Question for the passive portfolio holders

goodguy1977

Member
Jan 5, 2011
777
0
16
Hello all,

I've been analyzing the markets rapid move and while the fundamental reasons are starting to wane, I am now looking at it from a technical perspective.

I was reading the other posts and alot of investors talk about building etf portfolios, and using a passive strategy. I've just got a couple of questions:

1. How long have you held your passive portfolio position before transacting(rebalancing)?

2. What would be the catalyst to sell? If an 07-08 scenerio happened again would you just ride it down 50%? If not what would change your mind?

I just find it interesting when the market rallies the talk is strong for passive ports, but in a market crash/correction/pullback.... etfs aren't as popular.


Thanks

Goodguy
 
I'm not sure I call myself passive holder. But some positions i've held over 2 years simply because they never broke the trend lines.
other positions are bounded in a support resistance channel I buy sell them every couple of months.

I guess i'm a trend trader. If a stock keeps going up and never violates its support level then ill hold it forever.
 
If by passive you mean "buy-and-hold", I would tend to fall in this category. However, I stay away from ETFs and prefer fundamentally-sound, dividend-paying companies. It's more work than picking an ETF that tracks an exchange, but feel the reward is more than worth the homework involved. I tend to review these investments after about a one-year period based on their performance, new developments and business fundamentals. Afterwards, I then add to the holdings, stay the course or dump the investment.

Hope that answers your question...
 
Just today the Investor was praising the small and mid cap dividend paying stocks. I adhere to this since taking that bath in 2008. The fundementals there are usually more sound and the up side always a motivator.

Buy and hold I assume in what you mean by passive. There are a few traders here who can weigh in. I went in on a few REIT's a year or so back and so far so good.
 
1. How long have you held your passive portfolio position before transacting(rebalancing)?
2. What would be the catalyst to sell? If an 07-08 scenerio happened again would you just ride it down 50%? If not what would change your mind?

I tend to park capital I don't need for trading in very high dividend yielding equities and then immediately go delta neutral by putting a zero-cost collar on it so I don't have any exposure to the market but still get the high yield.
Obviously if it tanks or starts to look like it won't continue to dump dividends my way I'm protected but that tells me it is time to pick on something different but at least my major capital is always fully protected.
We used to hear about someones 401K or RRSP getting crushed (and we will again) and I always wonder why they didn't hedge it when it can cost nothing to do so. The only reason I can think of is that they just didn't know they could.
 
1. How long have you held your passive portfolio position before transacting(rebalancing)?

I've held positions for over a decade and have done very well with one (AAPL) and terrible with others. I'm now more inclined to get into and out of a position. I give a particular stock about 2-3 years to perform and then it's out.


2. What would be the catalyst to sell? If an 07-08 scenerio happened again would you just ride it down 50%? If not what would change your mind?

I'd sell if the market for a company's products was to disappear. For instance, I hold a position in one of Canada's largest oil sands producers. It's thrown off a small dividend over the past two years but is still down for me by a couple of percentage points. Now, given that I am pretty sure that the oil market is about go kablooey, I am probably going to liquidate that position in a few months.

As for the 2008 scenario, I didn't bother looking at my portfolio and it went down by about 10-15%. I was much more concerned about picking companies to purchase and, unfortunately, I faced a personal situation at that time which took all of my cash and then some. :(

For the record, I love it when the market panics and people flee. I've been through 2-3 market crashes and love each one for the opportunities.
 
Thanks for the great responses so far! Keep them coming! I myself am a more active trader unless there is a huge fundamental story. (I've held MFC from the 11s)


Goodguy
 
Once a year, rebalance and add new cash. If the market is going down, just means it's cheaper buying in.
 
Once a year, rebalance and add new cash. If the market is going down, just means it's cheaper buying in.

Hi there,

Are you using ETFs or mutual funds? Also in cases of serious corrections like 07 would you honestly stick with that strategy?

Thanks for the opinion..


Goodguy
 
Hi there,

Are you using ETFs or mutual funds? Also in cases of serious corrections like 07 would you honestly stick with that strategy?

Thanks for the opinion..


Goodguy

The most knowledgeable investors in the world rebalance according to the guidelines set out in their IPS (Investment Policy Statement) Normally, they set the threshold at 5% From the target allocation. They also maintain discipline regardless of bull or bear markets.


,
 
Hi there,

Are you using ETFs or mutual funds? Also in cases of serious corrections like 07 would you honestly stick with that strategy?

Thanks for the opinion..


Goodguy

ETFs, for the low fees.

Yes, I would stick with the strategy. Not everyone likes it, but no one who recommends it suggest that there are moments when there is some sort of active intervention to take.

If you were 50/50 bonds and stocks, even if bonds did nothing in a crash of 30% on the stock market, your portfolio would lose 15%.

I've heard lots of stories about people being massacred but I always wonder what the real risk profile of their portfolio was. 100% stocks 3 years before retirement is just asking for trouble, and I wonder who might have been in a boat like that in 2007.
 
The most knowledgeable investors in the world rebalance according to the guidelines set out in their IPS (Investment Policy Statement) Normally, they set the threshold at 5% From the target allocation. They also maintain discipline regardless of bull or bear markets.


,

My IPS offers some ranges. For instance if I am really leary about shaky markets, I might rbalance to 45-50% stocks instead of 55%, and up cash to 10%. Without getting into all the guidelines that are there, there can be room to add a touch of added conservatism to ride out a storm.

Making a radical choice to completely sell off just opens you up to missing the recovery.
 
As an update, my so-called passive portfolio has just gotten a bit more active. One holding has been bought out by another company leaving me with a 17% loss over 1.5 years. Ugh.

Another holding I am selling off after less than six months for an annualized return of about 70%. It more than covers the first loss.

Am still regretting holding one of the biggest oil sands producer...should have sold a few months ago when I broke even. Good dividend but it's down by 7% from my entry point two years back.
 
As an update, my so-called passive portfolio has just gotten a bit more active. One holding has been bought out by another company leaving me with a 17% loss over 1.5 years. Ugh.

Another holding I am selling off after less than six months for an annualized return of about 70%. It more than covers the first loss.

Am still regretting holding one of the biggest oil sands producer...should have sold a few months ago when I broke even. Good dividend but it's down by 7% from my entry point two years back.

Are you down 7% from your original investment with or without factoring in the dividends?
 
Hello folks,

Has this Cyprus news shaken anyone's confidence? A little rebalancing? Buying op?

Thanks and happy trading!

Goodguy
 
Has this Cyprus news shaken anyone's confidence? A little rebalancing? Buying op?

No but I have to admit that as a passive portfolio/dumb money guy I don't/can't keep up with everything.

And I'll confess something...for well over a decade I've thought of Europe as an economic backwater. My attention has been focused on North America and Asia. In fact, Europe has only reappeared on my radar screen because of my Asian travels where I've noticed that a lot of the products are European designed if not European manufactured.