Proof Canadians Are Stupid

Keebler Elf

The Original Elf
Aug 31, 2001
14,845
507
113
The Keebler Factory
From a Globe & Mail and CTV poll:

http://news.sympatico.msn.ctv.ca/ab...=true&newsitemid=CTVNews/20090116/budget_poll

Out of the 10 choices, a GST cut ranked ninth:

1. invest in infrastructure construction -- especially transit, roads and highways: 54 per cent
2. cut personal income taxes: 39 per cent
3. invest in training programs: 34 per cent
4. make the economy more competitive and productive in the long term: 28 per cent
5. cut federal government spending: 27 per cent
6. ensure private sector pension plans are able to pay out full pensions: 25 per cent
7. provide major financial aid to important sectors such as the auto sector, manufacturing and the forestry sector: 25 per cent
8. increase unemployment benefits : 18 per cent
9. cut the GST by a further percentage point: 11 per cent
10. offer one-time $400 tax rebate: 8 per cent


Sometimes it amazes me how hypocritical we Canadians can be. On the one hand we want all sorts of gov't spending increases, but on the other we want to cut federal spending and taxes. :rolleyes:
 
I wonder what demographics they polled.
 
That's not stupid. That's wanting better value for my tax dollar. I believe that tax cuts should be accompanied by more efficient spending decisions. The federal government is incredibly wasteful, its employees overpaid and lazy, and they keep funding bullshit studies and programs.
 
A GST cut will do diddly-squat to encourage consumer confidence. Economist call it, "pushing on a rope."

Best bet is to put money in the hands of those hard-working men and women who drive the economy forward. Personal income tax cuts - NOT corporate ones, that's been done and it didn't work - combined with infrastructure spending programs are probably the way to go.
 
Hangman said:
That's wanting better value for my tax dollar.

But that's not what they asked for.

Besides, that's the age-old cop out that people make. "I'll pay more taxes when my money is spent better." Of course, that's totally subjective and no one will ever admit that their money is being spent "better". It's just a bullshit way of saying you want a tax cut. Besides, just because something sounds "wasteful" to you doesn't mean it is. There is no requirement to spend your taxes on something you want. Just like there's no requirement that my taxes are spent on something someone else wants.
 
capncrunch said:
A GST cut will do diddly-squat to encourage consumer confidence. Economist call it, "pushing on a rope."

I thought it was called "pissing up a rope".
 
Keebler Elf said:
Sometimes it amazes me how hypocritical we Canadians can be. On the one hand we want all sorts of gov't spending increases, but on the other we want to cut federal spending and taxes.
:confused: It is hard to tell without seeing the actual question but it looks like they asked which of these ten things should be in the budget. If that was the case then a GST cut would have to end up somewhere in the list which it did at the bottom of the choices.
 
Hey - I pay my taxes. I'm not saying "why do I have to pay for education if I'm not a student?"No "cop out" here.
.
I vote for governments that I believe will manage government spending prudently. I understand that some programs may not appear to benefit me directly but do benefit society in general, and that we need to pay for those. I'm familiar with public policy theory of public vs private goods, congestibility, and 'free riders' from my Masters of Public Administration classes.
.
I've also worked for the federal government. Incredibly wasteful and inefficient, with really poor attitudes towards budgets and overspending. That's what bothers me. I want more bang for my buck through improved efficiencies and better accounting practices. Federal workers are grossly overpaid for what they do, have fat pensions that we support, get tons of vacation, and so many sick days that they treat them like secondary vacations. They're in for the minimum hours necessary, and are barely competent when they are in. If a business had the kinds of workers the fed government has, they'd collapse.
.
It's these kinds of systematic inefficiencies that I would like to see reduced, not specific programs (though they could all use a good auditing).
 
Hangman said:
I've also worked for the federal government. Incredibly wasteful and inefficient, with really poor attitudes towards budgets and overspending...
I've done some contract work for a couple of different Federal departments and my experience was entirely different.

I know it goes against popular perception and may not be politically correct, but I actually found that the federal departments I worked for were actually run better, more efficiently and with a tighter control on spending than any of the large financial services firms I worked for.

For instance, in one of the financial services organizations I worked with, a series of projects that had already cost tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars were cancelled with the stroke of a pen and no benefit was realized from them, all to satisfy a director's ego. No review, no cost-benefit analysis, no lessons taken from it. Thousands of dollars and thousands of hours wasted because someone in an office somewhere changed their mind.

You'd never see that in a federal department because individual directors and project leaders don't have that sort of discretion to start or cancel things on their own.

Are there inefficiencies in government departments? Absolutely. Are there employees who are there just for the benefits and who are just putting in time to collect a fat pension? Yes, of course. But, in my experience, those inefficiencies pale in comparison to inefficiencies and colossal waste that goes on in large financial service organizations. It's just that federal departments make for easy targets because of their transparency and the fact that they're paid for with tax dollars. But nobody screams at financial services organizations for waste and ineptitude, mostly because such waste is hidden from public view.

For the record, I was a contract employee only, didn't get any benefits, wasn't part of the union and don't work for the feds anymore.
 
Well, Capncrunch, it's good to hear your experience. Maybe better fiscal controls are in place now. I definitely hope so.

I also think that infrastructure spending will improve the economy, and that some income tax cuts to boost consumer confidence are in order. People also need to do more personal saving so that they can better rely on themselves instead of the government. And when I say infrastructure, I actually mean road, sewer, transit etc projects. Not endless multimillion-dollar pork barrel studies and assessments that make consultants and lawyers rich but don't actually get anyone employed or anything useful built.
 
I have been involved in government projects too and yes, to outside suppliers they ARE very tight with their money and constantly want cost updates and we were told there would be no "extras" at the end.

BUT where the waste comes from is within. For eg: that one MPP who ordered and received and was approved for a new IPOD touch every few months. She also ordered and was approved for numerous other items and she was turning them around and selling them on Ebay.

I also don't know the nuts and bolts of the policy but from what I understand, if you're elected to the federal government, you serve a couple or four years, then you get a lifelong pension (and a pretty damn good one at that).

I also want to point out (locally) again how Mayor Miller is crying poor and instigating new taxes and yet sees NO problem with voting himself a 15% increase. Sure, HE thinks it's not wasteful, but when was the last time any employee received a 15% increase? I mean hell, even the unions aren't getting that!

I also would like to add that age old example of the $500.00 hammer (yeah, it's the US but we aren't that different). From all the procedures, paperwork, cost analysis', and multiple vendors a $25.00 hammer ends up costing the taxpayer $500.00. How is THAT efficient?

Now there have been almost annual reviews of our income tax system/returns and every financial analist goes on to say that the reason revenue canada requires such a large staff if because it is so fricken complicated. They also said that our taxes could actually be cut in half and the feds and provincial governments would still have the same revenues by simplifying the returns/taxation process. They would be able to let go 40% of their staff (which amounts to a huge cost savings).

And finally, if the various governments were so efficient and well run, why do they constantly have budget deficits? It is a widely known fact that if a company was run and managed like our various governments that company would be bankrupt long ago.

As for comparing the government to a large financial institution, the big difference there is if I (a private citizen) don't like the wastefulness of that institution I don't use them. With the various governments I DON'T HAVE A CHOICE and that is the difference.
 
So I have one of these silly little girl questions...

Why does everyone want a GST tax cut? I'm not very informed about economics but it doesn't seem to be that the 1 point difference is going to encourage people to spend. Having to spend an extra penny less per dollar in tax really isn't going to change my mind about purchasing something from my local small business. I'd think the hit in tax revenue, added up across all of Canada accumulatively would be a very large amount.

Why would the government want to lose a large amount of tax revenue and give no little-to-no benefit (in practice 1% doesn't seem to mean that much) to the tax payers?
 
tboy said:
For eg: that one MPP who ordered and received and was approved for a new IPOD touch every few months. She also ordered and was approved for numerous other items and she was turning them around and selling them on Ebay.
Wow. That's fraud. People go to jail for stuff like that.
tboy said:
I also don't know the nuts and bolts of the policy but from what I understand, if you're elected to the federal government, you serve a couple or four years, then you get a lifelong pension (and a pretty damn good one at that).
I think it's six years service at the federal level entitles one to a pension.
tboy said:
And finally, if the various governments were so efficient and well run, why do they constantly have budget deficits? It is a widely known fact that if a company was run and managed like our various governments that company would be bankrupt long ago.
This is an old comparison - "if I ran my business/household like the government, I'd be out of business/thrown in jail" - but it doesn't stand up to scrutiny. Business exists to make money. Households exist (financially speaking) to make life better for their children. Governments exist to provide security and services. Providing security and services costs money and is intended to be available to all citizens regardless of their ability to pay for them.
tboy said:
As for comparing the government to a large financial institution, the big difference there is if I (a private citizen) don't like the wastefulness of that institution I don't use them. With the various governments I DON'T HAVE A CHOICE and that is the difference.
Governments are supposed to be transparent, and, by and large, they are. (There are exceptions, of course, but every penny spent by a government department is scrutinized to within an inch of it's life.) Large institutions are not transparent, so when massive waste occurs you'd never know it anyway.

Don't get me wrong, tboy. I feel your pain. I don't like paying taxes anymore than the next guy, and it pisses me off too when I hear of examples - and they are legion - of my hard-earned money being wasted by government departments at any level. All I'm saying is that governments have legislated controls on their budgets. Large financial institutions have no such controls, and the waste that goes on in them far eclipses the waste that I've personally seen in federal departments (I can't speak for provincial departments because I've never worked for them).
Hiding said:
Why does everyone want a GST tax cut? I'm not very informed about economics but it doesn't seem to be that the 1 point difference is going to encourage people to spend. Having to spend an extra penny less per dollar in tax really isn't going to change my mind about purchasing something from my local small business. I'd think the hit in tax revenue, added up across all of Canada accumulatively would be a very large amount.
This is not a silly little girl question at all; actually, it's very astute.

You're absolutely right, of course. A percentage or two drop in the GST will be almost meaningless to consumers but might add up to a big net loss in federal revenue. Hey, I'm all for a tax reduction as the next Canadian, but let's make it meaningful. Cut the personal tax rate substantially; put real money back in our pockets, not the jingling chump-change that would come out of a GST cut.
 
Hiding said:
So I have one of these silly little girl questions...

Why does everyone want a GST tax cut? I'm not very informed about economics but it doesn't seem to be that the 1 point difference is going to encourage people to spend. Having to spend an extra penny less per dollar in tax really isn't going to change my mind about purchasing something from my local small business. I'd think the hit in tax revenue, added up across all of Canada accumulatively would be a very large amount.

Why would the government want to lose a large amount of tax revenue and give no little-to-no benefit (in practice 1% doesn't seem to mean that much) to the tax payers?

Exactly.

This supposed "savings" is a in your face type political gift, with no real benefits IMO. Now Harpo said that his GST cut would offset the promise he made to cut taxes on gasoline if it went over $1.00 per litre. That's a crock of shit because to offset a 30 cent per litre increase one would have to spent 10 times what the gst is in order to see any difference (in other words, they'd have to spend $30.00 per every litre of gasoline they purchased but the problem was/is, no one could afford to spend that $30.00 because all their money was going to buy gas so they could get to work etc.).

I don't know exactly how it works but Obama stated that a tax cut actually increases government revenues by giving more people money in their pockets to spend on taxable items and to promote business growth which gives the government revenues via corporate taxes and less money going out to things like unemployment etc.

Put it another way: imagine what it would do to the economy if you gave everyone (working age) $3000.00. The vast majority would pay rent (in otherwords stay in a rent paying position as opposed to going into public housing), buy food (revenue returns to the government in taxes, etc), buy clothes and or goods and services (revenue returns to the government in sales taxes etc), and increase consumer spending and hopefully increase revenues to keep some businesses operating thereby giving them continued income tax revenues by more people instead of businesses closing and having people go on unemployment.
 
tboy said:
I don't know exactly how it works but Obama stated that a tax cut actually increases government revenues by giving more people money in their pockets to spend on taxable items and to promote business growth which gives the government revenues via corporate taxes and less money going out to things like unemployment etc.
I'm willing to be wrong on this, but I don't think Obama said this. What you're describing is supply-side economics and a thing called the Laffer curve. Might make for nice theory, but it's long since been discredited.

David Stockman, Reagan-era budget wunderkind who made the idea popular, repudiated it a long time ago. See The Triumph of Politics: Why the Reagan Revolution Failed.
 
Capn:

Fraud/jail: sorry, that one trustee from the catholic school board wasn't and didn't go to jail. Same as the one example I mentioned, they said "they were considering laying criminal charges" but I bet you any amount of money no charges were laid and NO procedures to recoup the lost monies was ever attempted.

Scrutinized expenses: Ahem....NOT. Most of the cases of abuse were discovered by the media, not the auditors via the freedom of information act. In many cases the amounts and expenses were approved even though they were excessive and sort of grey in regards to falling within approved rules.

For eg: I forget which economic summit this was, but there was a case a few years ago where 4 cabinet ministers flew to the summit in Europe each on a separate government jet. They all arrived on the same day. The media got wind of this and said: why couldn't they all fly from ottawa on the same plane ? Sure, it was approved, but was it efficient? NOT.

The point is: just because something is scrutinized and falls within the rules, doesn't make it right. It's kind of like those ads you see on TV for people with healhcare coverage for glasses. They are saying: use your benefit for Dec 31 or lose it (even if you don't need a new pair of glasses).

Kind of like: if you have enough heart meds to last you until next year, get more now and spend the money even if you don't need it. I know many people that do this. They go out and get another pair of glasses and add them to the pile already sitting in their drawer.

The Sun had a great article on the Council member's budgets. There were some who spent 10% of what they are entitled to and another councillor spent 20% more (and was reimbursed for it).

How many times have you worked for a company and the boss comes to you at year end and says: we have to spend x amount of the money left in our budget else we'll lose it next year? I can't tell you how many people I've known who have worked for various government depts and have told me they got that every year......
 
capncrunch said:
I'm willing to be wrong on this, but I don't think Obama said this. What you're describing is supply-side economics and a thing called the Laffer curve. Might make for nice theory, but it's long since been discredited.

David Stockman, Reagan-era budget wunderkind who made the idea popular, repudiated it a long time ago. See The Triumph of Politics: Why the Reagan Revolution Failed.

Actually, it was part of his speech on what he plans to do with bailout money and was discussed on Bill Maher's new show. Obama's mandate is to not just give money to big banks etc, but to start giving money to the people to keep them in their homes, to help them get a home (which would kickstart the building industry again). One of the points brought up was the fairness of it. The opposer said that "what happens when neighbour A who has a job and is making his payments sees neighbour B who wasn't making his payments get a bailout"? Bill came back with "just like with unemployment benefits: the guy who is working and always worked never sees it either...". Which is why I disagree with being paid money for welfare and unemployment, those benefits should be paid to the rental company, coupons for food stores, and a small amount for transportation costs, NOT money to go buy beer.

I cite my experience living by subsidized housing up until I was 18. There used to be a running joke that you don't go to the beer store on (I think it was) every second friday because it would be packed with all the welfare people buying beer with their welfare cheques and cabs lined up 3 deep. My father worked his ass off every day and as a "treat" he'd buy a 12 once every couple of months yet here these people are, who don't work at all, getting a couple of two fours for the weekend party and taking a fricken CAB to get it.
 
tboy said:
How many times have you worked for a company and the boss comes to you at year end and says: we have to spend x amount of the money left in our budget else we'll lose it next year?
Happens all the time. The last two months approaching year-end to one of the financial institutions I worked for were a boon to the organization's IT department, because they were basically given a blank cheque to "buy whatever you need immediately, otherwise your budget will get cut for next fiscal year." I didn't work in the IT department, by the way, but our department was told pretty much the same thing. One would always see new computers, printers, monitors and whatnot in the last month before fiscal year-end.
 
I just remembered a great example: Remember the old CEO of Ontario Hydro?

She got caught not quite embezzling but I think it was misappropriations of funds and was terminated. Well, BFD, she was paid something like $12 Million dollars as part of her package.....
 
Keebler Elf said:
From a Globe & Mail and CTV poll:

http://news.sympatico.msn.ctv.ca/ab...=true&newsitemid=CTVNews/20090116/budget_poll

Out of the 10 choices, a GST cut ranked ninth:

1. invest in infrastructure construction -- especially transit, roads and highways: 54 per cent
2. cut personal income taxes: 39 per cent
3. invest in training programs: 34 per cent
4. make the economy more competitive and productive in the long term: 28 per cent
5. cut federal government spending: 27 per cent
6. ensure private sector pension plans are able to pay out full pensions: 25 per cent
7. provide major financial aid to important sectors such as the auto sector, manufacturing and the forestry sector: 25 per cent
8. increase unemployment benefits : 18 per cent
9. cut the GST by a further percentage point: 11 per cent
10. offer one-time $400 tax rebate: 8 per cent


Sometimes it amazes me how hypocritical we Canadians can be. On the one hand we want all sorts of gov't spending increases, but on the other we want to cut federal spending and taxes. :rolleyes:
it may not be the same people asking for each of these. point five is probably the request of those that vote tory