Private Healthcare

Competition is good for all consumers in the end.

Costs will drop and/or quality will be better (e.g. more coverage with the same price).
 
Canada should follow the German, Swiss and Japanese heath care system where health insurance is mandatory and you can choose to be insured under the public system or choose a private heath insurance company
 
Canada should follow the German, Swiss and Japanese heath care system where health insurance is mandatory and you can choose to be insured under the public system or choose a private heath insurance company
Is the public system in those countries "free"?
 
I have had private healthcare in the GTA for over 20 years. First at the King's Healthcare Centre, subsequently Medisys, and currently the Cleveland Clinic. These "luxury" clinics are usually supplied to executives of large corporations including family members. 2 annual rigorous (5-6 hour) full exams. This includes MD's, Dieticians, Dentistry, Physiotherapists, Ophthalmologist, and a Shrink. All bloodwork etc. is submitted in advance. This ain't no Doctor's office, more like a 5 star hotel. You show up, change into a robe, wait about 5 minutes and then see 6-8 health practitioners during the visit. Afterwards you can have a shower, sauna, hot tub, massage, workout, whatever. A very nice lunch is served as well. Frankly it is outrageously cool. Access to MRI's and other modalities is basically instantaneous. The key advantage is their record keeping. They track all of your vitals for years under one roof and take action to remediate accordingly. BTW the record holder for time on the stress test was/is Mats Sundin. He must have been a real animal in his prime!
 
I go to Medcan clinic through my company. Totally private
Like a spa. No waits.
 
Last edited:
I have had private healthcare in the GTA for over 20 years. First at the King's Healthcare Centre, subsequently Medisys, and currently the Cleveland Clinic. These "luxury" clinics are usually supplied to executives of large corporations including family members. 2 annual rigorous (5-6 hour) full exams. This includes MD's, Dieticians, Dentistry, Physiotherapists, Ophthalmologist, and a Shrink. All bloodwork etc. is submitted in advance. This ain't no Doctor's office, more like a 5 star hotel. You show up, change into a robe, wait about 5 minutes and then see 6-8 health practitioners during the visit. Afterwards you can have a shower, sauna, hot tub, massage, workout, whatever. A very nice lunch is served as well. Frankly it is outrageously cool. Access to MRI's and other modalities is basically instantaneous. The key advantage is their record keeping. They track all of your vitals for years under one roof and take action to remediate accordingly. BTW the record holder for time on the stress test was/is Mats Sundin. He must have been a real animal in his prime!

Was about to post essentially this too. There is already private healthcare in Canada. The average person just doesn't know about it. Kinda like Terb.
 
Was about to post essentially this too. There is already private healthcare in Canada. The average person just doesn't know about it. Kinda like Terb.

I knew about Medcan but had no idea Cleveland Clinic was operating in Toronto. They are one of the top healthcare facilities in the US. Despite being private these clinics still have to bill under OHIP for services rendered to patients.
 
Despite being private these clinics still have to bill under OHIP for services rendered to patients.
Does "private" in this case mean they can choose who they accept as a patient. I know that some people in Canada do have access to faster and better health care than ordinary citizens. For example, a Maple Leaf hockey player can get an MRI on the same day instead of waiting 4 months or longer.
 
The current 70/30 split public/private for Canada is fine as it is. Australia went 50/50 and it was a financial disaster, too many private clinics went on the public trough which caused a deterioration in health care all around.
 
I didn't read the article,but private health care in Canada isn't illegal.
It is probably illegal. Otherwise, there wouldn't be a trial.

Many rich Canadians (including at least one member of the Board) go to the U.S. for healthcare.
 
Health care in Canada is a provincial matter. The laws and regulations governing private healthcare and private insurance vary from province to province. The case referred to in the article cited by the OP is a British Columbia case.

In Quebec private healthcare is 100% legal; private insurance for procedures covered by medicare was not legal (this was the basis of the Chaoilli case). According to the referenced article, in BC neither private care nor private insurance is illegal. It appears to be illegal for physicians to bill publicly insured patients directly for procedures and care covered by BC public insurance.
 
It is probably illegal. Otherwise, there wouldn't be a trial.

Many rich Canadians (including at least one member of the Board) go to the U.S. for healthcare.

So were do all those Vancouver NHL players get their MRI and Xray's so fast?Highly doubt they get sent over to Washington State.
 
http://vancouversun.com/health/loca...e-health-care-could-reshape-canadian-medicare

Should Canadian citizens and residents be legally entitled to seek private health care in Canada or should it continue to be illegal?

All doctors offices in Canada and most clinics are private.

There compete with each other for patients and they run their operations efficiently as possible to lower costs.

Canada has a single payer healthcare system, not a fully public system.
 
http://vancouversun.com/health/loca...e-health-care-could-reshape-canadian-medicare

Should Canadian citizens and residents be legally entitled to seek private health care in Canada or should it continue to be illegal?

Canada has long been a nanny state. Significant changes to the Canada Health Act which would allow private health care could lead to physicians giving priority to paying patients over the non paying population creating further delays, backlogs and inefficiency to the general non paying population. Scenarios could arise where physicians cluster around areas where there are paying patients and neglect other areas. The nanny state would not tolerate this. A good portion of the Canadian medical schools tuition is heavily subsidized by the tax payer. Those doctors who are trained in Canada but want to see private patients only should be made to pay the full tuition without any government subsidization. The BC doctor's actions are illegal in that he bills the province and collects from the private health care plan.
 
Aside from occasional doctor check ups, I think the only time I've used a hospital is when I was born. So for now, all the $$$ I've paid to medical care has done basically nothing for me.

Never the less, I'm fine and all with this kind of route, but one thing that would solve many of the backlogs and "OK, we have an opening to see you..... in 4 weeks" is if the system somehow billed patients for wasting the doc's time. I have no doubt that the the times I sat there waiting to get a regular check up, I bet some of these people seeing the doc are going because it's free and the illness is either zero or a simple cold. People waiting in the lobby have more serious things to check up on.

By billing a patient for a nonsense appointment would surely crack down on people who know better, and trying to milk the system or take a day off work for nothing.
 
@FUJI go back to your cubicle, you are not a Player, you are a wannabe who knows zero about this topic (and many others) so stfu. Bottom line is if you are a person of position or have proper cash, private healthcare is absolutely available here. @KDouglas link below. @SkyRider you are correct and let me tell you when you get something dealt with in a U.S. clinic they really do make you feel like a client not a FUJI. For cosmetic items, Mexico rocks big time.

http://my.clevelandclinic.org/canada
 
@FUJI go back to your cubicle, you are not a Player, you are a wannabe who knows zero about this topic (and many others) so stfu. Bottom line is if you are a person of position or have proper cash, private healthcare is absolutely available here. @KDouglas link below. @SkyRider you are correct and let me tell you when you get something dealt with in a U.S. clinic they really do make you feel like a client not a FUJI. For cosmetic items, Mexico rocks big time.

http://my.clevelandclinic.org/canada

And yet my post was accurate. All doctors offices in Canada are private. What is regulated are the prices charged for OHIP covered services.