question about murder

Yoga Face

New member
Jun 30, 2009
6,307
19
0
can someone admit murder but be found innocent if he can talk the jury into accepting his reason for killing?


I am not talking self defence but if you kill for any other reason (political, societal, religious etc)


the same question for any crime

what if you stole from the rich and gave to the poor ? for example


what if you are charged with running a bawdy house and insist on a jury tral and simply say the law is wrong and convince the jury of your argument?


dealing drugs is another one
 
From a legal perspective the answer may be no. But in reality a jury can do what they want. If they want to find someone "not guilty" no matter how obvious guilt is or even if they take into account things the judge directed them to ignore, etc and there's nothing that anyone can do about that. Jury duty is the only true form of democracy our society has.
 
From a legal perspective the answer may be no. But in reality a jury can do what they want. If they want to find someone "not guilty" no matter how obvious guilt is or even if they take into account things the judge directed them to ignore, etc and there's nothing that anyone can do about that. Jury duty is the only true form of democracy our society has.

can the judge declare mistrial?


what if a Muslim terrorist filled the jury with Muslim extremists?


i would like to think he would not walk after admitting guilt
 
A judge can set aside a verdict if he feels the jury erred in some way..but very seldom is that the case...
Reasonable doubt..... put that notion in some jurors head and anything is possible
The law isn't black and white....
if it was there would be a lot of unemployed lawyers...LOL
 
A judge can set aside a verdict if he feels the jury erred in some way..but very seldom is that the case...
Reasonable doubt..... put that notion in some jurors head and anything is possible
The law isn't black and white....
if it was there would be a lot of unemployed lawyers...LOL

no resonable doubt here


the charged admit they did it but get the jury to accept his rationale in commiting the crime
 
can someone admit murder but be found innocent if he can talk the jury into accepting his reason for killing?


I am not talking self defence but if you kill for any other reason (political, societal, religious etc)


the same question for any crime

what if you stole from the rich and gave to the poor ? for example


what if you are charged with running a bawdy house and insist on a jury tral and simply say the law is wrong and convince the jury of your argument?


dealing drugs is another one

I don't remember the name but it's happened in Toronto. A few years back some young black dude from Jane Finch shit a bad black dude.
The black dude who was shot was a bad ass. He made no bones that he was going to kill the guy charged with murder. The guy said he needed to "kill or be killed". The Judge bought it.
 
no resonable doubt here


the charged admit they did it but get the jury to accept his rationale in commiting the crime

Justifiable homicide....I believe is the term
a woman get beat and raped by her husband...regularly ...one night she decides she's had enough...
Kills him...she argues sooner of later he would have killed her...she was genuinely in fear of her life....jury buys it...
she's Free to go....battered wife syndrome....
 
I don't remember the name but it's happened in Toronto. A few years back some young black dude from Jane Finch shit a bad black dude.
The black dude who was shot was a bad ass. He made no bones that he was going to kill the guy charged with murder. The guy said he needed to "kill or be killed". The Judge bought it.

in that case it was considered self defence

i am not taking self defence

commiting a crime because you feel justified such as killing a mob boss or a political leader
 
in that case it was considered self defence

i am not taking self defence

commiting a crime because you feel justified such as killing a mob boss or a political leader


You mean like a vigilante? Take your meds son. A lilly white boy in mommy's basement can't go hunting with animals. Just saying.
Animals kill animals . If you try to mess around in that world you won't have to worry about a Judge and Jury.
 
Justifiable homicide....I believe is the term
a woman get beat and raped by her husband...regularly ...one night she decides she's had enough...
Kills him...she argues sooner of later he would have killed her...she was genuinely in fear of her life....jury buys it...
she's Free to go....battered wife syndrome....

The concept of justifiable homicide in criminal law differs from other forms of homicide in that the homicide is justified as preventing greater harm to innocents.


Then why are there not more vigilantees ? using this excuse
eg kill a Hells Angel or mob head or drug dealer etc ?
 
You mean like a vigilante? Take your meds son. A lilly white boy in mommy's basement can't go hunting with animals. Just saying.
Animals kill animals . If you try to mess around in that world you won't have to worry about a Judge and Jury.

agree


once you admit it they will come after you but as we see from the mass murders in the USA some folks do not care if they die
 
agree


once you admit it they will come after you but as we see from the mass murders in the USA some folks do not care if they die
Mass murders usually target little kids, people eating at McDonalds and the weak. They don't target gangsters and mafia members. Those guys bite back.
If anyone even drove by a few times suspiciously in gang territory you would have a few boys with guns on you. It's not going to be easy to Target those people.
 
can someone admit murder but be found innocent if he can talk the jury into accepting his reason for killing?


I am not talking self defence but if you kill for any other reason (political, societal, religious etc)


the same question for any crime

what if you stole from the rich and gave to the poor ? for example


what if you are charged with running a bawdy house and insist on a jury tral and simply say the law is wrong and convince the jury of your argument?


dealing drugs is another one

No. The law is absolute and must always govern. You must have a recognized defence or else you must be found guilty.
 
No. The law is absolute and must always govern. You must have a recognized defence or else you must be found guilty.

"Jury nullification" is the term for it. While in some legal theory you are correct, as others have said, if a jury finds you not guilty there isn't much the judge can do about that.

Not sure how common it is with murder, but in the case of pot possession there are examples of juries refusing to convict even in the face of absolutely damning evidence apparently because the jury didn't believe it should be criminal.

I guess the most famous case in Canada was R. v Morgentaler, where juries simply refused to convict him for performing abortions he admitted to performing.
 
"Jury nullification" is the term for it. While in some legal theory you are correct, as others have said, if a jury finds you not guilty there isn't much the judge can do about that.

Not sure how common it is with murder, but in the case of pot possession there are examples of juries refusing to convict even in the face of absolutely damning evidence apparently because the jury didn't believe it should be criminal.

I guess the most famous case in Canada was R. v Morgentaler, where juries simply refused to convict him for performing abortions he admitted to performing.

Yup. If the jury feels sympathetic enough to the accused, they can simply thwart the prosecution. Of course, that's totally illegal and in breach of their juror's oath. But the Crown can do nothing.

Of course, a judge can do pretty much the same thing. He / she is just a lot more cagey about it and dresses it up with a lot of mumbo-jumbo.
 
The concept of justifiable homicide in criminal law differs from other forms of homicide in that the homicide is justified as preventing greater harm to innocents.


Then why are there not more vigilantees ? using this excuse
eg kill a Hells Angel or mob head or drug dealer etc
?

Doesnt it have to do something with imminent threat of death? or something like that?..
I would think that you just couldnt go out and say ...well sooner or later he is gonna kill someone...so i will beat him to the punch....if that was the case.....you could go out and kill a guy sitting in a bar drinking a few beers....
whats your arguement going to be?..well sooner or later he will drive drunk and kill some one ....so...I just stopped a needless death....
I dont think a judge/jury would buy that arguement.....
 
"Jury nullification" is the term for it.
The two foundational cases are: Bushel’s Case (1670) 24 Eng. Rep. 1006 and its preceding foundational case The Trial of William Penn and William Mead (1670) 6 How. 951

(in more modern terms these would probably have been termed R. v Penn and Meade and Ex Parte Bushel)

Those truly interested might want to take a look at the article by Simon Stern in the Yale Law Journal Vol. 111, No. 6 2002 Which is available for a fee on line.