Quantas filled nitrogen in oxygen tanks

danmand

Well-known member
Nov 28, 2003
46,971
5,606
113
For 10 months, Quantas' mechanics in Melbourne filled Nitrogen into the
emergency air tanks of 51 Quantas airplanes.

http://ing.dk/artikel/84366
 
No, for 10 months they could have filled the crew tanks with nitrogen but didn't.

For those of us who speak English:

http://www.theage.com.au/news/national/probe-after-qantas-pumps-wrong-gas-into-jets/2007/12/15/1197568332267.html
"They identified 21 that were at risk because they had had a reasonable amount of oxygen top-up, so there was a reasonable chance they had been contaminated. There were another 30 aircraft at minor risk because they have had minor top ups," said the spokeswoman. The planes were inspected and no positive results found."

Qantas engineering executive general manager David Cox said: "We had a guy using a new rig and he inadvertently serviced the crew oxygen with nitrogen. He realised what he was doing and flagged it."

Mr Cox said that once the mistake had been realised, extensive safety checks were put in place to ensure no other aircraft had been contaminated and that it could never happen again.
​
OK, so a guy noticed the mistake as he was making the mistake, all planes potentially affected have been tested and passed (i.e. no planes left the ground with nitrogen instead of oxygen) and Qantas is putting new safety checks in place to ensure it doesn't happen again.
 
Here is another version of the story, different from Quantas' version:

POTENTIALLY fatal gas being pumped into passenger jet emergency oxygen tanks in Australia has sparked a worldwide safety investigation.

The Australian Safety Transport Bureau confirmed yesterday that Qantas engineers accidentally put nitrogen into the emergency oxygen tanks of a Boeing 747 passenger jet at Melbourne Airport.

The Australian carrier immediately checked the oxygen supplies of more than 50 of its planes that had been serviced by the mislabelled nitrogen cart at the airport. But an aviation source said: "This could have affected hundreds of planes worldwide. Any international jet that passed through Melbourne and was serviced by Qantas could have had nitrogen pumped into its oxygen tanks."
Health experts warned that in an emergency the effects of nitrogen in the oxygen tanks could have potentially fatal results.

Dr Ian Millar, hyperbaric medicine unit director at The Alfred hospital, said: "If there was an emergency and the pilot took nitrogen instead of oxygen, instead of gaining control of the aircraft he would black out and it would be all over. It's a pretty serious mistake."

Nitrogen, which is non-flammable, is commonly used at airports to fill aircraft tyres. The aviation source said: "Qantas took delivery of the new nitrogen cart 10 months ago. It looked exactly like the old oxygen cart. When the attachments did not fit they went and took them off the old oxygen cart and started using it."

The mistake was eventually spotted by an aircraft engineer. "He was walking around the plane and asked what they were doing. When they said they were topping up the oxygen, he said, 'No you're not, that's a nitrogen cart'," said the source.
The incident was reported to the Civil Aviation Safety Bureau, which confirmed that an investigation detected nitrogen in the crew oxygen tanks on the Boeing 747-300. A bureau spokeswoman said it was a one-off incident.

But the aviation source said: "This has affected at least 175 planes and Qantas has had to tell any other airline that has been serviced in Melbourne to check out its oxygen supplies."
 
Quantas have never had an air crash.

I've flown them many times and like'em.

Seems they have a bit of an odd accent though.;)
 
LancsLad said:
Quantas have never had an air crash.

I've flown them many times and like'em.

Seems they have a bit of an odd accent though.

Maybe they also sometimes use Helium instead of Oxygen.

I am going Air New Zealand this month.
 
danmand said:
Maybe they also sometimes use Helium instead of Oxygen.

PS: thanks for informing us about your world travels.
Did you miss the thread about millionaires on Terb?



No and I even posted in it.

If you are fishing for a confirm or deny I'll have to let you continue to ponder as I think I've already answered the question.

P.S. I fully expected a response from you on my very clever PM Spam line. Years of Python training finally pays off.


Hope you had a great New years, where did this farkin snow and cold come from. I'm telling mikey moore .
 
LancsLad said:
Hope you had a great New years, where did this farkin snow and cold come from. I'm telling mikey moore .

Great Christmas, quiet New Year, took in the Vienna show Yesterday.
I am off to San Andres tomorrow, after that to NZ for a month. Hate the snow.
 
danmand said:
Great Christmas, quiet New Year, took in the Vienna show Yesterday.
I am off to San Andres tomorrow, after that to NZ for a month. Hate the snow.


Lucky.

Just got back myself in time for the New Years snow.

May be heading back to HK later this month. Snow is for the younger set.
 
LancsLad said:
Lucky.

Just got back myself in time for the New Years snow.

May be heading back to HK later this month. Snow is for the younger set.

Hope it snows where ever you go.
 
LancsLad said:
Well I say, hail too you then!!!!!!

Seems that your relationship is cooling!
 
LancsLad said:
I really couldn't give a sleet what that hairy bruin thinks!

No worse hails than from a man scorned.
 
danmand said:
Here is another version of the story, different from Quantas' version:

POTENTIALLY fatal gas being pumped into passenger jet emergency oxygen tanks in Australia has sparked a worldwide safety investigation.

The Australian Safety Transport Bureau confirmed yesterday that Qantas engineers accidentally put nitrogen into the emergency oxygen tanks of a Boeing 747 passenger jet at Melbourne Airport.

The Australian carrier immediately checked the oxygen supplies of more than 50 of its planes that had been serviced by the mislabelled nitrogen cart at the airport. But an aviation source said: "This could have affected hundreds of planes worldwide. Any international jet that passed through Melbourne and was serviced by Qantas could have had nitrogen pumped into its oxygen tanks."
Health experts warned that in an emergency the effects of nitrogen in the oxygen tanks could have potentially fatal results.

Dr Ian Millar, hyperbaric medicine unit director at The Alfred hospital, said: "If there was an emergency and the pilot took nitrogen instead of oxygen, instead of gaining control of the aircraft he would black out and it would be all over. It's a pretty serious mistake."

Nitrogen, which is non-flammable, is commonly used at airports to fill aircraft tyres. The aviation source said: "Qantas took delivery of the new nitrogen cart 10 months ago. It looked exactly like the old oxygen cart. When the attachments did not fit they went and took them off the old oxygen cart and started using it."

The mistake was eventually spotted by an aircraft engineer. "He was walking around the plane and asked what they were doing. When they said they were topping up the oxygen, he said, 'No you're not, that's a nitrogen cart'," said the source.
The incident was reported to the Civil Aviation Safety Bureau, which confirmed that an investigation detected nitrogen in the crew oxygen tanks on the Boeing 747-300. A bureau spokeswoman said it was a one-off incident.

But the aviation source said: "This has affected at least 175 planes and Qantas has had to tell any other airline that has been serviced in Melbourne to check out its oxygen supplies."
Not exactly sure what point you're trying to make. If you read the article that I quoted from then you would see that there is no difference between what you quoted and what Qantas stated. I just didn't quote the entire article.

The plane that actually had nitrogen in it's crew oxygen system never left the ground. It was the plane that triggered this investigation. Quantas checked all 51 of it's planes and none were affected. They can't check any other plane that went through Melbourne since those planes are operated by other carriers. They have done their part by informing the other carriers of the situation. Until the status of the other 175 aircraft is known there's no way of knowing if the error actually ocurred except in the one case that never left the ground.
 
glaeken said:
Not exactly sure what point you're trying to make. If you read the article that I quoted from then you would see that there is no difference between what you quoted and what Qantas stated. I just didn't quote the entire article.

There seem to me to be a considerable differnce between what you posted (Quantas' version of the story):
glaeken said:
Qantas engineering executive general manager David Cox said: "We had a guy using a new rig and he inadvertently serviced the crew oxygen with nitrogen. He realised what he was doing and flagged it."

and what the rest of the article says:

"The mistake was eventually spotted by an aircraft engineer. "He was walking around the plane and asked what they were doing. When they said they were topping up the oxygen, he said, 'No you're not, that's a nitrogen cart'," said the source.
The incident was reported to the Civil Aviation Safety Bureau, which confirmed that an investigation detected nitrogen in the crew oxygen tanks on the Boeing 747-300. "


There is no reason for you to swipe this incident under the cover.
Fortunately nobody was hurt.
 
danmand said:
There seem to me to be a considerable differnce between what you posted (Quantas' version of the story):


and what the rest of the article says:

"The mistake was eventually spotted by an aircraft engineer. "He was walking around the plane and asked what they were doing. When they said they were topping up the oxygen, he said, 'No you're not, that's a nitrogen cart'," said the source.
The incident was reported to the Civil Aviation Safety Bureau, which confirmed that an investigation detected nitrogen in the crew oxygen tanks on the Boeing 747-300. "


There is no reason for you to swipe this incident under the cover.
Fortunately nobody was hurt.
Since you seem to want to crucify them I thought it only fair to show the other side of the story. Of course this is very serious but I think Qantas acted responsibility once the problem was discovered.

The difference in minute details of the statements could be something as simple as a PR person who didn't have the exact facts but the general story is consistent. The Quantas statement indicated that a worker noticed the mistake, the unnamed "aviation source" you quoted indicated it was an aircraft engineer. What does it matter who found the error. Who cares if it was a passing kangaroo who spotted it. The relevant and consistent fact is that someone noticed it.

If you expect 100% consistency in any two people's recounting of any incident then you're sadly mistaken.

Once the reports are in from the other airlines we'll know if there was a potential for any harm. And by that I mean that unless a plane actually left the ground with nitrogen in the system then Qantas got lucky and no harm, potential or otherwise, has been done.

So far the only plane that has confirmed to have nitrogen in the crew oxygen system is the one that triggered the investigation. Again, I'll say IT NEVER LEFT THE GROUND.

When any corporation does right thing it deserves to be awknowledged. Not forgiven, just awknowledged.
 
glaeken said:
Since you seem to want to crucify them I thought it only fair to show the other side of the story. Of course this is very serious but I think Qantas acted responsibility once the problem was discovered.

I have no interest in crucifying anybody. But I don't see why you insists this
was a trivial occurrence. Pilots blogs all over the world think differently.


glaeken said:
The Quantas statement indicated that a worker noticed the mistake, the unnamed "aviation source" you quoted indicated it was an aircraft engineer. What does it matter who found the error. Who cares if it was a passing kangaroo who spotted it. The relevant and consistent fact is that someone noticed it.

It makes a big difference.

Quantas says that a mechanic who was filling an airplane with Nitrogen noticed his own mistake and reported it.
You insist it only impacted a single airplane.

The other source says that for 10 months the quantas mechanics have been
using Nitrogen instead of oxygen to top up airplanes, and that it was only
noticed when an aircraft engineer happened to walk by. It seems serious enough
to warrent checking 175 airplanes for Nitrogen.

I would say there is a massive difference between the two versions of the events.

PS: The mistake was likely caused because the US and Europe (I don't know about Australia)
uses different markings for the same bottled gasses. Different gasses also have diffewrent couplings,
but the Quantas mechaniocs had circumvented that safety feature.
 
Do Qantas flight attendants still have sex with you, or is that only if the name on your boarding pass says "Ralph Fiennes"?
 
danmand said:
I have no interest in crucifying anybody. But I don't see why you insists this
was a trivial occurrence. Pilots blogs all over the world think differently.
I never said it was a trivial occurance. Do not put words in my mouth. I just said lets wait until the other 175 aircraft have been checked and then we will know what actually happened.


danmand said:
It makes a big difference.

Quantas says that a mechanic who was filling an airplane with Nitrogen noticed his own mistake and reported it.
You insist it only impacted a single airplane.

The other source says that for 10 months the quantas mechanics have been
using Nitrogen instead of oxygen to top up airplanes, and that it was only
noticed when an aircraft engineer happened to walk by. It seems serious enough
to warrent checking 175 airplanes for Nitrogen.
No, the tanks had been mislabelled for 10 months. And yes someone, whoever, noticed an incident where it was being wrongly used. Because of this it warrents checking 226 aircraft, not 175. The 51 Qantas aircraft have already been tested and are not affected. The other 175 are from other airlines and of course it warrents checking them. Of those, Air New Zealand checked their aircraft 6 weeks ago in response to a letter from Qantas and no irregularities were found.

From the article I linked to:
The incident was reported to the Civil Aviation Safety Bureau, which confirmed that an investigation detected nitrogen in the crew oxygen tanks on the Boeing 747-300. A bureau spokeswoman said it was a one-off incident.
​
I'm not defending them but at least read more than one account and wait until all the evidence is in.

danmand said:
I would say there is a massive difference between the two versions of the events.
That would be a massive overstatement.
danmand said:
PS: The mistake was likely caused because the US and Europe (I don't know about Australia)
uses different markings for the same bottled gasses. Different gasses also have diffewrent couplings,
but the Quantas mechaniocs had circumvented that safety feature.
I did read that the new nitrogen rig in question was the same as their old oxygen rig so they were using it for spare parts. Whether the Qantas mechanics intentionally circumvented any safety feature is up to an investigation to determine.

I'll leave you to your own opinions.