Protecting Canada's Flag

jwmorrice

Gentleman by Profession
Jun 30, 2003
7,133
2
0
In the laboratory.
I think this idea is fucking retarded.

jwm

September 28, 2011
MP's bid to protect flag adds another notch to Harper's patriotic belt
By JANE TABER
Globe and Mail Update
Conservative private member's bill would slap fines or jail terms on Canadians who prevent others from flying the Maple Leaf


A rookie Conservative MP wants to fine - or even jail - Canadians who prevent others from flying the Maple Leaf.

John Carmichael, who represents the Toronto riding of Don Valley West, has crafted a truly patriotic private member's bill. He is to unveil the National Flag of Canada Act in more detail Wednesday at a news conference with Heritage Minister James Moore.

This proposed bill adds to Stephen Harper's efforts at re-branding Canada and its symbols [http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news...ins-a-new-brand-of-patriotism/article2135876], creating more public expressions of pride in the country and presenting history through a conservative lens.

For example, Mr. Moore's department is poised to launch new funding for commemorating the 200th anniversary of the War of 1812 [http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news...in-war-of-1812-commemorations/article2099541], which the Conservatives are billing as a defining moment in the creation of Canada as a country.

In addition, Defence Minister Peter MacKay has restored the traditional "Royal" designation [http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news...l-to-air-force-and-navy-names/article2130991] to the air force and navy. And Foreign Affairs Minister John Baird has ordered all of Canada's missions and embassies abroad to put a portrait of the Queen [http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news...5-to-hang-the-queens-portrait/article2156792] on prominent display.

Mr. Carmichael's bill, meanwhile, would prohibit "any person to prevent the displaying of the National Flag of Canada provided that (a) the flag is displayed in a manner befitting this national symbol; (b) the display is not for an improper purpose or use; (c) the flag is not subjected to desecration."

As for enforcement, the rookie Tory MP proposes that anyone who contravenes the act be subject to a temporary restraining order or an interlocutory injunction. His bill goes on to say that anyone who disregards an injunction or restraining order could be punished by "a fine in the discretion of the court or by imprisonment for a term not exceeding two years."

Mr. Carmichael is a well-know businessman in Toronto, running a successful car dealership. He is a father of three adult children and a grandfather of three.

It is not clear how he came up with this bill and what his motivation for it is. However, a two-year-old column in the Ottawa Sun tells the story of a dispute at an apartment building [http://www.ottawasun.com/news/columnists/earl_mcrae/2009/07/30/10319241.html] over the flying of small Canadian flags from several balconies.

The rookie Tory MP was in caucus Wednesday morning and could not comment before his midday news conference. An aide to Mr. Moore would also not comment, saying this is Mr. Carmichael's announcement and the minister is attending the news conference simply to support his colleague.
 
Protect the flag and kill the CBC.
 
So are you saying it ok to prevent people from flying the flag ?

Just another attempt to emulate the US. Soon Harper will make it a crime to visit Cuba.

The Harperites are flying false flag. They pretend to be patriotic, while they systematicly destroy canadian institutions in
favour of US type policies.

I am sure that the US will welcome 13 new states. (Isn't that what the PQ wanted at some stage?)
 
Just another attempt to emulate the US. Soon Harper will make it a crime to visit Cuba.

I am sure that the US will welcome 13 new states. (Isn't that what the PQ wanted at some stage?)

You are getting just as nutty as Woody now. I would have thought that was beneath you.

Seriously, though why is this legislation necessary have there been cases where displaying it was restricted - Quebec maybe?
 
You are getting just as nutty as Woody now. I would have thought that was beneath you.

Seriously, though why is this legislation necessary have there been cases where displaying it was restricted - Quebec maybe?

Read the article!

jwm
 
You are getting just as nutty as Woody now. I would have thought that was beneath you.

Seriously, though why is this legislation necessary have there been cases where displaying it was restricted - Quebec maybe?

Maybe, however, the following is the true:

The Harperites are flying false flag. They pretend to be patriotic, while they systematicly destroy canadian institutions in
favour of US type policies.
 
Globe and Mail Update
For example, Mr. Moore's department is poised to launch new funding for commemorating the 200th anniversary of the War of 1812 which the Conservatives are billing as a defining moment in the creation of Canada as a country.
Are The Globe and Mail and/or Jane Taber attempting to say that only Conservatives feel this way or that the statement is untrue?
 
Just another attempt to emulate the US. Soon Harper will make it a crime to visit Cuba.

The Harperites are flying false flag. They pretend to be patriotic, while they systematicly destroy canadian institutions in
favour of US type policies.

I am sure that the US will welcome 13 new states. (Isn't that what the PQ wanted at some stage?)


Again, forget you bias for a few minutes and answer the question.

Do you think it's ok to prevent someone from flying the flag ?
 
You are getting just as nutty as Woody now. I would have thought that was beneath you.

Seriously, though why is this legislation necessary have there been cases where displaying it was restricted - Quebec maybe?

Happened fairly recently , last year I believe, in Toronto ill try and find link
 
Again, forget you bias for a few minutes and answer the question.

Do you think it's ok to prevent someone from flying the flag ?

You are asking the wrong person. I don't care much about flags, not the canadian, the US or the danish flags. Rules like the american one against desecrating the flag, and other rules about flying other countries' flags are in my view silly and by nature inconsistent, and can be misused by governments.

If the flag is the only thing that makes us canadian, so help us God. It is culture and institutions, and yes, the flag is a small part of that.
 
...Do you think it's ok to prevent someone from flying the flag ?

I don't think there's anything sacred about a flag nor do I think that in all and every circumstance, flying one would be okay. I can see folks making patriotic nuisances of themselves.

jwm
 
You are asking the wrong person. I don't care much about flags, not the canadian, the US or the danish flags. Rules like the american one against desecrating the flag, and other rules about flying other countries' flags are in my view silly and by nature inconsistent, and can be misused by governments.

If the flag is the only thing that makes us canadian, so help us God. It is culture and institutions, and yes, the flag is a small part of that.

I didn't ask if you cared about the flag, I asked if you thought it was OK to tell someone else that they cannot fly a flag ? ?
 
I didn't ask if you cared about the flag, I asked if you thought it was OK to tell someone else that they cannot fly a flag ? ?

I have to ask about the specific circumstances. For example, I cannot fly the canadian flag in denmark, at least not at the top of the flagpole.

If the question is if anyone should be able to tell me not to fly the canadian flag at my house in Canada, the answer is no.
 
...For example, I cannot fly the canadian flag in denmark, at least not at the top of the flagpole.

It's a wonder our government didn't add that restriction to the proposed bill. Wow, talk about falling down on the job!

jwm
 
I have to ask about the specific circumstances. For example, I cannot fly the canadian flag in denmark, at least not at the top of the flagpole.

The circumstance is on Canadian soil.

Foreign flags are not allowed at all in denmark without permission ( exception Norway, Sweden, Finland, Iceland)
 
Just another attempt to emulate the US. Soon Harper will make it a crime to visit Cuba.

The Harperites are flying false flag. They pretend to be patriotic, while they systematicly destroy canadian institutions in
favour of US type policies.

I am sure that the US will welcome 13 new states. (Isn't that what the PQ wanted at some stage?)

I know I am wasting my breath but just because an idea or policy comes from the US does not mean it is either evil in its nature or unpatriotic to implement it.

If our government leaders believe that a policy that was thought up in the US is good for the country and we should emulate it, and it will make the country better, that is patriotic at every level. They are trying to make Canada better.

I get the impression that if the US government came up with a system of better traffic control that cut cost in half and reduced accidents by 50% you would argue that it would be unpatriotic to emulate it here.
 
I know I am wasting my breath but just because an idea or policy comes from the US does not mean it is either evil in its nature or unpatriotic to implement it.

If our government leaders believe that a policy that was thought up in the US is good for the country and we should emulate it, and it will make the country better, that is patriotic at every level. They are trying to make Canada better.

I get the impression that if the US government came up with a system of better traffic control that cut cost in half and reduced accidents by 50% you would argue that it would be unpatriotic to emulate it here.

No, you are definitely wrong there.
 
Foreign flags are not allowed at all in denmark without permission ( exception Norway, Sweden, Finland, Iceland)

And UN, EU and Greenland.
 
If I want to fly a flag from my house or something else, there are already laws to prevent people from stopping me.

I put up flag
Neighbor comes over to tell me to put it down.
I tell him to fuck right off and get off my property or I call the cops.
End of story.

Not that I would put up a flag, being I am not an American.

What is next passing a law making it illegal to beat up people who wear T shirts?



Now if the law means that my neighbour can put up a Canadian flag on my property, and I can't stop him, that is fucked up.