Prorogation - the fallout

Unfortunatly for the liberals the detainee issue has virtually no traction outside of Ottawa and opposition ranks. The general public just does not care about the mistreatment of " terrorists" who set IEDs to kill Canadians and others. The prorogation will enjd up on the trash heap of political expediency along side the coalition, and JAck LAyton.

These are things that just don't have traction where it matters with the people who vote . Those people are going to want to know how the government is going to spend their money over the next couple of years. That is going to be the major issue going forward.

We shall see. Harper was dropping in the polls and taking a political shit-kicking even before he prorogued. That was strictly fallout over the detainee issue. Most Canadians expect better from their government and Harper was clearly disappointing them. Even among those misinformed saps who assume every detainee had been busily planting IEDs and was automatically a murdering terrorist scumbag, many still expect their government to be more open and accountable, to abide by the GC and to respect legitimate inquiries like the one about the mishandling of detainees (ie: they expect the gov't to co-operate, to tell the truth, to not boycott or otherwise obstruct, to not assassinate the character of witnesses etc). As I said earlier, Harper underestimated Canadians if he really thought we only cared about the economy. If that were true, his polling numbers wouldn't have budged no matter what we found out about detainee abuse and no matter how blatantly the government lied, obstructed, boycotted or prorogued. Clearly the polls show that Canadians care about this more than you think. And they don't have short memories either.
 
S you say we shall see. there is not a poll outtheir that shows people really care about the detainees in any large way, they are more worried about their mortgages groceries and jobs.
 
I'm missing something here - why would delaying parliament by a month have the slightest impact on the detainee issue? It's not as if the opposition is going to forget about it. I know they have short attention spans but not that short.
 
I wouldn't bet on these polling numbers disappearing once the Olympics change the channel. The real change in this poll are the numbers out of Ontario were it can be argued that the Province that has been hit the hardest by this recession is once again being ignored by the Federal Conservatives. This coupled with the Federal Conservative support of the HST has Ontario in a foul mood that won't go away so easy. Ontario voters are restless and I do think that the straw that broke the camel's back was the closing of Parliament. The Conservatives now have a big problem here. My suspicion was that since they have been polling better when they are not in Parliament, the plan was to put together a budget the opposition couldn't support and force a spring election so they could campaign on all the things put on hold by closing Parliament. With precious little left in the bank, the next budget will not have the goodies it has had in the past. All in all this blunder could cost Harper the Government.


kf

I don't see the connection between the federal gov't and the Olympics anyway. The venue is in Vancouver which is about as far away from Ottawa as you can get. And it is the individual athletes who do all the work and actually win these medals - not a bunch of suits from Ottawa. So I can't see why the Olympics will improve the gov'ts ratings. That doesn't mean it won't happen but it sure doesn't make much sense!

When you talk about "the straw that broke the camel's back", you seem to be saying the same thing I've been saying - namely that Harper has been Mr. Teflon for the last 4 years but his no-stick amnesty days seem to be coming to an end. When that happens, Harper will very quickly lose that "nice-boy-gets-benefit-of-the-doubt" innocence and start to look like every other repeat offender who got plenty of chances but blew them all off. You can't keep lying, denying, obstructing, manipulating and proroguing forever.
 
I'm missing something here - why would delaying parliament by a month have the slightest impact on the detainee issue? It's not as if the opposition is going to forget about it. I know they have short attention spans but not that short.

It isn't the oppos that Harper was worried about. It was the voters. Those daily doses of detainee details were starting to cause unrest among the townsfolk. This hearsay was giving Harper headaches, heartburn, hives and halitosis. So he just changed the locks. What'd you expect - real solution?
 
I'm missing something here - why would delaying parliament by a month have the slightest impact on the detainee issue? It's not as if the opposition is going to forget about it. I know they have short attention spans but not that short.

Yes you are missing something, this: It doesn't just delay it, it officially cancels all of the proceedings to date, tosses out all the evidence that has been submitted, nullifies the actions that were before the committee--essentially terminates the whole inquiry and sets it back to square one, not to mention, delays it by (actually over) a month...
 
Unfortunatly for the liberals the detainee issue has virtually no traction outside of Ottawa and opposition ranks. The general public just does not care about the mistreatment of " terrorists" who set IEDs to kill Canadians and others. The prorogation will enjd up on the trash heap of political expediency along side the coalition, and JAck LAyton.

These are things that just don't have traction where it matters with the people who vote . Those people are going to want to know how the government is going to spend their money over the next couple of years. That is going to be the major issue going forward.

People are visual. They aren't moved by descriptions of torture, as we have had so far, but rather by images. So Abu Ghraib was no big deal when it was detailed on paper, all hell broke loose when the media got ahold of good visuals to run. That upset people. Visually.

That is one of the reason why the Conservatives are doing everything they possibly can to block the release of photographs of the tortured detainees, going so far as defy a motion of Parliament to keep that material under wraps.

Harper keeps saying nobody cares, but he knows people will care once they can see it with their own eyes, and THAT has him scared shitless.
 
The pictures that are available have a couple of problems, the biggest one being the person in the picture would have to be identifiable as somebody who was turned over to teh Afghans by our forces. That information would be very difficult to obtain and verify.

How would you go about proving that somebody in the picture was somnebody that we had turned over?
 
As I said earlier, Harper underestimated Canadians if he really thought we only cared about the economy. If that were true, his polling numbers wouldn't have budged no matter what we found out about detainee abuse and no matter how blatantly the government lied, obstructed, boycotted or prorogued. Clearly the polls show that Canadians care about this more than you think. And they don't have short memories either.

I wish that were true, although the EKOS polling seems to indicate Canadians don't care about anything that isn't the flavour of the day.

"However, all is not so bad for the Prime Minister and his team. Mr. Graves’s survey was taken over several days – from Jan. 6 to Jan. 12 – and Tory fortunes were rebounding in the last few days of the poll.
On Jan. 6, the Conservatives were at 28.3 per cent compared to 34 per cent by Jan. 12. Averaged all together, however, the Tories emerge with 30.9 per cent. The Liberals, meanwhile, began on the first day of the poll with 23.6 per cent and ended with 26.6 per cent. Their global total for the poll period was 29.3 per cent."

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/blog...n-harpers-prorogation-mistake/article1431024/
 
The pictures that are available have a couple of problems, the biggest one being the person in the picture would have to be identifiable as somebody who was turned over to teh Afghans by our forces. That information would be very difficult to obtain and verify.

How would you go about proving that somebody in the picture was somnebody that we had turned over?

There are before and after pictures, of the captive in Canadian custody (i.e., with Canadian soldiers) and then again pictures of the same individual after being retrieved from the Afghans. These photographs are discussed in the Parliamentary evidence and referenced in several reports but the Conservatives are not releasing them claiming that the photographs are a sensitive national security secret.
 
S you say we shall see. there is not a poll outtheir that shows people really care about the detainees in any large way, they are more worried about their mortgages groceries and jobs.

You are correct no gives a fuck about extremists, but Canadians are hard working people and they expect the same from their ELECTED representatives. By proroguing parliament a second time, Harper has made himself look like a lazy, naked moocher. For the rest of us, if we asked our bosses for a two month Christmas holiday watch how fast our jobs disappear. It's time for Peter McKay to become PM, let Harper go back to building firewalls.

As for Justin Trudeau, lets not forget that in the last election, he was the only MP to take down an incumbent Blochead.

http://www.economist.com/world/americas/displaystory.cfm?story_id=15211862
 
I wish that were true, although the EKOS polling seems to indicate Canadians don't care about anything that isn't the flavour of the day.

"However, all is not so bad for the Prime Minister and his team. Mr. Graves’s survey was taken over several days – from Jan. 6 to Jan. 12 – and Tory fortunes were rebounding in the last few days of the poll.
On Jan. 6, the Conservatives were at 28.3 per cent compared to 34 per cent by Jan. 12. Averaged all together, however, the Tories emerge with 30.9 per cent. The Liberals, meanwhile, began on the first day of the poll with 23.6 per cent and ended with 26.6 per cent. Their global total for the poll period was 29.3 per cent."

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/blog...n-harpers-prorogation-mistake/article1431024/

You're probably right - Harper's drop in popularity won't last and his polling results will recover slightly. But people won't completely forget the reasons why they were temporarily dissatisfied with Harper. Harper is steadily losing the benefit of the doubt and he will find that voter attitudes become less and less elastic each time he pulls one of these annoying stunts. This last episode was a double whammy. Harper was dropping in the polls because of all the negative detainee disclosures and then he dropped even more when he prorogued parliament without a good reason. Some of that damage is permanent and some of it has been set aside but none of it is totally off the table. Once undecided voters start comparing Harper to an alternative candidate, all or most of Harper's sins will be back in the frame.

Harper has been getting one freebie after another from Dion and Iggy but that won't necessarily continue. Iggy has been keeping a relatively low profile after his aborted election bid - giving everyone lots of time to forget his mistakes. If voter attitudes towards Harper can recover, they can also recover towards Iggy. Iggy had already started to reinvent himself and Harpo's latest fumble gave that process an unexpected boost.
 
Harper's poll surges—he's squandered them before—have had two causes, opposition ineptitude, and All Quiet in Ottawa. His iron resolve to listen only to the squeals of gratitude and adulation from the base he's already got makes him deaf to the scuttlebutt from the two out of three voters he needs for majority. And eventually he sticks his foot in some easy to avoid mess and then it ain't quiet anymore.

Any leader with his brains and background could put together a platform that would win such non-con folks over, especially since IggMan and Jacko are so unappealing. But he doesn't. He keeps hammering away at the planks that only the already long-converted believe in, and the RoC has twice rejected, not realizing that sounds more like nails going into his coffin, than into the gallows for the Liberals only he and his toadies care about building.

If he took off his blinders, saw the whole country and actually spoke to it, not at it, he might win enough votes to be a real PM. Another Mackenzie King (which is his ambition after all)

Little danger of that.

Two failed election calls, a hollow Accountabilty act, a meaningless no Fixed Elections law, all the various independent watchdogs done away with, broken promises on deficits, Senate reform (see also electoral reforms promised and undelivered, and see also under that head the In and Out Scam and the Cons suing Elections Canada), getting tough on crime, (as if that works) etc. etc. etc.

Just the same old same old, but more self-righteous and ideological. So the polls go up, and Harpo brings them down.

Anyone care to surmise why he didn't call an election with the polls high? He did before, though he said he never would, 'member? Was he smart then? Or smart now?

Hardly matters, as long as no on's holding their breath unti Harpo actually tries to appeal to all of us.
 
oj,

Harper hasn't wanted to risk an election, even when he's been up in the polls because even though he's got the support at times, it's not "firm" support. David Petersen learned this lesson calling an early election while strongly ahead in the polls, only to discover that that support was very weak and looking for an excuse to slap him.

He knows Iggy is bright and will be an adversary in a debate, and Harper is a fighter, so he's hoping the longer he lasts in govt., the more likely Iggy will give him some ammunition.

Meanwhile, Canadians are stuck with a government that has only been in office a few years, but needs to "recalibrate."
 
Harper hasn't wanted to risk an election, even when he's been up in the polls because even though he's got the support at times, it's not "firm" support.…edit…Meanwhile, Canadians are stuck with a government that has only been in office a few years, but needs to "recalibrate."
Hmm. So why did he call that last election (breaking his word to us in the process)? Wasn't he up in the polls then? And while technically true that his government can count its time just from that election, we all know Harper's been in office coming up to four years. With litle or nothing to show for it but rancour, discord, dumb calls and broken promises and no demonstrable talent for anything but forelock tugging from Ministers and MPs and behind the curtains knife work worthy of dull-normal Rennaissance thugs.

A successful 're-calibration' might restore the Cons to their one-in-three support. What Harper needs to do is calibrate: To match his message and program to the majority of Canadians, not his present and constant rump.
 
I wish that were true, although the EKOS polling seems to indicate Canadians don't care about anything that isn't the flavour of the day.

"However, all is not so bad for the Prime Minister and his team. Mr. Graves’s survey was taken over several days – from Jan. 6 to Jan. 12 – and Tory fortunes were rebounding in the last few days of the poll.
On Jan. 6, the Conservatives were at 28.3 per cent compared to 34 per cent by Jan. 12. Averaged all together, however, the Tories emerge with 30.9 per cent. The Liberals, meanwhile, began on the first day of the poll with 23.6 per cent and ended with 26.6 per cent. Their global total for the poll period was 29.3 per cent."

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/blog...n-harpers-prorogation-mistake/article1431024/

The backlash over Harper's detainee disclosures and his penchant for perpetual prorogation seems to have more staying power than we thought. This is the latest EKOS poll and it shows the Libs in a tie with the CPOC. Haiti hasn't helped Harper. Maybe the Olympics won't help him either.

http://www.ekospolitics.com/index.php/2010/01/liberalsconservatives-in-virtual-tie/

LIBERALS/CONSERVATIVES IN VIRTUAL TIE
“HAITI EFFECT” NOT YET BOOSTING TORIES

[Ottawa – January 21, 2010] - The federal Liberals have pulled into a virtual tie with the Conservatives in the past week – the first time they have drawn so close to the governing party since late summer.

“The Conservative Party has been in decline since mid-October,” said EKOS President Frank Graves. “However, for the first time it is possible to say that the Liberals have also had a rebound – albeit a more modest one.”

The Liberals sunk into the mid-20 percent range in the fall after threatening to force an election. Today’s poll marks the first time since then that they have cracked the thirty per cent mark.

“The Liberals continued to edge upward this week despite Stephen Harper’s adroit response to the disaster in Haiti, which dominated the news, obliterating the vexatious issues of prorogation and the treatment of Afghan detainees,” Graves said. “However, public opinion sometimes lags the news by a few days, and so it will be important to watch whether the trends of the last month or two are sustained in coming weeks.”

The Liberals are staging a comeback at the moment among many of their key regions and demographics. They have regained a modest lead in Ontario, and a larger one in the Atlantic provinces. They are now clearly the strongest federalist party in Quebec.

“One key demographic group to watch as the race between the two major parties tightens are the baby-boomers,” said Graves. “They swung to the Conservatives in the last two elections, especially the most affluent among them. They then defected to the Liberals following the market crash, slowly moved back to the Tories as the markets recovered and the Liberals failed to offer a clear alternative economic plan. Now many are defecting to the Liberals again, apparently unhappy with the Conservatives’ governance style. The Conservatives still lead among this group, but their lead is much less significant than it was.”

The Liberals now have a clear lead among younger voters, though they continue to lag the Conservatives among older voters who have a higher propensity to vote. They have reclaimed a solid lead among university educated voters and among New Canadians – groups they had lost to the Tories during what was a dismal political fall season for the Liberal Party.

The Conservatives retain a narrow lead among men – a demographic group among whom they often lead by a larger margin. The two parties are virtually tied among women, though the Liberals have been on an upward trend in what is for them a traditional bulwark demographic."..

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/blog...ies-on-prorogation-poll-finds/article1438655/

Thursday, January 21, 2010 8:15 AM

Liberals could skate ahead of Tories
on prorogation, poll finds
Jane Taber

1. Prorogation still resonates. Stephen Harper’s decision to shut down Parliament continues to bedevil him, with a new EKOS poll showing Michael Ignatieff’s Liberals are for the first time since late summer in a dead heat with the Conservatives.

Incredibly, too, the latestl EKOS seat projections give the Liberals a three-seat advantage over the Conservatives if an election were held today - 117 to 114. The Tories now have 145 seats compared to 77 for the Liberals, out of a total of 308 seats in the House of Commons. (The new projection distributes the remaining seats as follows: 28 NDP, 47 Bloc, one Green and one Independent.)

This poll shows the Liberal rebound is not simply the result of Tory declines. Rather, EKOS pollster Frank Graves says “for the first time it is clear that the Liberals are actually showing some modest signs of positive lift.”

The Conservatives have 31.5 per cent support compared to 30.9 per cent for the Liberals; the NDP are at 14.9 per cent, the Bloc at 9.1 per cent and the Green Party at 11.5 per cent.

And the hits just keep coming for Michael Ignateiff and his team that had been seen to falter so badly over the summer and fall: For the first time since late summer they have broken through the 30-per-cent mark for voter intention. They had been in the mid-20 per cent range in the fall as a result of their threats to force an election. What is going on?

Mr. Graves says one would have thought the Harper government’s impressive response to the Haitian earthquake disaster would have wiped away any bitterness over the prorogation issue. But he suggests the public is clearly not in a mood to forgive.

“Clearly, the diversion of attention to a pretty well flawless performance on the Haiti crisis to date has not taken the Conservatives out of the penalty box with voters yet,” he told The Globe. “This underscores the depth of public disenchantment.”

And this disenchantment may not soon abate. “If daily images of adroit performance have seen the government’s position with voters continuing to erode (slightly) then how will substituting daily images of cobwebs collecting and crickets chirping in the empty halls of Parliament work out?”
 
Harper won't be helped by Haiti much if it has the appearance of doing it only to get votes. Harper certainly hasn't sounded emotional on the issue; hasn't shown he really cares. It's funny - he's pretty much done well on the issue, but because he fails to do the simple things he doesn't score points. Honestly - it really appears he is more motivated by scoring.

Iggy meanwhile is scoring a few points doing a McGuinty impression - remember how McGuinty laughed off attempts by the PC's to paint him as some kind of evil alient cat eater? His making fun of the attempts made him much more likeable. It showed he has a sense of humour. Iggy laughing at Harper's recalibration is having a small similar impact.

Meanwhile - Harper gives Iggy more ammunition - Harper does a cabinet shuffle - bringing back into the fold his former Environment Minister - the only Environment Minister in Canadian History who's previous job was to lobby the Environemnt Ministry on behalf of oil and gas companies - Ms. Ambrose. Harper is just totally surrounded by a lack of talent. He has no where else to turn.