Question

drlove

Ph.D. in Pussyology
Oct 14, 2001
4,895
329
83
The doctor is in
I was recently sent an offer by the bank I have my mortgage with to apply for one of their credit cards. I had a card from them years ago but cancelled it since I never used it. I called up and asked if they could just reactivate my old card, but they said I needed to re-apply. I thought it might be nice to get the Visa since I could take advantage of special promotional rates on balance transfers and cash advances - the problem is, I have so much credit already (probably too much) so I don't know if it's a good idea. I made an appointment with a bank rep to discuss the situation. My question is, if they see how much credit I already have in general, would they freak and say something along the lines of, "we'll have to re-evaluate your mortgage... your debt service ratio is too high etc. and try to cancel the mortgage on me? I don't know if something like that can work against me or not. I should say I'm only using a very small percentage of my available credit at this time. I just don't want to have any problems where my mortgage is concerned, that's all. Thanks.
 
I can't speak first hand, but this was the situation from good friends .
They sold their condo and purchased another one, when they went for the new mortgage the fact came up that they had too many credit cards with the ability to borrow too much money for their income, thus potentially putting the new mortgage at risk due to inability to pay. even tho their current debt was low, they had the ability to charge much more on the credit credit cards. They had to cancel some of their cards in order to get the new mortgage.
Having said all of that, the banks will already have a good knowledge of your debt, and credit cards you hold with the available limits
 
I can't speak first hand, but this was the situation from good friends .
They sold their condo and purchased another one, when they went for the new mortgage the fact came up that they had too many credit cards with the ability to borrow too much money for their income, thus potentially putting the new mortgage at risk due to inability to pay. even tho their current debt was low, they had the ability to charge much more on the credit credit cards. They had to cancel some of their cards in order to get the new mortgage.
Having said all of that, the banks will already have a good knowledge of your debt, and credit cards you hold with the available limits

Would such a scenerio apply with regard to a simple renewal as well?
 
if you already got credit cards, why bother getting another one. ya okay rewards but whatever, why bother.
 
I should say I'm only using a very small percentage of my available credit at this time. I just don't want to have any problems where my mortgage is concerned, that's all. Thanks.

I can't comment as to the effect on your mortgage/renewal but - given that you state you do not use the credit you already have - why do you feel the need to consider yet another card? I would think you would be just providing no goodniks one more thing they could fraud you with if your info got compromised...
 
As long as your mortgage payment history has been good, your mortgage should be renewed without any fuss. The worst thing that could happen would be the bank would ask you to cancel some of your credit cards, especially since you don't use them.
 
I was recently sent an offer by the bank I have my mortgage with to apply for one of their credit cards. ... My question is, if they see how much credit I already have in general, would they freak and say something along the lines of, "we'll have to re-evaluate your mortgage...
No. They would have already tested your credit score before offering you a new credit card (you gave them the right to do so when you got your mortgage from them). The offer your received means they are interested in selling you more credit and not cutting you off.
 
When you go for a mortgage banks look at how much credit you have available to you. If you have a lot of credit available to you in credit cards, that is bad. Even though you may think that it shows that you are a credit worthy person, banks look at it as if you get into a tight spot, you will run up the cards and then will not be able to service your mortgage. If this becomes an issue with your bank, just simply cancel some cards and then go back to them.
 
Every time your mortagage comes up or you apply for any kind of credit card the financing company does a credit check.Trust me ,they all know what your debt is and how many cards you have,how far behind you are on repayment.They also go way back to your first loan you ever had.They know more about you than you know about yourself.
 
If you are in specific discussions with your financial institution about borrowing, they will review your credit rating & history. However, the marketing departments of these institutions seldom do any background work when sending out these pre-approvals. You probably got a letter because you've got an account (or mortgage) but no credit card. They'll offer some low pre-approval amount, say $5000, but it isn't until you actually send in the application that they will do the credit review. At that time, they may decide to recind their offer.

Akin to something Gentle Ben already mentioned, your creditworthiness is based on your potential borrowing power, moreso than what you currently owe. Even if you have a fistful of cards you never use, they are still active and have the potential to be maxed out. If you really don't need certain cards, cancel them outright.

If you want to know your credit history and credit score, you can obtain that information from either Equifax or TransUnion. For a nominal fee (I believe ~ $25), you can get a detailed listing of your credit history, as well as your credit score. It's money well spent, so that you know exactly what the banks know about you.

I did this a couple of years ago, and was surprised to see a few old store cards that were still "on the books", even though the companies themselves were no longer in business (Texaco, Eatons), plus a few closed lines of credit that the banks hadn't reported as being closed. It was all small stuff that didn't significantly impact my credit rating, but it was still good to clean up the loose ends.
 
Interesting, so which looks worse to the lender in a hypothetical situation - having say 5-10 credit cards you don't use with all that unused credit 'available', or having cards with a lot of debt outstanding on them, but one always makes partial payments and is never late?

A guy I know once said he has a great credit rating and he owes 40k split between 6 cards, but because he always makes a minimum payment on time on all of them, he has a great relationship with his bank/credit card companies (as they make tons of interest off of him) and they always keep increasing his credit limits whenever his debt gets up there without his even asking them to do so. Why would this guy be seen as a better risk than a guy who pays his bills in full every month and happens to have unused credit?

I have three cards + Amex. I use one MasterCard card for my puchases, and pay it off every month. My three cards together have (unused) limits of over 50k. Amex is a charge card, not credit. So would banks think me a high risk for a mortgage...because I have cards I don't even use? (not that I want a mortgage, just saying...)
 
Certainly, banks will also look at your ability to pay, and your payment history, as well as what you owe.

Take for example your friend who owes $40k on six cards. A bank will look at him differently if he earns $100k /year vs $30k /year. Also, it depends on what percentage of his total credit limit that $40k represents. A higher percentage is worse. That's probably one reason c.c. companies "automatically" boost limits when you get near them - it helps bring that percentage back down. (Evil bastards!)
 
Certainly, banks will also look at your ability to pay, and your payment history, as well as what you owe.

Take for example your friend who owes $40k on six cards. A bank will look at him differently if he earns $100k /year vs $30k /year. Also, it depends on what percentage of his total credit limit that $40k represents. A higher percentage is worse. That's probably one reason c.c. companies "automatically" boost limits when you get near them - it helps bring that percentage back down. (Evil bastards!)

Okay, that makes sense. I often say to him it is crazy paying all that interest but he says he uses them to get airline points on purchases. My counter is with the interest he pays he could have bought his own airline ticket and had change left over lol. I don`t know what he makes per year - probably 60-80k - but I`m just guessing.

I was kind of raised in the old school mindset that every dollar you pay out to a bank in cc interest is one less dollar you have to spend yourself, so why throw money away. Sure, some things one needs to borrow for in life, but consumer goods doesn`t fit the bill in my mind.
 
Carrying a balance on a credit card is not a good way to borrow money because the interest rate is much higher than for lines of credit or secured loans.

On the other hand, having a comfortable limit on your credit card gives you the flexibility to make purchases when you want to even if your payroll isn't due for a few more days and you don't have to carry much cash. Just be sure to pay off the card at the end of the billing cycle.
 
If you have so much credit already, why would you want more?

Big red flag: BALANCE TRANSFER.

Really? You carry credit card debt??????????????? Stop applying for credit and pay that shit off.

If you REALLY like this card better than one you have already for some reason why not cancel some of your existing credit when you open this up? Yes you can have too much credit.. but if you aren't using it, it's a very small thing to shut some of it off! If you got a better offer than your existing credit why not just cancel the existing credit? If the answer is "I can't I owe" then don't get any more credit--pay down your damn debt.

Really the ONLY personal (non business) debt anyone should ever have is a mortage, and MAYBE a car loan. Car loans are usually a bad idea, but sometimes people have to have a car and just don't have the cash. There are few other "have to have" things in life, so really, that should be it for debt. If you're carrying debt for anything other than house or car then you fucked up somewhere.
 
Car loans are usually a bad idea, but sometimes people have to have a car and just don't have the cash
Car loans can be beneficial depending on the terms. I notice that a number of dealers are currently offering 0% financing over four years. In this case, you can put the money into a safe investment and earn interest for yourself instead of fronting it to the dealer. However, if the interest on the car loan is higher than you can make elsewhere, it's always better (if you have the cash) to pay up-front.
 
Really the ONLY personal (non business) debt anyone should ever have is a mortage, and MAYBE a car loan.

I would add a line of credit to that list. It can be a useful tool for situations where cash flow doesn't allow you to make purchases outright. Say for example you need to put a new roof on the house. If you don't have the $6000 on hand, and vendor financing isn't offered, you could put the expense on the LOC and pay that balance down as you are able every month. In terms of interest rates, it's less expensive than throwing it all on the credit card.

Of course, as with any borrowing tool, it has to be used wisely and with a plan to restore its balance back to zero.
 
If you have so much credit already, why would you want more?

Big red flag: BALANCE TRANSFER.

Really? You carry credit card debt??????????????? Stop applying for credit and pay that shit off.

If you REALLY like this card better than one you have already for some reason why not cancel some of your existing credit when you open this up? Yes you can have too much credit.. but if you aren't using it, it's a very small thing to shut some of it off! If you got a better offer than your existing credit why not just cancel the existing credit? If the answer is "I can't I owe" then don't get any more credit--pay down your damn debt.

Really the ONLY personal (non business) debt anyone should ever have is a mortage, and MAYBE a car loan. Car loans are usually a bad idea, but sometimes people have to have a car and just don't have the cash. There are few other "have to have" things in life, so really, that should be it for debt. If you're carrying debt for anything other than house or car then you fucked up somewhere.

No, no... I use the offers to my advantage: One of the banks I deal with gave me an offer of 0% interest for 14 months on cash advances / balance transfers. Therefore, I borrowed $10,000 at 0% and applied to the principal, thus saving me the 3.54% (mortgage rate) on that $10,000. When it comes due, I'll just pay it off, or get another offer and continue. See?