms? Are there any observable instances of this?

If species are constantly evolving and this is the process by which new species come into existence, why don't we observe thousands of different species evolving into brand new species every day (since there are billions of species on earth)?

It is constantly happening. We usually see it quite easily with species that reproduce rapidly since it takes many generations for distinct mutations to become prominent. Viruses and bacteria are easy places to see mutations in action.

As for larger species, besides the generations issue, something needs to occur so that the mutated individuals don't breed back into the rest of the species and the identifiable mutation becomes a defining characteristic of that population. If the changing populations become a breeding population again then the differences will blend back together.

Fact is that mutations are happening all the time but for most multi-celled organisms, the only ones that can be passed on to offspring are mutations in sperm, eggs, or the very early stages of fetal development. Otherwise the mutations play no part in reproduction.

Finally, the vast majority of mutations have no observable effect so that even when mutations occur, the individuals don't become distinct from the rest of the population.


(not an evolutionary biologist but I did find genetics the only interesting part of biology in school)
 
...

As MissCroft points out, evolution doesn't strive for perfection, it just strives for adapting best to the environment that a species finds itself in....

To be honest, evolution doesn't strive for anything. It's just a bunch of random shit that happens. If the mutations are helpful, they are more likely to get passed on and if they are destructive, they are less likely but the mutations are just mutations (unless the flying spaghetti monster is guiding us to a pastadice on earth - actually, judging by the trend of gluten allergies, maybe it isn't the true god).
 
By species I'm referring to something that can only reproduce with other members of the same species.

As I understand it, you and I could still mate with humans that lived 50k years ago (if we could travel back in time) since they are the same species. However, since we're constantly evolving, does this mean that there may come a time in the future when our species' reproductive genes have undergone so many new mutations that humans would no longer be considered human (i.e. they would not be able to theoretically mate with you, I, or humans that lived in the past to produce offspring)? The same way we cannot mate with some proto-human types although I recall reading that modern Europeans were able to breed with Neanderthals, according to new DNA research.

Different species that are genetically close enough to each other can still reproduce, but their offspring are usually sterile. The most common example of this is a mule (horse + donkey).
 
How does mixed race breeding set back evolution? Wouldn't it be speeding up the clock and make the human stock even stronger (more genetic variation)?

Evolution = specialized organisms for specific environments (go read Darwins comments of finches)

When we travel to vastly different climates and mix races you are undoing evolution at that point

You also end up with less genetic variations (recessive genes require smaller breeding pool, same as in dogs)
 
???

Some studies have shown mixed-race children (half black) tend to perform better on I.Q. tests than their white (or black) counterparts. I have mixed race cousins who are super smart and performed extremely well in school.

.

I would love to see a *valid* study on this; only one I have ever seen was that mixed race kids tended to be worse off immunity wise

But either way you are making the same argument smallcock did based on an ignorance of what evolution is

As evidenced by the neanderthal throwback attitude your post embodies?

Jesus. The fucking Grand Dragon of the Orangeville chapter is a TERB poster. Just fucking great.

You guys make me laugh with the racism bit
Try understanding the concept of what evolution is then come back to post again
 
Mutation.

^ This

And time. A lot of time.

Evolution has been occurring consistently for billions of years, but in infinitesimally small steps. "Stages" in the development of any given species isn't going to be noticeable within anyone's life span, but observation of species with a common root is observed in many cases... the most obvious being Darwin's finches.

If you are interested in this stuff, read Darwin's original work "Origin of the Species". While he didn't nail it, he got pretty damn close...

http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/origin.html
 
But either way you are making the same argument smallcock did based on an ignorance of what evolution is.


I've read the Origin of Species, took a course on evolutionary biology in university and dated a geneticist. I have one of his books which explains genetic variations, genetic drift (which also occurs in small, isolated populations by the way so there is no guarantee that change will not occur), mutations (new mutations, familial mutations, meiotic versus mitotic mutations), consanguinity, lod scores, etc. etc. very clearly.

Please don't say that I am 'ignorant' about what evolution is.


Natural selection is not perfect. It has no brain and therefore no goal.
http://evolution.berkeley.edu/evolibrary/article/evo_32


Your previous comments although being politically correct have nothing to do with how evolution works though


My posts had absolutely nothing to do with politics or being politically correct. Don't know where you got that from? :confused:



From a technical side MORE species would tend to indicate evolution is failing


Can't follow that logic at all. So the fewer species on Earth, the better? Why?


Evolution can't fail because it doesn't have a goal to begin with in the first place.
 
Last edited:
By species I'm referring to something that can only reproduce with other members of the same species.

As I understand it, you and I could still mate with humans that lived 50k years ago (if we could travel back in time) since they are the same species. However, since we're constantly evolving, does this mean that there may come a time in the future when our species' reproductive genes have undergone so many new mutations that humans would no longer be considered human (i.e. they would not be able to theoretically mate with you, I, or humans that lived in the past to produce offspring)? The same way we cannot mate with some proto-human types although I recall reading that modern Europeans were able to breed with Neanderthals, according to new DNA research.
Ok, so until a mutation shows up that makes non-mate-ability a preferable survival characteristic, we won't have a new species. Given that evolutionary survival is a matter of maximizing genetic transmission by mating—at least for plants and animals that do it sexually—it seems almost too obvious that such a transmission-limiting mutation would arise and disappear again — all unnoticed — countless times before it finally came with enough other packaging and there were enough other potential mates to pass it on.

But anyone who wanted to detect it would have an awful lot of 'sterile' matings to investigate. No wonder they look at fruitflies.
 
You realize an evolution branch takes millions of years right?


Not always...

An excerpt from a book I have:

"Sometime within the past 12,000 or so years, most of humankind began to experience a profound shift in lifestyle.........A landscape full of wild grasses, woolly mammoths and sabertooth cats gave way to giant-eared corn, fat cattle, toy poodles and many other new species. For reasons that remain obscure, the shift happened rapidly, by evolutionary standards, and in the mere space of a few thousand years, different domestic animals and plants appeared independently in several parts of the world."

To be fair, there was likely human involvement because it was during the time when humans began to manipulate the environment domesticating plants and animals but still. Evolution happened rapidly. The gray wolf 'evolved' into dogs like toy poodles, spaniels, bulldogs, St. Bernards, etc. within a relatively short timeframe. But this was also due to at least 2,000 years of breeding under human control. (Keep in mind that the original gray wolf still exists - it did not die out).



A more natural example would be blue eyes. That was a mutation that spread rapidly. But I realize that it's a specific trait and not a branch of evolution. Interesting article though:

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/s...00-years-old-and-lived-in-a-cave-9086310.html


Hitler would've likely been upset to know that the first known person with blue eyes was of African descent.
 
Variation within a species is not the same as a new species. Speciation involves many variations, lots of time, and usually geographic separation of one subset of the group (e.g. by water, mountain range,etc.)


As I understand it, humans and dogs have been closely involved for much longer than that. Even still, domesticated dogs are still part of the same species that includes wolves. They can mate and produce offspring that can also reproduce. Keep dogs and wolves separate for thousands and thousands of years, and you'll probably have two truly distinct species.

Again, one mutation does not make a new species. Neither probably does dozens or hundreds.

I'm glad OP is asking questions, but why ask this random group of people. If you want to understand evolution,mead a book by a scientist - the one I suggested is hard going but it's excellent - or find a good BBC documentary if you don't have the time. Even if you are skeptical about it, watch it, read it, skeptically, and at least understand for yourself what their conclusions are on this, and if you still don't buy it, fine.
 
As I understand it, humans and dogs have been closely involved for much longer than that. Even still, domesticated dogs are still part of the same species that includes wolves. They can mate and produce offspring that can also reproduce. Keep dogs and wolves separate for thousands and thousands of years, and you'll probably have two truly distinct species.


You are correct. Wolves and dogs are still the same species. I like the Blue Wilderness commercials. :)

It's impossible to know when the first wolves starting hanging around human settlements. But the first physical evidence was of a human skeleton in Israel about 12,000 years ago where the person was buried holding a puppy. Either a dog or a wolf pup.


But it was stated that a branch of evolution takes millions of years and that has not been proven to be true. And there were new species of plants and animals that appeared rapidly in the last 12,000 years.