Prorogation - the fallout

dcbogey

New member
Sep 29, 2004
3,169
0
0
I bet Harper and the CPOC didn't expect this. I hope they use the time out to produce a budget that knocks it out of the park or Harper's turn at the helm of the CPOC may be done.
It's an interesting chart

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/blog...conservative-support-in-polls/article1430143/

Prorogation hammers Conservative support in polls
John Ibbitson

Voter anger over Prime Minister Stephen Harper’s decision to have Parliament prorogued is costing the government heavily in public support.
The Conservatives, who were flirting with majority-government popularity in the fall, are suddenly tied with the Liberals, or headed in that direction, according to two polls released Wednesday.
Although there had been some softening in support before Christmas, it appears that Mr. Harper’s decision on Christmas week to suspend Parliament until March struck a nerve. A word that many had not heard of and few could spell has suddenly become the latest tactically clever move by the Conservatives that turned out to be too clever by half.
 
Isn't it interesting that for several months, the MSM didn't bother publishing polls because Ignatieff was so low. Now that the Liberals have finally shown the slightest signs of life in the polls, the media are all over it.
 
Isn't it interesting that for several months, the MSM didn't bother publishing polls because Ignatieff was so low. Now that the Liberals have finally shown the slightest signs of life in the polls, the media are all over it.

The Liberals have made marginal gains - it's your beloved CPOC that has had the big decline. The next election will give us more of the same and Harper and Iggy will be toast.
 
The Liberals have made marginal gains - it's your beloved CPOC that has had the bid decline. The next election will give us more of the same and Harper and Iggy will be toast.

And then what? Mike fucking Harris? Ben fucking Mulroney?

I'm not an Iggy man, nor am I a Harpo man, but jeeeeezus, if these two guys are who their respective parties thought were "the most electable", what Bertha-Mason-freak-show-meat-puppets are they going to drag down from the attic the next time 'round?

What's Joe Clark up to these days?
 
And then what? Mike fucking Harris? Ben fucking Mulroney?

I'm not an Iggy man, nor am I a Harpo man, but jeeeeezus, if these two guys are who their respective parties thought were "the most electable", what Bertha-Mason-freak-show-meat-puppets are they going to drag down from the attic the next time 'round?

What's Joe Clark up to these days?

You forgot Justin-not-another-Trudeau. Your point is well taken - neither party seems to have the bench strength to deal with seems inevitable. Somehow "Prime Minister Flaherty" doesn't exactly do it for me. :cool:
 
You forgot Justin-not-another-Trudeau. Your point is well taken - neither party seems to have the bench strength to deal with seems inevitable. Somehow "Prime Minister Flaherty" doesn't exactly do it for me. :cool:

My theory is that Harper keeps Flaherty around for job security reasons. By keeping an incompetent boob in the job that is normally seen as a stepping stone to PM he is making it a lot less attractive for his own party to oust him. Had he put someone competent into the Finance job then he'd always have to be looking over his shoulder.

Laugh if you want but that's how many authoritarian leaders in history have behaved, and Harper sure fits the bill as an authoritarian.
 
Yeah, Justin doesn't quite have the same gravitas as papa did, does he? I saw him about 8 years ago leading a mini-entourage at a speech by the Dalai Lama at SkyDome. Trudeau was trying to look important, but on that day, he looked about as politically significant as Ben Mulroney.

Flaherty as PM? There...is...no...god.
 
Yeah, Justin doesn't quite have the same gravitas as papa did, does he? I saw him about 8 years ago leading a mini-entourage at a speech by the Dalai Lama at SkyDome. Trudeau was trying to look important, but on that day, he looked about as politically significant as Ben Mulroney.

Flaherty as PM? There...is...no...god.

' EIGHT YEARS AGO'. He was a newbie politician of the first kind. Gimme a break.
 
For all the slagging of the eminently slagable gritlist, the real point is that Harpo has boobed once again. He's squandering his short-lived popularity numbers by giving up his stated principles (accountability and such) and giving into his baser purposes: hanging onto power so he can entrench the Conservatives as firmly as the Liberals once were.

Too bad his toadies can't see he's just digging a hole to hide in. Too bad he can't see if he actually kept his promises he'd actually keep the voters he needs for the Cons to be a majority rather than a 'not as bad as the other guys' minority.
 
pol numbers are really intertesting , along the same lines as Britney Spears tweets. There is a short term drop because of the news coverage of the prorogation, if anybody diod not think it would happen they need to get the leaded coffee. The actual numbers don't really matter they will change again next week when the PM's swift decisiove action on the Hatian relief issue is polled, followed by the next poll that has Jack LAyton complaining that we don't have enogh wind power in down town toronto, followed by Jaques.... well you probably get the idea.

Polls are deceptive for several reasons
First they are a point in time, by the time the poll is published the numbers have changed one way or the other
Second the question, how its phrased, where and what time it is conducted all skew results.
Third the polling entity has its own reasons and methods for conduction polls, The Globe and Mail has Liberal leanings , the poll was commisioned by them for their purpose, ie selling papers to their audience, I am pretty sure a paper with conservative leanings will publish a poll at the end of the week with different results.

All of the above is a prelude to

The only poll that really matters is an election
 
'The only poll that really matters is an election'.

That's usually the quote from the guy that's holding the short and dirty end of the stick. Careful now.
 
' EIGHT YEARS AGO'. He was a newbie politician of the first kind. Gimme a break.

He was over 30, had already presented himself as a person with great political aspirations, and yet he looked like a kid on a field trip. Even discounting expectations based on his age and lack of experience, he looked out of his depth, and he does not appear to have improved much since then.
 
He was over 30, had already presented himself as a person with great political aspirations, and yet he looked like a kid on a field trip. Even discounting expectations based on his age and lack of experience, he looked out of his depth, and he does not appear to have improved much since then.

Yep and he decided to trade on the family name to get elected. He was less than impressed when the party decided he should run somewhere beside the safe family riding. Apparantly the party is not supposed to hitch a ride on the NAME. The young man needs a whole bunch of seasoning before he decides to run for the party leadership, the question is will the party powers that be give him that time? That name is a very powerful thing in some quarters, particularly quarters where the name is a legend and there are not a lot of people who acutally lived through those times . The lived through those times is meant as an age related aside not in the sense of they were horrible times. Everybody can make their own decision on the period.
 
I think Harper gambled that voter apathy would allow him to prorogue his way out of a problem once again. He'd gotten away with it last time but only because he'd persuaded many Canadians that the coalition's non-confidence vote would be tantamount to a palace coup by traitors, socialists and separatists. Canadians didn't think much of Dion to begin with so they accepted Harper's prorogation excuse almost by default. The GG backed him up and that also helped to legitimize that prorogation as a measure to maintain stable government.

Harper was foolish to think he could justify a second prorogation unless a similar crisis was threatening him. But the only emergency facing Harper during the last session was the mounting evidence that he hadn't cared about the torture of detainees and that he was now doing his utmost to cover his tracks and discredit witnesses who's testimony pointed to his negligence. Harper underestimated Canadians if he really thought we only cared about the economy. With all the military and civilian casualties, the human and financial costs of our Afghan mission, Canadians were not going to just yawn and change the channel if the evidence showed we'd knowingly delivered prisoners to be tortured.

After the furor about prisoner abuse at Gitmo and Abu Ghraib, any suggestion that government negligence contributed to the mistreatment of prisoners was bound to get national attention. Harper saw that the detainee inquiry was quickly spinning out of control but his only remaining option was to prorogue his way out of it. It was a calculated risk but it backfired. This time, the situation did not justify a prorogation so Canadians saw it as an attempt to silence the detainee inquiry. The fact that Harper had boycotted the last couple of inquiry sessions also supports the notion that Harper was desperate to stop the inquiry in its tracks. In an earlier poll, only 23% of Canadians accepted Harper's excuse that he prorogued because he needed time to reclibrate etc. That number may be even lower now that we've had such a sustained backlash.

The more our attention is drawn to this issue, the worse Harper looks. If we accept the allegation that he prorogued to avoid the inquiry, we naturally start to ask how much damage the inquiry would have done if it had been allowed to continue? This is the part that will be most harmful for Harper. It was bad enough that he prorogued our parliament to sabotage a legitimate inquiry and prevent more revelations about detainee abuse. But what was the inquiry about to uncover? What information about the handling of detainees was Harper hiding? These are unavoidable questions that will haunt Harper. He's been getting the benefit of the doubt for his earlier blunders and partisan excesses but those demerit points are still pending. You can't postpone judgement forever and this may be the issue that brings those earlier missteps back into the frame. I wish.
 
^Good analysis. Time will tell, but I would say it is still 2-1 in favour of Harpo still being PM at the end of 2010.

While I would hope otherwise, my inner realist says that enough Canadians either (a) support the torture of Afghan POWs or (b) are at least willing to settle for a marginally plausible denial of culpability (which will only be possible if the detainee inquiry is derailed until summer and then we are preoccupied by a fall election).
 
There will be political capital spent over this they probably knew that going in, they also knew that it would pass, something will come up to change the chanel the olymipcs notably, the earthquake in Haiti has moved alot of people on.

The bottom line is it won't matter, it will be forgotten two weeks after they come back.
 
He was over 30, had already presented himself as a person with great political aspirations, and yet he looked like a kid on a field trip. Even discounting expectations based on his age and lack of experience, he looked out of his depth, and he does not appear to have improved much since then.

I went to high school with two guys that had political aspirations. That doesn't mean much. He had a name a pedigree and some smarts in the outside world but in the blood sport arena of politics, that's almost squat.

BTW, those from school are doing just fine, both federal back benchers, go figure.
 
There will be political capital spent over this they probably knew that going in, they also knew that it would pass, something will come up to change the chanel the olymipcs notably, the earthquake in Haiti has moved alot of people on.

The bottom line is it won't matter, it will be forgotten two weeks after they come back.

That assumes that people completely forget stuff like this. I disagree. Everyone still remembers the first time Harper prorogued to avoid a non-confidence vote and they'll remember this too - just like we still remember the sponsorship scandal and Dion's coalition. Harper has been getting away with quite a lot - mainly because the oppos have been too disorganized, too unpopular and too poor to do anything but scurry around trying to avoid elections. But Harpo won't get this free ride forever. The Libs may still lack popularity but Dion is gone, they are better funded and they can finally start shooting back. With Harpo's extensive and growing rap sheet, the oppos have plenty of ammo. And now that Harpo has dropped to the same level of unpopularity as his main opponent, there is less to fear and more to gain. Iggy may still not be very popular but neither is Harpo. Iggy now has enough money so Harpo's detainee fuck up has given him a second chance. This may not be a clear head shot but it's still a shot. If Iggy can stop making foolish election threats and start talking sense, peoples' memories will improve a lot more than you think.
 
Unfortunatly for the liberals the detainee issue has virtually no traction outside of Ottawa and opposition ranks. The general public just does not care about the mistreatment of " terrorists" who set IEDs to kill Canadians and others. The prorogation will enjd up on the trash heap of political expediency along side the coalition, and JAck LAyton.

These are things that just don't have traction where it matters with the people who vote . Those people are going to want to know how the government is going to spend their money over the next couple of years. That is going to be the major issue going forward.