Question about horse power

so the value of knowing HP is that it tells you how fast you can go while torque tells you much your engine can pull (but not how long it can pull it) ?

If you have so much power (HP), you can drive up a hill fast pulling little weight, or go up the hill slow pulling more weight. It depends on how you set up the gears in the transmission. In this case the relationship is, power = weight x speed
 
I cannot believe no one has answered this correctly yet.

Horsepower is, in its simplest form, an expression of torque at a certain RPM.

Torque can be measured by a dynomometer. Horsepower is then calculated using a mathematical formula based on the torque reading expressed at a certain RPM that the torque was measured

HP = (TQ*RPM)/5252

example - a dynomometer measures torque at 460 ft/lbs at 4500 rpm

(460*4500)/5252 = 394.14 HP

Manufacturers advertise PEAK horsepower, which is often at a ridiculously high RPM that is either not feasible to sustain (for reasons of fuel economy, engine longevity, etc). Peak horsepower means nothing. "power under the curve" or below the max plotted line on a dyno chart, is usable power that one is able to take advantage of during normal use.

Things do get a little more complex as the ratio of power to weight play a role also :)

Hope this helps you to gain a better understanding.

"Horsepower sells cars - torque wins races" - Enzo Ferrari
 
You can look at it from the perspective of gearing. Suppose an engine makes 100 hp and 100 ft.lbs of torque say at 1000 RPM, take the same engine and put in a 2 to 1 gear on it such that for every 2 rotations of the engine the shaft on the gear moves 1 rotation. Now if you take the shaft of the gear and measure the output it makes the same 100 hp, but now it makes 200ft.lbs of torque and runs at 500 RPM.

You can also look at it from the perspective of an electric motor as an electric motor output is still rated for HP and torque. Take a Direct current motor, and AC motor is more complicated, the voltage applied is proportional to the speed, the current is proportional to the torqure. The input power, Volt x Amp = Watts. If you measure the output power of the motor from the shaft, you also can get watts, RPM x torque (there might be a constant in there but it is a constant so you can leave out the constant and still get the idea). on an electric motor the maximum power output is always the same, that is to say that at near 0 RPM the torque is max, and falls linearly as RPM increases such that RPM x torque is constant and it also means that the power supplied to the motor is constant Volt x AMP.

In a real engine you do not see the straight linear relationship between RPM and torque due to air flow, ignition timing, fuel ratios, etc... I will guess that if you had a theoretically perfect engine the HP and torque relationship will look identical to that of a DC motor.

From a strictly physics point of view all you need to know is HP, you can just put in gears to get whatever torque you want, the RPM will be a function of the gearing. It is the same idea as electrical power, all you need to know is Watts, you can install transformers to get whatever voltage you want, the current will be a function of the transformer.
 
you answered my liter question


the corvette has 460 pound-feet of torque

a Cummings big truck engine at 425 HP has 800 pound-feet

less than twice the pulling (twisting) force of the corvette yet the Corvette cannot pull half the weight of the Cummings which can pull over 100,000 pounds (weight of vehicle and trailer included)


What logic escapes me???


Obviously, it is the size of the engine that makes the difference but I am wondering about why they measure so little difference in the power ratings

This size difference is shown in the size of the cylinders measured in liters

11.9 liter in the Cummings truck engine

6.2 in the corvette engine

Comparing a gas engine to a commercial diesel engine is like comparing apples to oranges!
A qwik explanation is the diesel engine is designed to turn at low rpm(about 2000rpm max) & make lots of torque to get heavy things to move.It achieves this by number one always having a greater stroke to bore ratio ie 6.12" stroke to 5' bore,a typical 327 vette engine will have a 4" bore & 3.25" stroke.The longer the stroke,the more leverage(torque) on the crank.A modern diesel engine will be turbocharged & filling the cylinders with around 30-50psi of boost,unlike a natural aspirated car engine relying on the seal of the piston rings to draw(vacum) air into the cylinders.Probably the biggest advantage of diesel is the slow burn time.While a gas engine makes its peak power in the cylinder about 15-17 degree's after TDC on the power stroke & fades real qwik,a diesel starts its peak power right at TDC & continues making power almost right through the power stroke as fuel is injected.Lastly unlike a gas engine that can only have a 8.5-13.0 to 1 compression ratio a diesel averages about a 15-22 to 1 compression ratio making the engine inherently more efficient.Also diesel has about 10-12% more energy by volume.

Long story short,huge torque not so much horsepower because of the low rpms.The figure 800ft/lbs you quoted is similar of whats in a dodge 1 ton pickup.The torque in a 475hp CAT commercial truck engine is around 1850ft/lbs@1200rpm!
460ft/lbs is still a shit load of torque,but run that engine there under load pulling something & it won't be together very long!
Hope that explains a bit of the diesel engine for you.
Cheers
 
Comparing a gas engine to a commercial diesel engine is like comparing apples to oranges!
A qwik explanation is the diesel engine is designed to turn at low rpm(about 2000rpm max) & make lots of torque to get heavy things to move.It achieves this by number one always having a greater stroke to bore ratio ie 6.12" stroke to 5' bore,a typical 327 vette engine will have a 4" bore & 3.25" stroke.The longer the stroke,the more leverage(torque) on the crank.A modern diesel engine will be turbocharged & filling the cylinders with around 30-50psi of boost,unlike a natural aspirated car engine relying on the seal of the piston rings to draw(vacum) air into the cylinders.Probably the biggest advantage of diesel is the slow burn time.While a gas engine makes its peak power in the cylinder about 15-17 degree's after TDC on the power stroke & fades real qwik,a diesel starts its peak power right at TDC & continues making power almost right through the power stroke as fuel is injected.Lastly unlike a gas engine that can only have a 8.5-13.0 to 1 compression ratio a diesel averages about a 15-22 to 1 compression ratio making the engine inherently more efficient.Also diesel has about 10-12% more energy by volume.

Long story short,huge torque not so much horsepower because of the low rpms.The figure 800ft/lbs you quoted is similar of whats in a dodge 1 ton pickup.The torque in a 475hp CAT commercial truck engine is around 1850ft/lbs@1200rpm!
460ft/lbs is still a shit load of torque,but run that engine there under load pulling something & it won't be together very long!
Hope that explains a bit of the diesel engine for you.
Cheers


good explanation


"The torque in a 475hp CAT commercial truck engine is around 1850ft/lbs@1200rpm! "

Yes, that is where it gets the most torque and a good truck driver runs at 12-1300 rpm when under heavy load IE going up a hill

"800ft/lbs is still a shit load of torque,but run that engine there under load pulling something & it won't be together very long!"

I have changes my mind that a dodge pick up truck can pull like a big truck can just that it quickly blow up

I suspect it could not even budge the load

Horse Power is misleading - the term "power" throws you off

What is the value of the term as it does not indicate "power" and is not an accurate representation of speed or engine RPM
 
Horse Power is misleading - the term "power" throws you off

What is the value of the term as it does not indicate "power" and is not an accurate representation of speed or engine RPM

Horsepower isn't a marketing term. And horsepower absolutely is a representation of both car top speed and engine RPM.

vulcan99 and bishop gave you excellent explanations but it takes a while before you can intuitively know what it means. You are also thinking about an entire complex system of real life performance, gearing and durability all at the same time which complicates things.

For physicists and engineers, power means how much work you can do in a certain amount of time (or how much energy you expended in that time, the flip side of the coin).

This means that all things being equal, a car with more horsepower will have a higher top speed. At steady state, high speed, the work you are doing no longer serves to accelerate the car. It works against friction and wind resistance to maintain your speed. So if in one second a car can do more work than another car, it can maintain speed against more wind resistance and friction, therefore will have a higher top speed.

Or look at it another way, if you have two identical cars with engines producing the same amount of torque (let's assume an absolutely flat torque curve for simplicity) but one with more power, and both cars are running at top speed. The engine with more power is applying the same amount of torque at more rpms (remember power is essentially torque times revs). This means that the wheels of the higher hp car are turning faster and hence the car is going faster.

The reason people often say you feel torque but buy power is mostly because buyers, especially in North America, generally don't like to rev their engines. So if you need a certain amount of power, but don't want to rev high that means your torque must be greater. A similar car with the same power but less torque will generally have close to the same gear ratios. Therefore it won't have the same ability to accelerate until it gets higher in the rev range where it is producing more power.
 
Torque makes you go. Horsepower makes you go fast.
 
I have one of those, it's an awesome car!
 
From the point of view of physics ....

Torque is power ...
Torque is not power. Torque has dimensions of force times distance. Power has dimensions of energy divided by time.

By your definition torque does not measure ability to do work (which could be correct) but I THOUGHT IT DID.
Torque has same dimensions as work, but they are different concepts.

HP is a measurement of torque described in a different term
HP is not a measurement of torque. HP is a measure of power.

That being said, I thank Vulcan99's for Enzo Ferrari's explanation.
 
i think i got it


staying away from physics (to keep it simple),


torque means ability to pull something so trucks have more torque than cars (basically because they have bigger cylinders)


HP means how fast you can go which is why cars have as much, if not more, HP than a big truck as HP is torque times revs divided by a certain number


cars have less torque but more revs (smaller cylinders but they go up and down faster)
 
Last edited:
No, that's called the "displacement", basically that's amount of air and fuel mixture that can be held inside the cylinders at any given time. Basically, it's the maximum size of each of those cylinders multiplied by the number of cylinders. If you have cylinders that are 1 Litre in size each, and you have 8 cylinders, then the displacement is 8 Litres (8 x 1 L).

so what does 6.2 L engine mean if it is not displacement
 
It is displacement, I mentioned that. Displacement is the only thing that anybody mentions in ads. Nobody mentions fuel tank capacity or oil tank capacity, as nobody cares.
ok

thanks for taking the time to help me out

greatly appreciated