Prostitution ruling expected this month

I'm curious about the situation that you would want to see. Are you saying that you favour legalization/regulation? I'm quite interested in knowing the differences.

I'd also like to clarify a few points in this thread:

1) Prostitution is not a criminal activity in Canada. Outcalls are quite legal. Perhaps....however those running the businesses and the drivers may well be breaking the laws...ie; living off the avails!
2) What is Criminalized are things like being Found-In A Bawdy House, Living Off The Avails of Prostitution, Keeping A Common Bawdy House. The girls can get around this by changing ie; hotel rooms. If you move consistently...it is hard to call a 'place' a bawdy house!!
3) What SPOC wants to do is to simply remove items I mention in #2 above from the Criminal Code, thereby "Decriminalizing" them. I could not support this unless you deal with the tru pimps!
4) SPOC is not seeking to "legalize" or "regulate" prostitution. Thus discussion of taxes being added to SP services, or prices going up as a result is a moot point.
The taxes...and tax collections I think would be a farce in this industry! There would be very little money on the books!!
 
This lawsuit is a terrible idea. If the judge rules against the restrictions on communication for the purpose of prostitution, then the Conservative government will criminalize prostitution. Allan Young will, of course, just walk away.
 
Yes and they now consider keeping a common bawdy house a "criminal organization"

No, they consider keeping a bawdy house to be a serious offence. This only comes into play when dealing with a criminal organization, which must have at least a certain number of people involved.
 
No, they consider keeping a bawdy house to be a serious offence. This only comes into play when dealing with a criminal organization, which must have at least a certain number of people involved.

3 escorts sharing a condo. Ergo you have a dangerous "criminal organization". Ridiculous. Putting escorts in jail sounds like something the murderous Islamic Iranian mullahs would do. We are support to be morally superior and we hold our government to a higher standard.
 
When I hear people clamouring for prostitution to be taxed and regulated,

I think that things are better off as they are now without legalized bawdy houses.
 
If I understand correctly, the "serious offence" tag only comes into play when dealing with a "criminal organization."

And taken one step further, aren't they automatically treating certain offences as being part of organized crime to give LE greater power?
 
When I hear people clamouring for prostitution to be taxed and regulated,

I think that things are better off as they are now without legalized bawdy houses.

Yeah, just look at how efficiently and productively the drug trade has organized itself w/o being taxed and regulated. 'Specially in Mexico.
 
Which is why SPOC sadly does not have the support of many upscale indies and agencies.

SPOC has been known {to those working in the industry} to only really be interested in the street walkers and "their" agenda related to this industry which is not something that many of us agree with.

While some of us agree that laws need to change, we can't all agree on how it should be done. I think that until that happens, we will not be seeing any major change in the near feature.
I applaud your stance on legalizing, but I would venture to guess that most agency owners and independents would not want to legalize it for the following reasons:
- higher prices when it is illegal (see US)
- more requirements for licensing, paperwork, mandatory checks
- cheating on taxes is easier
- hiring and firing is a breeze
- no rights for Johns
 
Be careful what you wish for. I have been to Amsterdam and it ain't as good as the hype. LEs there protect prostitutes, not customers. rip offs, bad attitude, high rates, reduced service levels are common place. Good for tourism and safety of prostitutes, but bad for hobbysts.

Ok, so either we have a system that protects human life or a system that protects money interests. I'm voting for the system that protects life.

The more that you post zardoz, the more I get the feeling that you are a worthless human being with no feelings for women. Did you enjoy killing small animals as a child?
 
I applaud your stance on legalizing, but I would venture to guess that most agency owners and independents would not want to legalize it for the following reasons:
- higher prices when it is illegal (see US)
- more requirements for licensing, paperwork, mandatory checks
- cheating on taxes is easier
- hiring and firing is a breeze
- no rights for Johns

While most independents would probably not want legalization, most agencies should. Yes, it creates paperwork etc, but it creates a framework when they have to run a legitimate business in an appropriate way, which I doubt most of them would really object to.

Giving both SP's and John's rights would not be a bad thing. Having mandatory health checks would not be a bad thing. Ensuring that children are not part of the sex trade is not a bad thing. Ensuring that women are not being preyed upon is not a bad thing. Regulating where the trade takes place so neighbourhoods feel safe is not a bad thing. Having taxes flow into the health care system is not a bad thing.

Where is the downside to legalization?
 
While most independents would probably not want legalization, most agencies should. Yes, it creates paperwork etc, but it creates a framework when they have to run a legitimate business in an appropriate way, which I doubt most of them would really object to.

Giving both SP's and John's rights would not be a bad thing. Having mandatory health checks would not be a bad thing. Ensuring that children are not part of the sex trade is not a bad thing. Ensuring that women are not being preyed upon is not a bad thing. Regulating where the trade takes place so neighbourhoods feel safe is not a bad thing. Having taxes flow into the health care system is not a bad thing.

Where is the downside to legalization?
No downside. But, you are clearly not viewing this from an agency owner's perspective. If prostitution is legalized agencies won't be flush with cash anymore they don't know what to do with.
 
Perhaps, but they'll also have a tsunami of new customers, guys too afraid to go before legalization, or too unconnected to find the incalls. No one can know (one of the difficulties of underground economies), but it sure sounds like the old HighPrice LowVolume vs.LowPrice HighVolume thing that has yet to destroy it's first business sector.

They told Ford the same thing when he doubled his workers wages. He sold twice as many cars instead. And there likely were some speakeasies that didn't make it when they repealed the Eighteenth, but the liquor business isn't hurting today from being legal.

Anyway, why would legalization necessarily lower prices? Incalls are illegal here and the US, but there the prices are higher. Gotta be something other than the laws.