Protecting Canada's Flag

The Ottawa Sun article isn't good enough? When your landlord can attempt to prevent you from flying your nation's flag in a none distructive manner perhaps there is such a need.

Attempt and succeed are different things. If a "quiet enjoyment" defense doesn't prevail then perhaps there's a just reason for not having an adornment in that location, flag or otherwise.
 
Because of this statement you made earlier

I admire many things about the US. However, Canada is different, mostly, I think for the better, and I believe it is a mistake to blindly adapt policies from the US. Particularly in the area of justice and law enforcement, I do not wish to see Canada becoming more like the US.
 
I admire many things about the US. However, Canada is different, mostly, I think for the better, and I believe it is a mistake to blindly adapt policies from the US. Particularly in the area of justice and law enforcement, I do not wish to see Canada becoming more like the US.

You have no valid opinion on this. Go home.
 
Read the article!

jwm

I did all it said was
It is not clear how he came up with this bill and what his motivation for it is

The 2 year old Ottawa Sun link seemed tenuous at best given that it was two years old and Carmichael is a rookie MP from Toronto. I'm not in the habit of jumping to conclusions or believeing everying I read just because it was written by a reporter. It was a wild ass guess when they could have asked the source after his news conference. I'm still looking for a direct quote from Carmichael and I still don't see one.
 
I admire many things about the US. However, Canada is different, mostly, I think for the better, and I believe it is a mistake to blindly adapt policies from the US. Particularly in the area of justice and law enforcement, I do not wish to see Canada becoming more like the US.

Ok fair enough, then it's fair to say any American concept, custom, law etc., should not be automatically accepted, or discounted, but simply judged based on it's own merit ?
 
Ok fair enough, then it's fair to say any American concept, custom, law etc., should not be automatically accepted, or discounted, but simply judged based on it's own merit ?

I agree completely with that.
 
Condos will still be able to insist residents have window coverings meeting certain common criteria (colour, style, etc). I sure as hell don't want a flag be it the Canadian flag or the Rebel flag making my building look like a trailer park.

I think the flag is cheapened when it's put on top of a Wal-Mart or whatever or when the design is incorporated in a chair and umbrellas and such.
 
If I want to fly a flag from my house or something else, there are already laws to prevent people from stopping me.

I put up flag
Neighbor comes over to tell me to put it down.
I tell him to fuck right off and get off my property or I call the cops.
End of story.

Not that I would put up a flag, being I am not an American.

What is next passing a law making it illegal to beat up people who wear T shirts?



Now if the law means that my neighbour can put up a Canadian flag on my property, and I can't stop him, that is fucked up.
Not true.

There have been plenty of documented cases of people being forced to remove the Canadian flag from being visible on their own property.

Glad to hear you support this legislation to protect that right.
 
Not true.

There have been plenty of documented cases of people being forced to remove the Canadian flag from being visible on their own property.

Glad to hear you support this legislation to protect that right.


Oddly enough the one case already presented does not actually state that someone was forced to remove the flag from their own property. I'd guess the reason the Sun article was so weak is because it isn't an issue and that was the best the fellow could pick up.

Here is another story
http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/windsor/story/2010/11/10/windsor-belle-river-flag-issue.html
Oh but wait
"[The association refuses] to back down and I refuse to take my flag down, so we're actually at a stalemate," Brian Cassidy said.
Never mind that if you live in a condo or a place with a community association, you don't really own your home.

Looking around the internet I found this
Chris Hollingworth of St. Albert, Alta., refused to remove a Canadian flag from the window of his condo in 2001, after the building's manager called it "aesthetically unpleasing." Hollingworth had placed it there after the Sept. 11 attacks against the United States.

In decades of daily reading of the G&M and to a lessor extent other papers, I don't recall seeing it come up [maybe I skipped it I admit] The articles I've seen on the bill don't seem to point to any other examples except these two, where the flag was NOT taken down. So you can excuse my doubt.

There have been plenty of documented cases of sex with ducks reversing heart disease also.
I don't expect you to actually look up documented cases just to win an argument on terb, but don't expect me to buy into your word. I don't recall seeing the issue raised in the G&M which I've read for ages, nor any of the other papers I happen to pick up.