Questions for TERB evolutionary biologists

I've read the Origin of Species, took a course on evolutionary biology in university and dated a geneticist. I have one of his books which explains genetic variations, genetic drift, mutations (new mutations, familial mutations, meiotic versus mitotic mutations), consanguinity, lod scores, etc. etc. very clearly.

Please don't say that I am 'ignorant' about what evolution is.

Many people have read many books without having a clue what the book was about
Your previous comments although being politically correct have nothing to do with how evolution works though

An isolated population develops certain traits (eg black skin, chinese eyes etc) through evolution
But mixing them is the opposite of evolution as recessive genes are suppressed
 
However, since we're constantly evolving, does this mean that there may come a time in the future when our species' reproductive genes have undergone so many new mutations that humans would no longer be considered human

Very unlikely
It would require a very long isolation for that kind of genetic drift

And if one mutation was so random it would most likely die out in general population very quickly
 
An isolated population develops certain traits (eg black skin, chinese eyes etc) through evolution
But mixing them is the opposite of evolution as recessive genes are suppressed


What exactly is the "opposite of evolution"? Sometimes, recessive traits are better suppressed because they are traits that are not helpful for survival. There are many diseases/autosomal disorders caused by recessive traits.


Cystic Fibrosis is one that affects mostly Caucasians.

Sickle-cell Anemia affects mostly African-Americans.

Tay-Sachs Disease affects mostly Jewish people of Eastern European descent.


There are also rare autosomal recessive disorders that will cause a child to die by the time they reach the age of ten. (The parents would both have to be carriers of the recessive gene though they would be unaffected). Any siblings will also be at risk.


So people should not mix with other races because...?




Did I mention the Hapsburgs?

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencet...ly-spelled-end-line-inbred-royal-dynasty.html






As a side note, 'Chinese eyes' (epicanthic eye folds) are believed to be a result of sexual selection. :)
 
Last edited:
What exactly is the "opposite of evolution"?

An example of this would be carrot top:
carrot-top-funny-pics.jpg


BTW: The title of the thread - Is there such a thing as a non-evolutionary biologist ?
 
Many people have read many books without having a clue what the book was about
Your previous comments although being politically correct have nothing to do with how evolution works though

An isolated population develops certain traits (eg black skin, chinese eyes etc) through evolution
But mixing them is the opposite of evolution as recessive genes are suppressed

What exactly is the "opposite of evolution"? Sometimes, recessive traits are better suppressed because they are traits that are not helpful for survival. There are many diseases/autosomal disorders caused by recessive traits.


Cystic Fibrosis is one that affects mostly Caucasians.

Sickle-cell Anemia affects mostly African-Americans.

Tay-Sachs Disease affects mostly Jewish people of Eastern European descent.







As a side note, 'Chinese eyes' (epicanthic eye folds) were a result of sexual selection.

There is no opposite of evolution.

There was a school of thought that evolution was moving species to some level of perfection. However evolutionary theory has no presumption that evolution has some direction.

This school of thought espouse devolution and was associated mainly with those who espoused theories on racial purity- they believed if the races mixed then then this was undoing the work of evolution.
 
By species I'm referring to something that can only reproduce with other members of the same species.

As I understand it, you and I could still mate with humans that lived 50k years ago (if we could travel back in time) since they are the same species. However, since we're constantly evolving, does this mean that there may come a time in the future when our species' reproductive genes have undergone so many new mutations that humans would no longer be considered human (i.e. they would not be able to theoretically mate with you, I, or humans that lived in the past to produce offspring)? The same way we cannot mate with some proto-human types although I recall reading that modern Europeans were able to breed with Neanderthals, according to new DNA research.
Could a human from today's time travel to some distant future period and be unable to produce viable offspring because humans have evolved sufficiently that they are now a different species?

Putting aside the time travel issue, then yes it's possible but it would take a very long time.
 

Eugenics was certainly one offshoot from this line of thinking and was sadly more common than most people realize.

Sterilizing the insane, the mentally retarded, gays, blacks, mongrel or mixed race people. It happened in many western countries.
 
Eugenics was certainly one offshoot from this line of thinking and was sadly more common than most people realize.

Sterilizing the insane, the mentally retarded, gays, blacks, mongrel or mixed race people. It happened in many western countries.

Evolution does not make presumptions about direction or perfection but humans can. Is it not possible or even reasonable if there are traits that some individuals find subjectively "good" that mixing would or does dilute or reduce?
 
If species are constantly evolving and this is the process by which new species come into existence, why don't we observe thousands of different species evolving into brand new species every day (since there are billions of species on earth)?

You probably don't get up early enough to see it.
 
Evolution does not make presumptions about direction or perfection but humans can. Is it not possible or even reasonable if there are traits that some individuals find subjectively "good" that mixing would or does dilute or reduce?

Maybe this would work if there was central control over human breeding over hundreds of thousands of years. If you like blondes then your children may have blonde hair but that would be the extent of it.

An individual can have no impact on the evolution of the human species. You don't live long enough or have enough children.

I assume., because I am polite, that you are not talking about some neo nazi white breeding programs and that by mixing you do not mean mixing of the races diluting the good meaning white. But in case you do mean that- fuck you.
 
Maybe this would work if there was central control over human breeding over hundreds of thousands of years. If you like blondes then your children may have blonde hair but that would be the extent of it.


Geneticists are already learning how to manipulate genes. For example, if you wanted a boy or a girl or a blue-eyed child, they can probably already do that (or are getting close) but the question is an ethical one.


They've apparently determined which gene causes a person to be prone to alcoholism so should eventually be able to manipulate and change that. (That will be bad for the bar business, lol)


Through Amniocentesis, https://en.wikipedia.org/?title=Amniocentesis it can be determined if the foetus has any genetic abnormalities or disorders like Down Syndrome and the mother could decide to abort but again there is a big question of ethics.


So, in the case of humans, evolution and 'natural' selection iis starting to become less random and more controlled.
 
Evolution = specialized organisms for specific environments (go read Darwins comments of finches)

When we travel to vastly different climates and mix races you are undoing evolution at that point

You also end up with less genetic variations (recessive genes require smaller breeding pool, same as in dogs)
If you're no longer in the tiny evolutionary niche of your 'home' environment, you'd damn well better do some race mixing or whatever evolved genes only you possess will be lost to your species. Far from undoing evolution, you're actually participating. and ensuring your little recessive pool doesn't last too long.

As in the case of dogs who haven't been allowed to breed true.They could never have managed to sustain such unhealthy deviations as English bulldogs that can't breathe or Shar Peis that breed skin fungus without human meddling. On their own, they'd be successful in a wide variety of environments, wild and urbanized, like coyotes and their crosses with wolves and dogs.

Or like the human race.