Protecting Canada's Flag

So are you saying it ok to prevent people from flying the flag ?

That depends where you are flying it, I would think. How about I put a big flag up on the sidewalk outside your home blotting out your view of the sun? This act could make it criminal for you--or any city bylaw--to stop me.

The act has some vague restrictions, like "improper purpose or use". What's an improper purpose? What's an improper use? Some purposes are clearly improper, but there are a lot of things that are debatable. Who decides? My purpose in putting up that 20 square meter flag on public property in front of your house was to create a visible expression of our community's patriotism toward Canada. Who says my purpose was to blot out your sunshine?

It's far too vague.
 
Last edited:
I agree with that, the law should only apply to the owner of the property, or renter.

I would think that is NOT the meaning of the law, because you already have an absolute right to do that, and no-one can stop you. Therefore the act must be aimed at things that are presently NOT covered, like erecting flags in public places, or on other people's property. If not, why have the act? As FatOne said it's completely covered by existing law if it's just saying you can't be stopped from putting up a flag on your own property.
 
I have to ask about the specific circumstances. For example, I cannot fly the canadian flag in denmark, at least not at the top of the flagpole.

If the question is if anyone should be able to tell me not to fly the canadian flag at my house in Canada, the answer is no.

In the condo I live in, flying flags is verbotten.

I wonder which law would win in this conflict? The Federal law or the Provincial law from which condominiums draw their power...

Interesting constitutional issue.
 
My op post was in response to the OP, who simply stated it was retarded, without saying why the law was retarded.

I don't agree with the current version of the law as is it too vague and does not spell out exactly what limitations are, such as the size of a flag. Example if someone living in a typical suburban housing puts a pole on their front yard and puts up a flag , let us say 6 feet by 3 feet, that's ok.

If they put of a flag that is 30 feet by 15 feet, then that's different, I also disagree with the possibility of jail time for such an offence.
 
Are you certain there is a federal law on this point or even that Ontario has such a law?

From this article it would certainly seem not. http://www.ottawasun.com/news/columnists/earl_mcrae/2009/07/30/10319241.html

Based on skimming the article, the flag is still there.
If a landlord can't tell a tenant he can't have dogs shitting all over the place and cats scratching up the walls, I'd be very surprised if a landlord order a renter to pull down a flag on his own unit. Ask sure, but order? If you rent an apartment, the landlord becomes your bitch.

If the law makes it illegal to even ask someone to take down a flag, I'd consider that to be very disturbing.
 
It also seems to be another one of these Conservative initiatives from nowhere, solving problems that simply do not exist.

Like when they claimed that there were privacy concerns around the long form of the census--but in fact NO-ONE had filed any privacy complaints, no-one was campaigning against it, the privacy commissioner hadn't raised any issue with it, polls didn't show any particular concern about it--there were pretty much zero detectable privacy concerns.

Now they are "protecting the flag". Sounds great. But who was threatening it? Where are the cases of outraged people who were prevented from flying the flag? What's the problem? Why is this necessary?

Is it a pre-emptive strike, in case some day, somewhere in some remote corner of Canada, this ever actually becomes an issue between some patriotic Canadian and his flag hating anti-Canadian neighbour?
 
Lets not throw people in jail if they don't do the long form census... but it's ok to throw others in jail if they prevent others from flying the Canadian flag.

Nice to know where the priorities are.
 
Lets not throw people in jail if they don't do the long form census... but it's ok to throw others in jail if they prevent others from flying the Canadian flag.

Nice to know where the priorities are.

Yes. Very high priorities, especially since no-one was ever jailed over the long form census, and no-one has been prevented from flying a flag!
 
Now they are "protecting the flag". Sounds great. But who was threatening it? Where are the cases of outraged people who were prevented from flying the flag? What's the problem? Why is this necessary?
The Ottawa Sun article isn't good enough? When your landlord can attempt to prevent you from flying your nation's flag in a none distructive manner perhaps there is such a need.
 
The Ottawa Sun article isn't good enough? When your landlord can attempt to prevent you from flying your nation's flag in a none distructive manner perhaps there is such a need.

It is a huge issue. Maybe our tea party friends in the US can come and help out with this.
 
Are you saying because this concept is , in your opinion, so American is it not acceptable ?

No, I don't think so, and I fail to understand why you are asking the question. It just seems to me to be the kind of issues the tea party in the US likes to flog.
 
The Ottawa Sun article isn't good enough? When your landlord can attempt to prevent you from flying your nation's flag in a none distructive manner perhaps there is such a need.

"Neither side in the flag fight at Montfort Manors Apartments at 550 Langs Rd. is backing down."

I don't see anyone being prevented from doing anything. They asked, tenets said fuck off, landlord can't do shit.

Or perhaps you think we need a law making it illegal to even ask.
 
"Neither side in the flag fight at Montfort Manors Apartments at 550 Langs Rd. is backing down."

I don't see anyone being prevented from doing anything. They asked, tenets said fuck off, landlord can't do shit.
That is merely because the landlord didn't think to put it in the lease. The proposed bill is to preclude that sort of eventuality.
 
No, I don't think so, and I fail to understand why you are asking the question. It just seems to me to be the kind of issues the tea party in the US likes to flog.

Because of this statement you made earlier

Just another attempt to emulate the US. Soon Harper will make it a crime to visit Cuba.

The Harperites are flying false flag. They pretend to be patriotic, while they systematicly destroy canadian institutions in
favour of US type policies.

I am sure that the US will welcome 13 new states. (Isn't that what the PQ wanted at some stage?)