Prostate biopsy

danmand

Well-known member
Nov 28, 2003
46,971
5,606
113
I have had elevated but fairly stable PSA numbers for a couple of years. The urologist ordered a biopsy 3 months ago, and the result was that there were some malignant cells, but that the aggressiveness number was low. He described the malignant cells as dormant, and ordered monitoring of the PSA numbers.

Now, the first time after the biopsy, the PSA number went up quite dramatically. I am wondering if that is normal, or that somehow the biopsy could have excited these "dormant" malignant cells.

Has anybody had a similar experience?
 
I have had elevated but fairly stable PSA numbers for a couple of years. The urologist ordered a biopsy 3 months ago, and the result was that there were some malignant cells, but that the aggressiveness number was low. He described the malignant cells as dormant, and ordered monitoring of the PSA numbers.

Now, the first time after the biopsy, the PSA number went up quite dramatically. I am wondering if that is normal, or that somehow the biopsy could have excited these "dormant" malignant cells.

Has anybody had a similar experience?

I've only had experience with my Dad's case where his PSA had gone up quite quickly and then he had a biopsy. His PSA didn't elevate post biopsy. He did go in for surgery (which went fine). The older you are the slower things happen but if you're relatively young and have an elevated PSA they should be treating it not watching it in my opinion.
 
The PSA is going up after the biopsy usually. If nothing serious it will be lower next time. PSA is not specific for cancer but the PSA vs. free PSA ratio is more specific. If the ratio is low, the risk is higher for cancer.
This site is very helpful where the guys shared their own experiences with you, but I know you don't have cancer don't worry:)

www.yananow.org

I hope this is helpful!
 
What did your urolgist say after seeing the higher psa number? Never heard of "dormant" malignant cells, you either have cancer or you do not, you do. It seems yours is not aggressive, which is called the gleason score. I know this because I just went through it, had a 4 psa over many yrs, finally got a biopsy, was a low gleason score, so not aggressive but had cancer in many samples. after reviewing the site mentioned above, one I recommend highly, chose robotic surgery and just came out of it. It is only after surgery and a pathology report that they truly know how extensive it was and the final gleason score. They seem to have gotten mine all out, but it was a close call, so do not avoid this, talk to your urologist and get a second opinion if not sure.
 
What did your urolgist say after seeing the higher psa number? Never heard of "dormant" malignant cells, you either have cancer or you do not, you do. It seems yours is not aggressive, which is called the gleason score. I know this because I just went through it, had a 4 psa over many yrs, finally got a biopsy, was a low gleason score, so not aggressive but had cancer in many samples. after reviewing the site mentioned above, one I recommend highly, chose robotic surgery and just came out of it. It is only after surgery and a pathology report that they truly know how extensive it was and the final gleason score. They seem to have gotten mine all out, but it was a close call, so do not avoid this, talk to your urologist and get a second opinion if not sure.

I had like you a 4 PSA number for two years. The biopsy found one (out of 10) spot with cancer cells, with a low gleason number. 3 month after the biopsy, the PSA number was 8, and the urologist ordered a new PSA test. He said that he expected it to be lower again, but if not, the biopsy might have missed something and I will need treatment.

Where did you have surgery? (PM me if you like) I thouht anyway you did not need surgery if the gleason number was low.

I had already a second opinion from the Mayo clinic, bedore the biopsy. The urologist there did not recommend a biopsy, but when my urologist here ordered one, I did not think it could hurt. I am now a little concerned that the biopsy might have triggered the cancer cells to become more aggressive, but I have no basis for that theory. It just seems an unlikely coincidence, if the cancer cells became aggressive right after the biopsy.c
 
I had 2 coworkers that had high psa counts . They were between 50 and 56 I'am not sure what the doctor told them but the 50 year old died within 2 years because he waited too long to do anything and the other waited too long for surgery and to go for chemo and that wasn't fun. In my case after seeing what happened to my friends and my counts were high I didn't wait. In the long run it's better to get the surgery done early ......
 
danmand

these are questions one should discuss with their urologist. a biopsy takes samples, yours was 10. yours found only one hit for cancer, which is good, but the results are only for those ten samples, they could have missed or may not have missed additional cancer cells, in non sampled areas of your prostrate. Yours intial one sample probably led your urologist to recommend watchful waiting, since it grows so slowly (if low gleason score). Mine was slow growing but more extensive. I never heard of a biopsy causing a cancer to become more aggressive. Wait to see what the next psa test shows, discuss it with a good urologist, educate yourself and try not to make yourself crazy. Go to the site suggested above, wish you the best.
 
danmand

these are questions one should discuss with their urologist. a biopsy takes samples, yours was 10. yours found only one hit for cancer, which is good, but the results are only for those ten samples, they could have missed or may not have missed additional cancer cells, in non sampled areas of your prostrate. Yours intial one sample probably led your urologist to recommend watchful waiting, since it grows so slowly (if low gleason score). Mine was slow growing but more extensive. I never heard of a biopsy causing a cancer to become more aggressive. Wait to see what the next psa test shows, discuss it with a good urologist, educate yourself and try not to make yourself crazy. Go to the site suggested above, wish you the best.


Thank you so very much. I really appreciate your advice and your sharing of your experience. Best wishes to you also.

PS: Would you mind sending me a PM about where you had your surgery. It appears to have been completely successful.


actually, thatks to everybody who have posted advice and suggestions fto me. It is appreciated.
 
Last edited:
The Da Vinci robotic surgery is very good results by Dr. Tony Finelli . If you are an older 60+ gentleman the non-invasive HIFU is excellent but it cost 22.000$ by Dr. William Orovan on the Maple Leaf HIFU center.