Question re Raptors' overall talent level

smuddan

Well-known member
Mar 7, 2007
2,393
387
83
The question I'd like to post here is, if you take the "stud" player out, which of the following teams would you say has the best overall talent and how would you rank the Raptors ?

A) Toronto without Bosh;
B) Clevland without James;
C) Orlando without Howard;
D) New Orleans without Paul;
E) LA without Bryant;
F) Denver wtihout either AI or Anthony;
G) Boston without Garnet;
H) Phoenix without Nash;

The reason I ask is because often when Bosh is out the Raptors play like crap, but if you compare these teams, I don't think Raptors are that bad without Bosh. I'd say Raptors would rank no worse than 3rd. and Boston would have to be best because they still had Pierce and Allen.

Would love to hear your opinion.

Smuddan
 
This is a great question.

Boston would have to be ranked the best because they still have Pierce and Allen. Don't forget Rajon Rondo, a future star. The addition of Cassell helps as well.

The Raps should be ranked high as well because they do have the best one-two punch at the PG position.

Take out Anthony from Denver and Denver should be ranked quite high.
Take out AI and the team plummets.

Regards,

Lawyerman
 
Boston
New Orleans (David West/Tyson Chandler/Peja Stojakovic)
LA (Gasol, Bynum, Odom)

Would all rank higher than Toronto IMO and Denver would be close IMO if JR Smith keeps his head straight. Toronto has such a creampuff schedule compared to them so its tough to compare.
Also missing from this list are teams with similar records to Toronto like Portland, Golden State, Philadephia etc with more balanced teams or younger teams than Toronto. Also teams like San Antonio, Dallas, Houston.

Cleveland would suck without Lebron and Orlando wouldn't be very good either. However, Lebron and Howard are far more valuable players than Bosh. Younger, healthier, much better rounded.
 
Powershot said:
Boston
New Orleans (David West/Tyson Chandler/Peja Stojakovic)
LA (Gasol, Bynum, Odom)

Would all rank higher than Toronto IMO and Denver would be close IMO if JR Smith keeps his head straight. Toronto has such a creampuff schedule compared to them so its tough to compare.
Also missing from this list are teams with similar records to Toronto like Portland, Golden State, Philadephia etc with more balanced teams or younger teams than Toronto. Also teams like San Antonio, Dallas, Houston.

Cleveland would suck without Lebron and Orlando wouldn't be very good either. However, Lebron and Howard are far more valuable players than Bosh. Younger, healthier, much better rounded.
I left out those teams for the reason you mentioned, i.e. those teams rely more on its balanced lineup than on anyone particular stud player. I should perhaps added Houston but they are doing ok even with Yao Ming and I wonder what they'd look like if it were McGrady who's out.

Perhaps your answer to this question would also indicate how you evaluate the stud players, e.g. if you think Toronto without Bosh is a much better team than Orlando without Howard, shouldn't that also mean you feel Howard is a much better player than Bosh ?
 
smuddan said:
I left out those teams for the reason you mentioned, i.e. those teams rely more on its balanced lineup than on anyone particular stud player. I should perhaps added Houston but they are doing ok even with Yao Ming and I wonder what they'd look like if it were McGrady who's out.

Perhaps your answer to this question would also indicate how you evaluate the stud players, e.g. if you think Toronto without Bosh is a much better team than Orlando without Howard, shouldn't that also mean you feel Howard is a much better player than Bosh ?
Understood.

Bosh is no where near the player Dwight Howard is. Hasn't this series shown it? Bosh is an average defender at best. Howard? If Orlando had a better distributor, watch out.
 
Cleveland would be a lottery team without Lebron. Orlando next on the list. The rest would shake out in this order, worst-to-best: Phoenix. New Orleans. Boston. Lakers. Toronto and Denver.
(Sorry, that's the reverse of what you were asking, but I'm not going to change the whole thing - you guys can figure it out!)

This is going on the assumption that the teams would just be missing the player by injury, would keep their current coaching staff and could not add a replacement.

Boston would be a lot worse than most people think because Garnett means so much defensively - individually, but in particular team defence - to the Celts along with the energy/intensity/accountability he brings to the team.
 
I don't know what the final stats were on this, but about 30 games into the season, Dwight Howard had more dunks than 25 NBA teams combined. Granted, he need to learn how to pass out of the double team, shoot free throws more consistently, and develop a jump shot, but the guy just turned 22 in December, and he hasn't missed a game in his NBA career. Other than LeBron, he is the only high school player to make the jump directly to the NBA, and make an immediate impact. If he hadn't started out in the ABA, Moses Malone would be on that list, too.
 
Wow I'm surprised people think so much of Toronto's players.

Toronto is not a good team with Bosh (.500 in the east = marginal team), yet without him they would be better than those other teams? How many games did they win this year without Bosh playing? Boston played +.500 without Garnett when he was out!

Have people not seen Andrew Bynum or Pau Gasol play? They are more valuable players than anyone on the Raptors "Boshless" roster.

How about David West/Peja/Tyson Chandler? Tyson and West again are better than anyone on a Boshless Raptor's roster.
 
Well, from my perspective, I looked at it as though the player would be gone for the long haul and that the team was in the playoffs, along with the relative expectations of the team before and after the player in question was removed from the team.

The Raptors' point guards and shooting would keep them in some games. Cleveland's entire game revolves around LBJ. Without him, who would score on that team? Who would handle the rock? Considering the Cavs went to the Finals last year, their bar is set a bit higher.
 
Herodotus said:
Cleveland would be a lottery team without Lebron. Orlando next on the list. The rest would shake out in this order, worst-to-best: Phoenix. New Orleans. Boston. Lakers. Toronto and Denver.
(Sorry, that's the reverse of what you were asking, but I'm not going to change the whole thing - you guys can figure it out!)

This is going on the assumption that the teams would just be missing the player by injury, would keep their current coaching staff and could not add a replacement.

Boston would be a lot worse than most people think because Garnett means so much defensively - individually, but in particular team defence - to the Celts along with the energy/intensity/accountability he brings to the team.
I agree with your assessment on Garnet's leadership quality, by the same token, I'm also very impressed with Bosh's disply of leadership this season. His natural skill level may be below par among the elite star players but he's probably second only to Garnet in terms of leadership.

As for the Lakers, the team was going nowhere before the arrival of Gasol. This one-two punch is probaly the most leathal weapon this year and that's good enough to propelled the team to the top. So if you take out Bryant, who I think is the best player this year, wouldn't that make them a very mediocre team ? Probably even worse than last year's Laker team ?
 
smuddan said:
As for the Lakers, the team was going nowhere before the arrival of Gasol. This one-two punch is probaly the most leathal weapon this year and that's good enough to propelled the team to the top. So if you take out Bryant, who I think is the best player this year, wouldn't that make them a very mediocre team ? Probably even worse than last year's Laker team ?

No, because the Lakers also have Bynum maturing into one of the top centers in the leauge who was injured around the allstar game. They're bench players are young/getting better. I don't get what you mean about them going no where before Gasol, they were top 6 in the West.

Bosh's leadership doesn't impress me that much because he talks the talk but too often doesn't walk the walk on the floor. His man to man defense is very suspect.
 
Quote : Powershot wrote "I don't get what you mean about them going nowhere before Gasol, they were top 6 in the West."

I said that in relative terms to how they're doing this year. If I remember correctly, didn't they lost out in the 1st round ? Both Toronto and Dallas finished 6 and they have gone nowhere either.

Alll I kept hearing this time last year was how the team was in disarray and how bad Kobe wanted out. But I would concur with Gasol and Bynum, they should still be better than a Rap team without Bosh.