Property Rights for Canadians

Marcus1027

New member
Feb 5, 2006
921
0
0
How many of you think that we should amend our constitution and have property rights included? At the moment we don't have such rights, and any government can with an order in council take away what's yours. How is it that nobody ever wants to talk about this? I've asked my past MP's and them being Liberals, the party policy was to ignore the issue and change the topic. What are your thoughts on this? How would you like a government come into power who for example, decide that all Blackberries and iPhones are a public menace and are to be banned and confiscated without compensation? We are powerless to do anything about it. Think about it!
 
It would be a useless entry into the constitution anyway. Properties in the US are confiscated or expropriated by various levels of government on a regular basis.

By the way, neither Liberal nor Conservative would want to open that can o'worms anyway. Just because your local rep is a Lib makes no difference. Ask a Con rep in a Con riding and see what answer you get.
 
Last edited:
We have some property rights, but I believe in the greater good of people prevailing over them in some instances. If we need a road, we'll take the land instead of going around your place. If someone wants to use their land as a toxic dump we should be allowed to stop them.
 
How many of you think that we should amend our constitution and have property rights included? At the moment we don't have such rights, and any government can with an order in council take away what's yours. How is it that nobody ever wants to talk about this? I've asked my past MP's and them being Liberals, the party policy was to ignore the issue and change the topic. What are your thoughts on this? How would you like a government come into power who for example, decide that all Blackberries and iPhones are a public menace and are to be banned and confiscated without compensation? We are powerless to do anything about it. Think about it!

We're not exactly powerless. Despite a lack of property rights in the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, there is a wealth of common law precedent that protect Canadians and their property.

Of course, I'm no "law-talking guy" so I might be out to lunch. Let the emotionally-charged Extremely Uninformed Debate begin!!
 
No emotion, no bias just a simple question. It arose out of a conversation with a local politician who's position was government can come in annex and expropriate property under an old obscure law and not have to compensate us for it. That property can be anything, not just land.

My question again is, do you think our ownership of property be decided by the whim of the government of the day? Nobody cares until it affects them, then it's too late.
 
Ok, let's start with FIRST PRINCIPLES. In the beginning all land, water, air, minerals, trees, etc. belong to the CROWN. The CROWN then decides to grant, sell, lease, allow extraction, etc. some of these CROWN assets but retain the right to tax and regulate same assets.

Take the CPR as an example. The CPR was built with private money (mainly British) and private labour (mainly Chinese). However, the CROWN granted ownership of the land on which the tracks were built to the CPR. In addition, the CROWN granted all mineral and other resource rights on, under and above the land to the CPR as well. As time went by, these resources rights were more valuable than the railway tracks as there was oil, trees and minerals of various types which could be extracted and sold to the PRC for billions of dollars.
 
It would be a useless entry into the constitution anyway. Properties in the US are confiscated or expropriated by various levels of government on a regular basis.
A bit of an overstatement. Under Eminent Domain (a.k.a in the U.K known as Compulsory Purchase and in Canada as Expropriation) the taking must be for a public use and just compensation must be paid. Just compensation is by judicial precedent the same as “fair market value." However, unlike in Canada only a few states (and not the Federal Government) allow for business loss and relocation expenses.
 
Don't ask me for citations and links but, apparently, there is an obsure Ontario law that says the landowner does not own the minerial rights under the land. Saw it on W-5 or 5th Estate.
 
Property rights extend beyond just real estate, it also refers to your possessions that you have worked to acquire or things you have inherited.
I'll give one example then i'll say no more. Motorcycles are inherently dangerous, they are the cause of hundreds of deaths and injuries every year. Let's ban the sale of motorcycles, and have current owners turn them over to the crown as forfeit. It sounds outlandish, but the federal government has the power to do so and there is not a damn thing you can do other than turn in your bike without compensation
 
Don't ask me for citations and links but, apparently, there is an obsure Ontario law that says the landowner does not own the minerial rights under the land. Saw it on W-5 or 5th Estate.
Yes, but mineral rights are different from governmental expropriation. But is is a reminder when you purchase real estate to see whether you own the subsurface rights.



By the way here is a mineral rights map of Ontario. http://www.mndmf.gov.on.ca/mines/claimaps_e.asp

I understand that a solid black circle on your property indicates that you own the mineral rights; a half circle means that the Crown or a third party owns them. However, I don't see that.
 
I understand that a solid black circle on your property indicates that you own the mineral rights; a half circle means that the Crown or a third party owns them.

Mine is a red circle with a big X in the middle. What does that mean? Hee, hee, hee.
 
Let's ban the sale of motorcycles, and have current owners turn them over to the crown as forfeit. It sounds outlandish, but the federal government has the power to do so

The federal government also has the right to ban the sale of sexual favours between consenting adults. It sounds outlandish, but the federal government has the power to do so (except on Indian treaty lands).
 
It will be interesting to see the outcome of intellectual property rights concerning the patenting of human genes. Can big pharma really 'own' one of your genes if they are "part of your collective heritage" or they were able to "demonstrate a use for the discovery"?

http://www.genome.gov/19016590
 
Ok, so Joe Terrorist acquires property—land and materiel—and puts it to use to cause great harm to people and the state, or a biker gang is selling crack from their clubhouse thru the slot in the armoured door, and gang-raping teens inside. We put them in jail but their successors, to whom they pass their property, sell it to buy tanks, which they have a right to own, and carry on.

Controlling property ownership and the uses that may legally be made of it—can an owner refusing to sell a shed on a postage stamp lot for any price hold up the building of a military base vital to national security?—have been part and parcel of the rights of the state since forever. That sometimes can involve confiscating without the owner being happy, even if no one else can see why he's not.

The better question is how should the state's right—I believe the term is 'eminent domain' which points out that before your ownership happens, whatever it is, had to be part of the overall state—be limited or fairly exercised. The possibility of doing away with it is fairytales.

Or maybe just ask why the state would have any reason to protect and enforce such a right that a citizen had, and it did not. Since you mentioned 'Canadian' in this rater American topic, let's go back to the purpose of Canada which is to provide, "peace, order and good government'. Again, traditionally that includes protecting your property, and mine by ensuring that means and records of ownership, sale and transfer are established, enforced and maintained. All are serious benefits that flow to individuals, as are the legal requirements that set out how you can be forced, if needs be, to do what we the nation want, with your property. All due to the state acting under laws democratically passed.

Assuming the state's out to get your property unfairly, and imagining a right you expect the state to stand by you and enforce on itself will somehow be better seems folly, and a recipe the make civic life even more dysfunctional.
 
the state's right—I believe the term is 'eminent domain' which points out that before your ownership happens, whatever it is,

First nations??
 
I think the main difference between Canada and the United States is the American constitution restricts the State’s right of what Americans call Eminent domain. In Canada, provincial legislation, also restricts the government’s right of expropriation (what the Americans on the board have been referring to as “eminent domain” and what other English speaking countries often refer to as “compulsory purchase”). The big difference is that unlike provincial governments, the government in the U.S. cannot just pass legislation to override their constitutional protections on property rights. However, American governments can try to get around the restrictions on eminent domain through regulation (however, if they go to far, I believe courts can effectively rule that the regulation is really a ‘taking” but I could be wrong).

As far as mineral rights are concerned, property rights are always a bundle of rights. Most people also don’t own the air rights above their property. E.g. you cannot charge jets flying over your property a toll.
 
First of all, no right is absolute.

And, OP, are you suggesting we add something to provincial legislation like the Canadian Bill of Rights, which guaruntees property rights federally?

I suspect that politician you were speaking to was not well informed.