Question about size and fights. Need advice.

stinkynuts

Super
Jan 4, 2005
8,939
3,220
113
Would a 5'4", 140 pound person, with martial arts training, be able to beat up someone 5"8" with a fairly large build (and presumably no training)?

What are the limits of speed and skill overcoming sheer size?

The reason I ask is because I was involved in an ugly incident today. I was on my way home on the ttc and this asshole started a fight with me. He had spit on the floor of the train. I wasn't paying attention when he did that, so I didn't know he did it.

All of a sudden he yells at me and points to the spit and mutters something. I'm like "huh?" I thought he was accusing me of spitting on the floor, so I told him "It wasn't me." He then continues badgering me about the spit, and so I continue to deny it, saying "Why would I do that?" He then gets frustrated, and says "You speak English? I'm saying *I* spit on the floor, and you were looking at me. What are you going to do about it?" I wasn't looking at him at all, so I am getting pissed at his rudeness. I tell him that he's crazy, and he says, "I'm gonna put your face in it (the spit)."

At this point I get up to get off, and says, "Nah, I can't fight you. You're like a midget." At that point I wanted to put my fist through his face. But I knew I'd get my ass kicked. So I just got off. But I was so pissed at myself for not being able to stand up for myself. I know that size isn't all that matters. Mike Tyson was able to beat up people much larger than him, so was Bruce Lee. But this guy was relatively stocky, and a good four inches taller than me.

If I knew karate, would I have been able to kick his ass? If yes, I will take lessons so I never have to go through this again. If no, I guess I'll have to learn to take shit from those bigger than me.
 
I think I read this in an ad on the back of a comic book.
Is your name Charles Atlas?
 
Last edited:
stinkynuts said:
Would a 5'4", 140 pound person, with martial arts training, be able to beat up someone 5"8" with a fairly large build (and presumably no training)?

What are the limits of speed and skill overcoming sheer size?

The reason I ask is because I was involved in an ugly incident today. I was on my way home on the ttc and this asshole started a fight with me. He had spit on the floor of the train. I wasn't paying attention when he did that, so I didn't know he did it.

All of a sudden he yells at me and points to the spit and mutters something. I'm like "huh?" I thought he was accusing me of spitting on the floor, so I told him "It wasn't me." He then continues badgering me about the spit, and so I continue to deny it, saying "Why would I do that?" He then gets frustrated, and says "You speak English? I'm saying *I* spit on the floor, and you were looking at me. What are you going to do about it?" I wasn't looking at him at all, so I am getting pissed at his rudeness. I tell him that he's crazy, and he says, "I'm gonna put your face in it (the spit)."

At this point I get to up get off, and says, "Nah, I can't fight you. You're like a midget." At that point I wanted to put my fist through his face. But I knew I'd get my ass kicked. So I just got off. But I was so pissed at myself for not being able to stand up for myself. I know that size isn't all that matters. Mike Tyson was able to beat up people much larger than him, so was Bruce Lee. But this guy was relatively stocky, and a good four inches taller than me.

If I knew karate, would I have been able to kick his ass? If yes, I will take lessons so I never have to go through this again. If no, I guess I'll have to learn with taking shit from those bigger than me.
Should have pulled out your trusty piece and put a cap in his ass. :eek:
 
I'm small and got into quite a few scraps in elementary and high school with guys up to twice my size. Now, aside from just being more cautious (a few bad experiences would do that to you), I just feel sorry for bullies and a**holes. And besides, these days you never know who's packing. I'd avoid fighting at all costs unless absolutely necessary (immediate danger, protecting someone, fighting for your country, etc). Learn self defence for those instances and not to be able to kick the crap out of someone. I think Jeet Kune Do and/or Wing Chung is well suited for smaller people. Power moves, like strikes in Karate, won't work on guys twice your size however deflecting and neutralizing their power will. And always remember that martial arts has it's limits. Your antagonist may know martial arts too and/or have a gun and/or lots of friends.
 
That's an unfortunate incident, guy sounds like a real prick. Size is definitely a factor when you are trying to match muscle to muscle but technique will get you much further. Kind of sounds like sex doesn't it? Anyway, a well-placed slug to the jaw will drop most people regardless of size. But careful, if you miss, you might find yourself in a heap of trouble.

Although you feel like crap right now, you did the right thing walking away. The guy obviously had issues and was looking for an excuse to fight; better to leave him in his own demented world. How would you feel if you did confront him and he kicked your ass? You'd feel a lot worse than you do now. Of course you would feel great if you kicked his ass, but is it worth it over something so trivial? Save your uppercuts and reverse-roundhouse kicks for something worth fighting for. Go see an SP and be happy!
 
Your training to become a student (after receiving black belt) may not be enough in martial arts. Attackers/defenders don't stand still for you to land your blows. In a real fight, the attacker and defender isn't going to stand still. When you are attacking or defending do you think what moves you gonna use or do you subconsciously react without need to think? How's your stamina? If you can't last long, then you better hope those first few strike counts. If you really want to know if you can win, then get a buddy whose bigger than you with punching mitts and hear gears to have a fight in the basement.
 
Getting into a fight on the ttc could be a real mess, with older people and kids around some innocent person could get badly hurt. It would have felt great to drop the guy, but walking away would be the safest thing to do for your own benefit, and the most considerate thing to do for those around you.

Training can make a difference in a fight, especially in being able to protect yourself. Just being in shape would help a lot. Maybe knowing you could fight would make it easier to walk away.
 
IMHO size does not matter. I've been a fan of the UFC for years and have seen many smaller fighters with martial arts backgrounds take down bigger opponents with with martial arts backgrounds that rely only on their girth. But I agree with what others have already said in that you did the right thing by walking away. You never know who is packing these days. :(
 
Would you consider it worth your time and effort to practice martial arts 3 times a week for several years just so that you could kick ass when you need to? Personally, I wouldn't. Walking away from that kind of situation is not easy on the ego, but many people do it rather than fight. A bruised ego is better than a bruised face or a bullet in the brain.

Have you considered weight training in order to gain muscular bodyweight so that you look less like a victim? It could help you attract girls, as well.

Having said all that, If that had happened to me, I would have kicked his ass or died trying, but I'm stupid like that!
 
Actually, you guys are right...

If I did know karate I would have probably gotten into a fight with him. Who knows what would have happened then. I could have a serious injury, lost some of my teeth, or even gotten killed. All to put some jerk in his place.

But I guess for self-defence, and only self-defence, it would be useful.
 
A few more things to think about if you are intent on fighting:

Things that make a good street fighter reagardless of skill or size:

- not being afraid of getting hurt
- not being afraid of hurting your opponent
- not being afraid of being arrested or convicted of assault
- not being afraid of being sued for causing bodily harm to your opponent

Now, how do you feel about fighting?
 
If you do chose to practice MA, I would recommend Judo, jui-jitsu or Aikido, which are more defensive, and you could use it to restrain attackers rather than hurt them.

There's less chance of getting arrested for assualt if you just throw someone to the ground or put them in an arm lock than if you punch them in the face, or do a flying kick!
 
Size matters if you intend to wrestle or subdue someone. However, if a well placed punch or kick is inititiated, you can end a contest early. Whether you are 140 lbs. or less, a solid blow can break the skin and bones of anyone bigger than you. The nose and teeth break the same no matter how big you are if struck in a solid manner. The trick is not to get hit first and to make sure that your shot connects on target. Follow up by disabling your apponent to discourage them from further retaliation. You must also know when to stop.
A smaller person losing a fight will suffer less shame than if the bigger person gets taken out in such a mis-match.
I'm not condoning violence in any situation, but if you need to defend yourself, be quick and decisive.
 
punter said:
A few more things to think about if you are intent on fighting:

Things that make a good street fighter reagardless of skill or size:

- not being afraid of getting hurt
- not being afraid of hurting your opponent...
QUOTE]


This is true, you can practice in a gym all you want, but in the end it has to be inside you. You must have a phislosphy that these things are "worth it " in some cases. Practical experience counts for more, but don't ever underestimate hate and will.
 
Don't think it would have been worth getting in a fight with a guy over something so petty. I think fighting is for defending yourself or helping out someone else.
 
stinkynuts said:
Would a 5'4", 140 pound person, with martial arts training, be able to beat up someone 5"8" with a fairly large build (and presumably no training)?

What are the limits of speed and skill overcoming sheer size?

The reason I ask is because I was involved in an ugly incident today. I was on my way home on the ttc and this asshole started a fight with me. He had spit on the floor of the train. I wasn't paying attention when he did that, so I didn't know he did it.

All of a sudden he yells at me and points to the spit and mutters something. I'm like "huh?" I thought he was accusing me of spitting on the floor, so I told him "It wasn't me." He then continues badgering me about the spit, and so I continue to deny it, saying "Why would I do that?" He then gets frustrated, and says "You speak English? I'm saying *I* spit on the floor, and you were looking at me. What are you going to do about it?" I wasn't looking at him at all, so I am getting pissed at his rudeness. I tell him that he's crazy, and he says, "I'm gonna put your face in it (the spit)."

At this point I get up to get off, and says, "Nah, I can't fight you. You're like a midget." At that point I wanted to put my fist through his face. But I knew I'd get my ass kicked. So I just got off. But I was so pissed at myself for not being able to stand up for myself. I know that size isn't all that matters. Mike Tyson was able to beat up people much larger than him, so was Bruce Lee. But this guy was relatively stocky, and a good four inches taller than me.

If I knew karate, would I have been able to kick his ass? If yes, I will take lessons so I never have to go through this again. If no, I guess I'll have to learn to take shit from those bigger than me.


Stinkynuts, i think you did the right thing man. There is no need to get into a fight with someone like that, over something stupid, dont waste your time. Its the subway, you get all kinds of rude, weird ppl. Like someone said earlier, these days you never know who has a gun or whatever else they might carry on them. No need to risk your life over something stupid like that. If you really want, join the army or something.;)

I know how you feel, but when you really think about it, you walking away was a good thing. Sooner or later, he is going to get his, what goes around comes around. No matter how big or tough you are there is always someone bigger and tougher, you cant win them all.
 
punter said:
A few more things to think about if you are intent on fighting:


- not being afraid of being sued for causing bodily harm to your opponent

?

LOL! Havent had to worry about that for a long time! No ethical lawyer would lie to his client by telling him he'd ever collect even 2% of his judgement from me! And an unethical one would insist on full payment up front and a huge retainer for enforcment action.
 
Hard Idle said:
LOL! Havent had to worry about that for a long time! No ethical lawyer would lie to his client by telling him he'd ever collect even 2% of his judgement from me! And an unethical one would insist on full payment up front and a huge retainer for enforcment action.

Hard Idle,

Are you a lawyer?

Are you saying that it is almost impossible to be sued for kicking someone's ass?

What if I break his arm or neck and he can't work?

Not that I would do that :)
 
punter said:
A few more things to think about if you are intent on fighting:

Things that make a good street fighter reagardless of skill or size:

- not being afraid of getting hurt
- not being afraid of hurting your opponent
- not being afraid of being arrested or convicted of assault
- not being afraid of being sued for causing bodily harm to your opponent

Now, how do you feel about fighting?

First off, let me say that you did the right thing by walking away.....sometimes turning the other cheek is the best action to take...Unfortunately there are instances where you can't and don't have that option.

The second point made above is IMHO THE most important aspect of fighting...

Let me tell you a little story:

I grew up on the wrong side of the tracks and being small (5-8 150) I was always ending up on the short end of the stick (I have the scars to proove it too).

One day I was up north at a friend's farm and while out in the back 40, some rejects came by and messed with my motorcycle, (pulled off all the hoses, drained the gas tank, pushed it over etc). I was pissed.

Funny thing was the idiots came back! So we get into a screaming match (there's 4 of them, 3 bigger than me 1 smaller) As they are getting into their car the driver yells that they will do this every time they see my bike...So I pick up a rock about the size of a softball and put it through his back window...

Well out come the other three....here's the result:
1) Smaller guy ends up in the hospital with a ruptured testicle, I nailed him as he was rushing me
2) Driver ends up in the hospital with a broken arm, I slammed him into the barn door as he was rushing me
3) 3rd guy ends up with a broken nose and missing 2 teeth from where my helmet hit him
4) 4th guy was able to push me down and got one kick in before my friend pulled him off...

You see, that day I was so pissed and sick of getting pushed around I realized that there is no "play fighting". I used to not take it seriously that is why I ended up bruised and battered.

Now? If I fight, I fight to win, period. Twice since then I've been in tussles and I say outright, you want to get into it? Do you REALLY want to get into it? If you do, ONE of us is going to the morgue because I won't stop coming....EVER

When fighting a larger or multiple opponents you may only get one chance and when that chance presents itself, you have to have the will to use it. To be able to put him down, permanantly if possible.

Again, discretion is the better part of valor....avoiding a conflict is always the best route but if you can't? And have to get into it? Then do so with extreme prejudice and use whatever you can to put him down....you'd be surprized how fast the wind goes out of a guy's sails, no matter how big he is, when he has a pencil sticking out of his eye....