Question about probability riddle: doesn't make sense

I still can't for some reason can't wrap my head around the following logic, that I perceive to be correct:

There are two frogs
One croaked, so it is male
We don't know the sex of the second one
The second one can be either male or female
So the probability that there will be a female among the pair of frogs is 50%


In this case I don't think that it matters if the frog on the left or right croaked
The probability that the other frog is female is still 50%

If the frog on the right croaked, then the probability that the frog on the left is female is 50%
If the frog on the left croaked, then the probability that the frog on the right is female is 50%

No matter which case, it is still 50%.

I agree

As long as he gets to lick both frogs, which he does

Conditional probability and sample space is voodoo math in this case


they say 4 probabilities exist

MF

MM

FM

FF

as both cannot be female that leaves 3 possibilities and in two of these one is female

I say MF and FM is same possibility

 
Let do this - say there are 100 lottery tickets and one is a winner. You pick one at random. It could be right. Then Mr X gets ride of 98 losers and says your ticket or the one left is the winner do you want to swtich?
Is it more likely you picket the right ticket at the start OR the one choice he gave you is the right choice? OR is it a 50 50 chance?

The chance of you being right in the first place was 1 in 100, the remaining group of tickets represented 99% chance. In effect you get to pick all 99 tickets but your ignore the wrong ones.
 
Let do this - say there are 100 lottery tickets and one is a winner. You pick one at random. It could be right. Then Mr X gets ride of 98 losers and says your ticket or the one left is the winner do you want to swtich?
Is it more likely you picket the right ticket at the start OR the one choice he gave you is the right choice? OR is it a 50 50 chance?

The chance of you being right in the first place was 1 in 100, the remaining group of tickets represented 99% chance. In effect you get to pick all 99 tickets but your ignore the wrong ones.

That doesn't seem analogous at all.

Absolutely I'd switch tickets. You had a 1 in 100 chance of picking the right ticket to begin with...chances are you picked a loser. But after Mr X eliminates 98 losers, you know with 100% certainty that the winner is either your ticket or the one outstanding ticket (Mr. X has knowledge you don't). Since you only had a 1 in 100 shot at picking the winner originally, chances are it's the other ticket.

People keep comparing this riddle to the Monty Hall problem. It's not the same. There is no third party with additional knowledge to rule out options.

I'm willing to accept I may be wrong, but I still believe the answer to the OP's riddle is still 50/50 either way.
 
Flip 2 coins simultaneously - reflip if you get 2 tails. Then record how many times you got one head, one tail and how many times you got 2 heads. By the time you've recorded 100 events you should see the 2/3 - 1/3 pattern develop.

I was thinking the same thing

coin flips should solve this problem


Heads means male frog

Tails means female frog

If you flip two tails it does not count because we need at least one male


The rest of the flips where you have at least one head (male frog) the other coin should be tails (female frog) 2/3 of the time


Correct?

I am going to try

be right back
 
That doesn't seem analogous at all.

Absolutely I'd switch tickets. You had a 1 in 100 chance of picking the right ticket to begin with...chances are you picked a loser. But after Mr X eliminates 98 losers, you know with 100% certainty that the winner is either your ticket or the one outstanding ticket (Mr. X has knowledge you don't). Since you only had a 1 in 100 shot at picking the winner originally, chances are it's the other ticket.

People keep comparing this riddle to the Monty Hall problem. It's not the same. There is no third party with additional knowledge to rule out options.

I'm willing to accept I may be wrong, but I still believe the answer to the OP's riddle is still 50/50 either way.

I am glad you see the value of switching. Ture its not directly analogous because of for knowledge. But we can make it by just having my Haul elimite one ticket at a time at random. Then he gets down to one last ticke at yours (crazy chance that could happen) - it does not chance the fact that there was only 1 in 100 chance that you where right and all the other tickets as a group had a 99% of being in that group.
Even if Haul Know where the ticket was, as long as he was required to make this offer each and every time (so his knowledge does not change the outcome) most of the time the winning ticket would be in the second group. In fact, in the case of the frogs and the ticket your never get to this stage as 1/3 or 98% of the time the right frog will be revealed.
Stage one: some of the time you lost, game over, if you do not lose go to stage two
Stage two: you did not lose do you want your ticket /frog or the other ticket/frog.
 
after 100 flips (see post 64)


female/female frogs (which does not count ) = 24

other frog being male frog = 25

other frog being female = 51

The reason is M/F and F/M are separate possibilities independent of each other which doubles the chance of it being female


Flip coins and the reasoning becomes clear

I was wrong in post 61

spock_fascinating.jpg
 
You go to the side with two frogs because you know that one of them is a guy, and it must be fucking another frog (which has to be a female).

This is how you get laid.

P(1 female | at least 1 male in 2 frogs) = P( 1 female and 1 male) / P( at least 1 male in 2 frogs)

P(1 female and 1 male ) = 1/2

P(at least 1 male in 2 frogs) = 3/4

So, P(1 female | 1 male in 2 frogs) = 2/3 = 66.6666666666666666666666666666666666666% ~ 67%
 
You can try this yourself in a pub.

Get a friend to flip two coins behind a screen. You get to pick heads or tails. If he has not got the coin you guessed it's a bye, and you play again.

If he has the coin you guessed, he slides it over to you, keeping the remaining coin secret. Now you have to guess that coin and if you guess right he buys the next round. If you guess wrong, you buy the round.

If you bet the second coin is the opposite of the first one, you win the bet 2/3rds of the time and wind up paying for only a third of the drinks.

It's really going to work.

A flip of the coin is a disticnt 50/50 each time. Any particular coin flip is independent of any other. However if you had one special coin out of three and did not know where it was (3 places) the odds are 2 in 3 it will be with the two coins,

Anyway tests have shown it works as crazy as it sounds.
 
I came across a video on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cpwSGsb-rTs

The riddle is essentially this:

You are in the forest and about to die from a disease. The only thing that can save you is if you lick the female species of a frog. Unfortunately, the only way to tell males and females apart is that males croak.

You see a frog on side A, and on side B there are two frogs. You only have time to reach one side. Suddenly, one of the two frogs on side A croaks, so you know it is male, and not going to save you.

You are feeling very sick. Hurry! Which side would you go to??


My logic is very simple. It makes no difference. On side B, the chances are 50/50 that the sole frog is male/female. On side A, one is male for sure. The other frog is 50/50 male or female.

So it should make absolutely no difference. But they came up with a very weird explanation in the video.

I'm not sure the video is right, and would like to know if there are any math experts who can clarify.

Why aren't the odds the same?? It should make no difference that one of the frogs is male. The other still has a 50/50 chance of being male or female. Just like the sole frog on the other side.
Before hearing the croak the probable combination outcomes are MM, MF, FM and FF if each side has 2 frogs. But you hear a croak on side A so that eliminates the possibility of FF. Therefore there is only a 2/3 probability that the remaining frog is female. Whereas on side B there is a 3/4 probability that one of the frogs is female because all outcomes are still in play.
 
op is right the explanation on video is wrong. they are counting 3 possibilities on the 2 frog side.

M/F
M/M
F/M

thats BS. reason is if the solution was a male and a female frog, then which possibility was right out of the 3? Was it the M/F or the F/M? so dumb. its 50/50 on that side not 2/3...
 
From the sample space, he should also eliminate one of the (male-female), since (male-Female) is same as (Female-male).

by doing that you only have two choices left , which is still 50%.

Exactly! The probability that the second frog is a female is the same as if the frog on the stump was female.

If we didn't know that one of the frogs was male then the probability would be 75%.
 
The bit your are missing is that on the two frog side you get to lick BOTH frogs.

Without the croak the two frog side had a 75% chance of containing at least one female. The croak lowered the chances to 67%.

Exactly! The probability that the second frog is a female is the same as if the frog on the stump was female.

If we didn't know that one of the frogs was male then the probability would be 75%.


That is not correct. To asses your probability, of getting a female, you would need to know the exact population of frogs in the forest by gender. The one frog on side A is a male for sure because it croaked. The frogs on side B could be 2 males that did not croak, 1 male that did not croak and 1 female, or 2 females. In summary all 3 could be males, one croaker and 2 non -croakers The fact that a total of 2 did not croak means nothing in determining your odds of getting a female other than your are certain the one is not female. Your odds of getting a female are male population - 1 to total female population.

Of course you would pick a side B frog because you know the one on A is male . Depending on the population the advantage might be insignificant.
 
Everything I ever learned I learned from movies. Theory of variable change. The Monty Hall Problem from the Movie 21. After the first frog dies the probability changes. Always account for variable change, and say Thank You!
 
I believe that this is the final solution to this strange problem.

The way the question is stated, one of the two frogs croaks. What is the probability that one of them is female? The answer is 50%. This is because we know for a fact that the one that croaked is a male, so we can disregard it. The other one that did not croak has a 50/50 chance of being male/female. The sample space is:

Croakiing Frog (Male) Non Croaking Frog (Male)
Croaking Frong (Male) Non Croaking Frog (Female)

As you can see, the odds that one of the two frogs is female is 50/50. Either the non croaking frog is male or female, there's a 50/50 chance.



However, had the questions simply stated that one of the two frogs was male, then we cannot disregard either frog as we did in the first case. The first frog could be female, or the second frog could be, we don't know.

In this case, the sample space is:
MF
FM
MM

So the odd are 2/3 that one is female.

This seems to be the universal consensus on this riddle. Very interesting how such a small detail can change the outcome of the results.

The author of the riddle simply assumed that saying that one frog croaked was the same as saying that there was one male, since only males croak. The seems to be in line with common sense, but it is not.
 
I believe that this is the final solution to this strange problem.

The way the question is stated, one of the two frogs croaks. What is the probability that one of them is female? The answer is 50%. This is because we know for a fact that the one that croaked is a male, so we can disregard it. The other one that did not croak has a 50/50 chance of being male/female. The sample space is:

Croakiing Frog (Male) Non Croaking Frog (Male)
Croaking Frong (Male) Non Croaking Frog (Female)

As you can see, the odds that one of the two frogs is female is 50/50. Either the non croaking frog is male or female, there's a 50/50 chance.



However, had the questions simply stated that one of the two frogs was male, then we cannot disregard either frog as we did in the first case. The first frog could be female, or the second frog could be, we don't know.

In this case, the sample space is:
MF
FM
MM

So the odd are 2/3 that one is female.

This seems to be the universal consensus on this riddle. Very interesting how such a small detail can change the outcome of the results.

The author of the riddle simply assumed that saying that one frog croaked was the same as saying that there was one male, since only males croak. The seems to be in line with common sense, but it is not.

Incorrect. You need to know the population of frogs by gender to determine your odds.

There is not necessarily a 50/50 chance of a non croaker being female if most of the population is male. If the overall population is fairly equal by gender is the only time the chances are 50/50.
 
Incorrect. You need to know the population of frogs by gender to determine your odds.

There is not necessarily a 50/50 chance of a non croaker being female if most of the population is male. If the overall population is fairly equal by gender is the only time the chances are 50/50.

I believe that in the video they say that the population is 50/50 male/female.
 
I can't believe anyone is still discussing this flawed riddle
The guy who made the video is wrong
Period
Move along
These aren't the droids you are looking for
 
Lol

yes i did not even watch it - just familiar with the concept.