Question for the Military Buffs...

Keebler Elf

The Original Elf
Aug 31, 2001
14,846
507
113
The Keebler Factory
A Bridge Too Far is on History Channel right now and it got me thinking. What is the standard procedure for defending bridges that lie deep behind the frontlines, and which troops guard them? Are troops specially designated for bridge defense (a garrison) or is it troops from whichever units are in the area or is it something else?

If there are no immediate known threats to the bridge, do they defend it at all?

The bridges in the movie are obvious targets and so it's no surprise they were defended/fortified. But what about other bridges?
 
Keebler Elf said:
A Bridge Too Far is on History Channel right now and it got me thinking. What is the standard procedure for defending bridges that lie deep behind the frontlines, and which troops guard them? Are troops specially designated for bridge defense (a garrison) or is it troops from whichever units are in the area or is it something else?

If there are no immediate known threats to the bridge, do they defend it at all?

The bridges in the movie are obvious targets and so it's no surprise they were defended/fortified. But what about other bridges?

This link give some idea http://www.globalsecurity.org/military/library/policy/army/fm/7-10/appi.htm

It would depend greatly on the tactical situation, of course. Classically speaking (i.e. WWII and Cold War-style doctrine), if that bridge is the only way across, and it's on your main axis of advance, then you will make sure that you own it, and can destroy it before it gets into the hands of the enemy. That kind of thing can be done with special forces, airborne, etc, but they can only last a short time before you have to link up with them with a heavier force. Even if you don't specifically allocate troops to the bridge, its capture would always figure in any plans that require it.

On the offense, your troops want to use it to move forward, then you would use soldiers from your own forces to secure it while the main body rolls through.

If it's defensive, and you don't want anyone coming over, you set charges and be prepared to blow it up. See "Demolition Guard".

In "A Bridge Too Far" (or Operation Market Garden), the Germans weren't defending the bridges per se because they were so far inside their own territory. Commander-in-Chief West Model had ordered the II SS Panzer Corps, including the 9th SS and 10th SS Panzer divisions under the command of Lieutenant General Wilhelm Bittrich, to rest and refit in a "safe" area. The place chosen happened to be the area around Arnhem with the 9th SS scattered in various towns and villages to the north of the city and the 10th SS stationed 15 km (9 miles) further to the east.
 
Keebler Elf said:
If there are no immediate known threats to the bridge, do they defend it at all?

As Hangman points out, it depends on the tactical situation. If a bridge is only of use to the defenders (for linking up main forces) the the offense can take the bridge out to prevent this from happening. In classical warfare, this might involve special ops / airborne who operate behind the line. Modern warfare would likely use a guided missile.

If the bridge is on the main axis of attack for the offense, then everything Hangman said applies. WWII saw the birth of specialized bridge units - their function was to construct / repair bridges to get the main battle force across. In modern times its common to take a turret off a tank a put on a special folding bridge. If you line a few of these units up you get an instant bridge which can travel along with the main battle force, leaving the rear units to build more permanent structures if necessary.

Depending on the situation, an army unit may elect to resupply via airlifts instead of traditional land-based methods. This great reduces the need to have rear-guard units building bridges and stuff like that but greatly increases the need for air units to fly resupply missions (mostly via helicopter but sometimes via cargo aircraft if possible).

If you think about it, you start to understand why warfare is such an expensive endeavour.
 
So let's take the bridge at Arnhem in January 1944. D-Day hadn't happened and all eyes were on the coast of France.

Would Arnhem have been guarded by anything but a token force, if at all?

And my other original question, who guards the bridge? Does it have a dedicated garrison or are whatever units in the area responsible for its defense? What if there are no units in the area?

I'm not talking about when it's obvious the bridge is a prime and imminent target for the enemy. That's obvious. I'm talking about a bridge in what is thought to be a secure sector, away from the theatre of operations.
 
A bridge such as you describe, with no apparent or immediate tactical significance, would likely not have its own force defending it. If it were well behind your own front line, then its defence, like the rest of the rear area, is part of the larger responsibility of the defending force at the front line.

You wouldn't divert combat power defending something that has no apparent need for defence. Concentration of force is key to victory, so you wouldn't have your guys all over the map in the rear area. In a secure sector, forces are moving administratively (vs tactically) for speed and ease of command...they're not configured for combat anyway.
 
There would always be rear area security forces. In WW2 occupied Europe, they would be low-grade personnel mainly tasked with keeping the local Resistance under control. As mentioned, the bugger of MArket Garden was that an entire SS Panzerkorps was sent to the Arnhem area for R+R just before the drop.

Heavy, elite armoured troops should - and did - make chop suey out of light airborne forces. This is the major reason the op failed.
 
Keebler Elf said:
So let's take the bridge at Arnhem in January 1944. D-Day hadn't happened and all eyes were on the coast of France.

Would Arnhem have been guarded by anything but a token force, if at all?

Huh? Are you going to take every bridge in Europe 6 months before you need them? Why?!

Assuming you had the hundred or so parachute divisions to do this (instead of the four the Allies actually had in summer '44), and the thousands of planes to keep them supplied, the Germans would simply have diverted heavy strategic-reserve units to annihilating your airborne drops 1 by 1 long before your ground forces could land and support them.
 
Actually, and if someone has better intel they can correct me, but in every historical documentary I ever saw the germans had guards in place at all key elements. ie: bridges, rail yards, factories, air strips, everywhere. Just because the allies hadn't landed yet didn't mean there wasn't any threat.

The french resistance targeted just about everything of military importance.

Yes, there would be a dedicated "guard" unit to protect certain assets. They might be rotated in and out but it wouldn't be just who happened to be around at the time.
 
Tactical chock points such as bridges are ussually defended . The defence force would come from what ever unit was garrisoning the area the bridge was in. At least that is the NATO system. Other countries use different systems, soem places would have a dedicated defence force, that happened a lot in Germany during the cold war, all the bridges were set up to be destroyed and could be destroyed on a couple of days notice, sometimes sooner.

The bridge guard itself would depend on what type of unit was responsible it was usually infantry units with pioneer or engineer support if the bridge was set for demolition
 
The "French Resistance" was much more a propaganda invention and post-war fantasy than a reality. The resistances in the Nederlands, and Norway were more effective.
 
COMMANDER KIRK said:
The "French Resistance" was much more a propaganda invention and post-war fantasy than a reality. The resistances in the Nederlands, and Norway were more effective.

And your data comes from....what exactly? Your own personal views or facts?
 
Lots of reading. Churchills histories, DeGaulles biographies. Military after-action reports. Casulty and sabotage statistics per 100,00 population during occupation. Evidence of co-operation with occupying forces. Vichy government.......
 
Depends on your perspective of "effective". I would think that per 100,000 population, the French Resistance disabled less tanks, blew up less Nazi stuff etc. But on the other hand, they probably helped more POWs escape.

Back to the original topic, after the famous "Dam Busters" raid by 617 squadron, the Nazis significantly upgraded security around major possible targets such as dams, bridges, research facilities etc. In the end it obviously didn't do them any good but they did make an effort to guard certain choice targets more carefully.
 
Of course, Arnhem is in Netherlands, not France.

What Bridge Too Far doesn't mention is the German reprisal against the Dutch people. In late 1944, as punishment for the effectiveness of the Dutch Resistance in helping the Market Garden operation, the Germans refused to distribute food to the Dutch population, leading to a really effective famine, which caused many deaths.
 
If it's a strategic bridge, wouldn't they have anti-aircraft for air attacks, and the crew to man those guns?

As for which bridge to defend and which will be attacked, those are decided in the strategy rooms of both camps. Short of spies, neither side can really predict what will happen.

Always a fog of war as well.
 
If there is no threats identified to a given bridge, chances are that it will not be defended. In a war situation, this is unlikely. However, there are literally thousands of bridges and it is practically impossible to defend them all. Choices are made about the importance of a given bridge (and other potential targets). In the rear of the battle space, those choices are generally associated with logistical requirements. A bridge that constitutes a significant source of supplies, or an important means of escape, will probably have some troops assigned for security.

In the case of occupied territory, like France and the Netherlands in WWII, security would fall on occupation forces. These would be second-rate units mostly and relatively lightly armed in general. If the bridge is deemed important, it will likely have a light anti-aircraft unit deployed around it as well. Overall, the total force will not amount to more than a couple hundred men and that is assuming an AA battery is deployed. Notice that at any given time of a given day, the number of troops on guard will be in the tens.

The size of these forces will be small because they are not expected to be more than a tripwire. If something happens that is beyond their ability to manage, it is expected that they will call for help. That will trigger a response of whatever local forces are available which is likely to be the unit from which the bridge guards are drawn from. It is likely that the scale of these forces will be sufficient to make any battle against irregulars, like resistance forces, incredibly uneven. Against a military force, it will depend on the situation.

Since the size of the defending forces is relatively tiny, I suppose it might raise the question of why the enemy would deploy divisional sized forces to capture these assets. If you think about it a bit, it makes a lot of sense. To secure the bridge in the first place, you want overwhelming force so that there is little or not opportunity for the defenders to do something like blow up the bridge or alert anyone. This might buy you a couple of hours. After that, you can expect larger forces to be deployed to recapture the bridge. Depending on the efficiency of the local units, you might be facing substantial forces in a matter of a few more hours. Holding out then depends on the ability to resist those forces until relieved.

At Arnhem I think the Allied force was expected to hold out for up to two days. That's a really long time when you have no new supplies arriving and the enemy not only surrounds you but is capable of calling on ever increasing forces (drawn from the higher chain of command) to defeat you. As a few people have noted, Arnhem is a special case because the area happened to be chosen to rest and refit two Waffen SS combat divisions that had been fighting on the Eastern Front. I doubt the Allied command would have attempted the operation as it did being aware of this situation. One paratroop division is not likely to be able to hold out against two mechanized divisions for 48 hours.
 
Good points Boot, but during WWII there were certain rivers where there weren't thousands of bridges, I forget which river it was but there were only 4 that could handle the load of military vehicles so they were extremely valuable for advance or retreat.
 
tboy said:
And your data comes from....what exactly? Your own personal views or facts?
My readings agree with Kirk's. The French resistance was made up mostly of fringe groups like the anarchists and communists. So much was made of a small amount of resistance to try and erase the story of the quick defeat and Vichy collaboration (a huge number of French bureaucrats and public servants post-war held essentially the same position under Nazi/Vichy leadership).


I believe the book Post-War has a fair bit of information about this.
 
While they may not have stationed permanent guards at many bridges, I believe they tried to put the troops "on R&R" in locations where they could be quickly called into service to defend things - as what happened in Marketgarden.
 
basketcase said:
My readings agree with Kirk's. The French resistance was made up mostly of fringe groups like the anarchists and communists. So much was made of a small amount of resistance to try and erase the story of the quick defeat and Vichy collaboration (a huge number of French bureaucrats and public servants post-war held essentially the same position under Nazi/Vichy leadership).


I believe the book Post-War has a fair bit of information about this.

Yeah, I guess I shouldn't have classified the resistance as french, I should have just said "the resistance" because there were dutch, russian, polish, etc. Plus you had allied "spies" dropped behind enemy lines as well.

But if the french resistance didn't do "much", why did the brits drop "tons" of high explosives to them? Kind of a contradiction in history if both are true....