Question about trespassing

McGib

Well-known member
Jun 9, 2009
761
1,048
93
I visited an store for the second time this week that I use to work at. The first visit I chatted with former co-workers and talked about my new job. This evening I went back to pick up some paperwork and was confronted by store security and was told I had been banned from the store because a comment I made on the first visit was unwelcome.

Can a retailer ban someone from their store because they dont like an opinion voiced by that person?
 
i was a bouncer at a bar and it was standard practice that a person that got fired was banned for 6 months. legal or not i couldn't tell you.
 
I visited an store for the second time this week that I use to work at. The first visit I chatted with former co-workers and talked about my new job. This evening I went back to pick up some paperwork and was confronted by store security and was told I had been banned from the store because a comment I made on the first visit was unwelcome.

Can a retailer ban someone from their store because they dont like an opinion voiced by that person?

Not sure what country you are in, but in the states a business can ban you for whatever reason they deem fit.
 
Can a retailer ban someone from their store because they dont like an opinion voiced by that person?
No. While stores are private property, they are open to the public and a retailer has to be careful about how he (or she) limits access. For example, I think we'd all agree that it would be a crime to ban someone from your store because they were white (or black, or asian). Similarly, you can't ban someone from your store because of their sexual orientation. Similarly, you can't exclude people because they don't agree with you on some opinion or other.

But don't get me wrong, you were banned legitimately. The retailer told you that you had made an unwelcome comment, not that he disagreed with what you said. Likely someone was offended by something you said (or at least that's the claim). Offending staff or other customers is valid grounds for removing you and banning you from the place.

Next time you get a new job, don't try so hard to rub it in the faces of your previous employer.
 
Thats just it, I dont know what I said that caused offense.
That's another matter. You asked if you can banned and the answer is "yes" if you are guilty (or accused) of causing offence. As the what you said...only you and the staff at the store know.

If you didn't actually offend them, I'm sure your friends will tell you the inside story...but you'll have to see them outside of work. If they won't meet you, then you have confirmed you've pissed them off.
 
No, they can't. Police officers only write trespass tickets it is a serious criminal offense or a court order by a judge (ie occupy toronto judge told police to evict). Trespass to property act is used in conjunction with the criminal code of canada, to keep legimate people from returning.

Anything else, it just bs. He has a store open to the public, you are a member of the public and you can enter. He's just trying to scare you that's all.
 
I doubt I offended the staff, more likely I offended the manager.
Thanks for the answer BS
 
The owner or the person under his authority ie. his employees has the right to remove you from the property. They can use no more force than necessary for this task ie. reasonable force. Should you resist the attempt to remove you, then you commit assault. They really don't need a reason to have you removed as it is their property.
 
The owner or the person under his authority ie. his employees has the right to remove you from the property. They can use no more force than necessary for this task ie. reasonable force. Should you resist the attempt to remove you, then you commit assault. They really don't need a reason to have you removed as it is their property.
I think this is correct. A store is not public property.

Banning someone on a prohibited basis (sexual orientation, age, sex ) might give you reason to have someone charged with something under human rights...but would not necessarily get you back into the store.
 
You're not really just any j-random member of the public. You are a former employee. They can likely choose to ban you, saying that your presence harms the morale of their staff, or some such.
 
They really don't need a reason to have you removed as it is their property.

Not entirely true. As someone pointed out, stores that are open to the public can't arbitrarily exclude someone for reasons that violate the human rights code.

However in his case I don't think that will help. He's a former employee and there's no doubt some history there.
 
I think I said that the new job payed a great deal more(which it does) than the old job. I dont recall the exact details, but thats the only thing I can think of that management might have taken offense too.
 
No idea, security just told me I was banned and to leave. I think he said paperwork was being done. I was rather shocked so I wasnt really listening to him
 
In fact, trespass is based on you being able to prove that you have a right to be there.

From the Tresspass to Property Act:
2. (1) Every person who is not acting under a right or authority conferred by law and who,

(a) without the express permission of the occupier, the proof of which rests on the defendant,

(i) enters on premises when entry is prohibited under this Act, or

(ii) engages in an activity on premises when the activity is prohibited under this Act; or

(b) does not leave the premises immediately after he or she is directed to do so by the occupier of the premises or a person authorized by the occupier,

is guilty of an offence and on conviction is liable to a fine of not more than $2,000.
Which basically says that they don't need a reason.
 
I think I said that the new job payed a great deal more(which it does) than the old job. I dont recall the exact details, but thats the only thing I can think of that management might have taken offense too.

Sounds like you have given them a very good reason to ban you from the store:

-- You are trying to persuade their employees to quit, and

-- You are making their employees feel bad about their job

I'd ban you too. They don't need paperwork to ban you. They just tell you to GTFO of their store, and you have to go. You can't really come around someone's business and try and poach away their staff and expect to be allowed to continue doing that.
 
Which basically says that they don't need a reason.

Generally that's true, but again, that's not absolute. If you tell everyone who is black to get out of your store you will find out that the Human Rights Code does have some teeth. You can kick someone out of your store for MOST reasons, but not EVERY reason. If it can be shown that you are discriminating based on a protected factor you will get into hot water. However you surely can kick someone out for trying to persuade your employees to quit!!!!!!!!
 
There are ways around it

If you are gay, non white or some other protected class, claim that the reason you were banned is on one of those grounds. It doesn't have to be true, you got rights dammit

Claim your presence at the store is part of a political protest. Pretend to be pissed about the last elections in Papua New Guinea. Or fight for medical prostitution in Canada. Make some demands and tell them you won't leave until you get your way. Fuck democracy, people who vote don't count if they don't agree with you.

If you are a member of the master race, just make a land claim. Hell if you got a land claim you can pretty much take over the business and do whatever you want.


Laws, rules, a Jedi needs not these things.